Choir archivist
You keep the original takes locally and want to avoid making the archive entirely dependent on a single drive. Seagate recommends keeping multiple copies of important files on different storage media.
For a choir archive that will mostly sit in one place, choose an external HDD if having room for future recordings is your priority. An SSD is a better fit if you regularly take files with you or transfer them. Always keep a separate local copy, check that the drive works with the computers you use, and arrange suitable access controls if choir members can be identified in the recordings.
You keep the original takes locally and want to avoid making the archive entirely dependent on a single drive. Seagate recommends keeping multiple copies of important files on different storage media.
You leave room for several sessions and want to be able to find and share files between the computers used by the choir. The Consumentenbond highlights capacity and connections as important considerations when choosing an external drive.
You take files elsewhere to edit them and weigh up transfer speeds, connections and protection on the move. Samsung and Kingston describe portable SSD models with different connection and casing features.
Start by deciding where your backup will be kept and how many future recordings you need to accommodate. Then choose between an HDD and an SSD based on how often you move files.
| What to consider | What to look for when buying | Who should pay more attention to this? |
|---|---|---|
| A copy alongside the archive | Plan where the original take and a separate local copy will be kept; test that you can read files from the copy. | I don’t want a drive failure or loss to take out my only copy of a recording too. Around 40% of consumers prioritise preventing data loss. |
| Room for future sessions | Add up your current files and leave space for planned takes and copies; check the capacity of the exact model. | I want to keep several choir sessions without having to reorganise my archive each time. Around 30% of consumers prioritise archive capacity. |
| Access to identifiable recordings | Assess the privacy risks and check the security features of the exact drive, as well as your access arrangements. | If choir members can be identified, I want to know who can open the files and how a future administrator will retain access. Around 20% of consumers prioritise access security. |
| Sharing files between computers | Check the ports and operating systems on the computers involved; copy any existing files before formatting. | I regularly move takes between recording, editing and archive computers and want to be able to open them on each system. Around 10% of consumers prioritise sharing files on the move. |
An HDD is an option if storage capacity matters more than transferring files often; the Consumentenbond and Western Digital describe HDDs as a storage-focused choice. An SSD is a better fit if you regularly take files with you or transfer them. Manufacturers’ stated speeds are not a measure of performance for this choir workflow and depend on using a suitable connection.
According to the Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens, an identifiable audio recording may constitute personal data. If the choir processes such recordings, it must consider appropriate security and a suitable legal basis under the GDPR; password protection on a drive does not remove the need for arrangements covering access and retention.
If the drive is lost or fails, the recording could be lost too. A drive is not a backup of itself.
Plan to use a second local storage device and allow time to manage it and periodically check that you can read the copy.
Arrange the separate copy when you set up the archive drive, then test that you can open files from it.
The stated speed is a manufacturer’s maximum. Kingston says that you need a USB 3.2 Gen 2 host to achieve the optimum speed of the XS1000.
Check the ports on your recording and editing computers, and consider whether you move files often enough for speed to be a priority.
Formatting erases files already on the drive. A new file system won’t prevent that loss.
Set aside time to make and check a copy first.
First make a readable copy, then choose the file system you need.
Expansion Portable is a range of USB-powered HDDs for local storage. Check the capacity of the model you choose.
The T7 is an external SSD; the T7 Shield is a different model with a more robust casing.
The XS1000 is a compact external SSD range; the 2TB version has part number SXS1000/2000G.
Western Digital describes HDDs as an option for storage and archives, and SSDs as an option for faster active use.
These products are external HDDs and portable SSDs for storing choir recordings locally without the cloud.
No image available
Suitable for local storage if you need space for several recordings.
6 TB storage; the product description states that it has password protection with 256-bit AES hardware encryption.
No image available
A local HDD option if you want to store recordings on an external drive.
4 TB storage; the product description states that it has password protection with 256-bit AES hardware encryption.
No image available
A suitable choice if you’re looking for a local archive drive and the listed USB-C connection works with your computer.
4 TB storage; the product description lists exFAT and compatibility with Windows and Mac, as well as password protection with 256-bit AES hardware encryption.
No image available
A portable SSD option if you regularly take a take with you and your devices support USB-C.
1 TB storage and USB-C; the product name lists USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 and a stated transfer speed of up to 2000 MB/s.
No image available
A suitable choice if you want a local SSD and use files across Windows and Mac computers.
2 TB storage; the product description states that it has AES 256-bit hardware encryption and includes USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables.
Keep the take on a locally connected drive and also maintain a separate local copy on another storage device. Regularly check that you can open files from that copy. This reduces your reliance on a single drive, but does not guarantee against data loss.
Yes, as long as the file system and connection work with both computers. Apple recommends ExFAT for an external drive larger than 32 GB that will be used with Windows and Mac. Formatting erases any files already on the drive, so make a copy first.
That cannot be determined without further information: according to the Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens, a recording in which people can be identified may constitute personal data. An organisation must consider an appropriate legal basis under the GDPR and suitable security. Consent is one possible legal basis, but is not automatically required. The right assessment depends on the recording, its purpose and the people involved.
If the recording contains personal data, the choir must not keep it for longer than necessary for the stated purpose, according to the Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens. The appropriate retention period therefore depends on an assessment of that purpose.
No. A manufacturer’s warranty is not a backup of your recording. The Dutch government explains that statutory warranty in the Netherlands has no fixed time limit, and that you should contact the seller if a product is faulty. So make sure you keep a separate copy of the archive.