Who is this guide for?

Choir archive manager

Keeps recordings and complete project folders from several performances and mainly needs plenty of space and a separate copy that is easy to locate. The Library of Congress recommends keeping copies on different storage media and in separate physical locations.

Volunteer transferring files

Takes projects between locations or computers and needs to consider the drive’s power supply, connection and formatting.

Editor working with large recordings

Regularly transfers large sessions or works from external storage. The advertised speed needs to suit the USB connection on the computer being used, as well as the capacity required.

What should you look for?

Start by deciding where the archive will be kept, then consider how often you’ll take files with you or edit them.

Desktop HDD

Choose this if: the archive will stay in one place and capacity is your priority.

Bear in mind: a desktop model may need a power adapter and is less convenient to carry around.

Portable HDD

Choose this if: you want to take project folders with you without using a separate power adapter.

Bear in mind: capacity and formatting vary by model, so check these before copying files.

Portable SSD

Choose this if: you regularly transfer large folders or edit files from external storage.

Bear in mind: manufacturers’ stated speeds depend on the computer, connection and conditions.

What to consider What to check before buying Who does this matter most to?
Space for project folders Add up the space used by your current folders and versions, then decide how much room to allow for future recordings. Compare this with the capacity of the exact model. If I want to keep every version of a performance, I want to know in advance whether the capacity will also leave room for future recordings. Around 36% of consumers give top priority to space for a growing archive.
Preserving recordings Plan to keep copies on at least two different storage media and in separate physical locations; the Library of Congress recommends this approach for digital preservation. For recordings that identify people, agree on suitable access controls based on the risks, as advised by the Dutch Data Protection Authority. If the recording needs to be available later, I don’t want to rely on a single drive or storage location. Around 29% of consumers prioritise keeping a separate copy.
Taking files with you and transferring them Check that the power supply and connections work with the computers you use. For an SSD, compare its stated speed with the computer’s USB connection and the capacity you need. When I take folders between the rehearsal room and editing computer, power, connection and transfer speed all matter. Around 21% of consumers put portability and transfer speed at the top of their list.
Opening files on different computers Check the operating systems and intended use before formatting. Apple says ExFAT is compatible with Windows; for a Mac drive used for Time Machine, Apple recommends APFS or APFS Encrypted. Reformatting can erase existing files. If volunteers use Windows and Mac, I want to know whether everyone can open the folders and whether formatting is needed. Around 14% of consumers give computer compatibility top priority.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming a large drive is a complete backup strategy

    Even a drive with plenty of space is still one storage medium in one location. If it fails or goes missing, you could lose the only copy of the recording.

    Keep separate copies and check that you can open the project folders on them. The Library of Congress recommends using different storage media and separate physical locations.

  • Filling a Windows-formatted HDD before deciding how you’ll use it with a Mac

    The Toshiba Canvio Basics mentioned here is supplied as an NTFS drive for Windows. Toshiba says it needs to be reformatted for the macOS versions listed; formatting can erase existing content.

    First decide which computers and backup tasks the drive needs to support. Move your files somewhere safe before changing the formatting.

    Moving files safely and reformatting a drive takes time.

  • Assuming an SSD’s maximum speed applies to every choir transfer

    Crucial says the X9’s stated speed depends on using suitable equipment and a suitable cable; performance may vary. So its maximum stated speed is no guarantee of how quickly every project folder will transfer.

    Check the connections on the computers you use and compare them with the requirements for the speed you want.

  • Enabling password protection without agreeing how access will be managed

    Western Digital says its technical support team cannot recover a forgotten WD Security password, and your data may become inaccessible.

    Agree within the choir who will manage access, and make sure important files are also kept in a separate location.

Brands to compare

Seagate

The Expansion desktop range is designed for an archive kept in one place.

  • Seagate lists capacities of up to 28 TB for the range; this does not apply to every model.
  • Seagate says the drive connects via a power adapter, so you’ll need a mains socket.

Toshiba

Canvio Basics is a portable HDD range for transferring projects.

  • Toshiba says the EMEA range consulted goes up to 4 TB and is powered via USB.
  • The drive comes formatted as NTFS for Windows. Toshiba says it needs to be reformatted for the macOS versions listed; check the exact model.

Western Digital

My Passport is a portable HDD range with models offering extra archive space.

  • The manufacturer’s specification sheet lists models including 5 TB and 6 TB versions, with password protection and hardware encryption.
  • Check the exact model and agree how passwords will be managed. Western Digital warns that forgetting a WD Security password can mean losing access to your data.

Samsung

The T7 Shield is a portable SSD range for transferring or editing files.

  • For the Dutch 2TB model, Samsung states sequential read and write speeds of up to 1.050/1.000 MB/s and IP65 protection.
  • These are manufacturer specifications, not measured speeds for choir files, and they are no substitute for keeping a separate copy.

Crucial

The X9 is a compact USB-C SSD range for transfers between compatible devices.

  • Crucial states a maximum read speed of 1.050 MB/s and models with capacities of up to 4 TB.
  • Crucial says performance and compatibility depend on the equipment and formatting. A stated drop rating is not a general guarantee that data will survive every fall.

Joybuy product picks

These product picks focus on portable HDDs and SSDs for taking choir project folders with you or transferring them. Compare the capacity with the size of your archive, and keep recordings on a separate copy as well.

SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB

SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB

Handy for taking and transferring project files, provided the computer you’re using supports the speed you want.

The product name lists 1 TB. The product description mentions USB-C and read speeds of up to 2.000 MB/s; reaching this maximum speed requires a compatible USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 host, and write speeds are lower.

View on Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport 6TB White

Western Digital My Passport 6TB White

A portable HDD for taking project files with you on a drive.

The product description lists 6 TB, password protection and 256-bit AES hardware encryption. Agree who will manage the password; forgetting a WD Security password could mean losing access to your data.

View on Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport USB-C 4TB Black

Western Digital My Passport USB-C 4TB Black

A good fit for taking project folders between computers that work with this model.

The product description lists 4 TB, exFAT, USB-C and USB bus power, as well as compatibility with the Windows and macOS versions specified.

View on Joybuy
Samsung MU-PE1T0S 1TB USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 Black

Samsung MU-PE1T0S 1TB USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 Black

A portable SSD for project files that you regularly take with you or transfer.

The product description lists 1 TB and USB 3.2 Gen 2, with sequential speeds of up to 1.050/1.000 MB/s. It also mentions IP65 protection and drop protection from up to 3 metres; the water protection is designed for temporary exposure, not prolonged immersion.

View on Joybuy
Samsung MU-PG2T0B 2TB USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2x2 Black

Samsung MU-PG2T0B 2TB USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2x2 Black

Suitable for taking and transferring large project folders, as long as the capacity and connection are compatible with your computers.

The product description lists 2 TB, read speeds of up to 2.000 MB/s and write speeds of up to 1.950 MB/s via USB 3.2 Gen 2x2. USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables are included.

View on Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is one external drive enough for the final choir archive?

No, not if it’s the only copy. For digital preservation, the Library of Congress recommends keeping copies on at least two different storage media and in separate physical locations. Also check that you can read the files you’ve saved.

Which format should you choose if volunteers use Windows and Mac?

It depends on the computers and how the drive will be used. Apple says ExFAT is compatible with Windows; for a drive used specifically for Mac Time Machine, Apple recommends APFS or APFS Encrypted. Reformatting can erase existing files, so check the process before copying anything.

What can you expect from the seller if a drive develops a fault?

For consumer purchases in the Netherlands, statutory guarantees apply alongside any manufacturer’s warranty. If a product does not meet reasonable expectations under normal use, the seller must offer an appropriate remedy free of charge, according to ACM ConsuWijzer. If you’re buying on behalf of an association, check which terms and rights apply to that buyer.

Can the choir keep or share identifiable recordings indefinitely on an unprotected drive?

Don’t assume that identifiable recordings can be kept or shared freely. The Dutch Data Protection Authority considers identifiable audio recordings to be personal data and says organisations should determine appropriate security measures based on the risks. Under the GDPR, you need a valid reason to share recordings with others; the appropriate legal basis, retention period and measures depend on how the data is processed.