Who is this guide for?

Manager of large project archives

You want to keep complete project folders and choose your drive capacity based on the files you actually need to restore. The National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping backups on multiple media and in multiple locations.

Manager of frequently updated spreadsheets

You want to keep more than just the latest copy, so you can restore an earlier version if a file is changed or deleted. Microsoft Support explains how File History can restore earlier versions when the right folders are included.

Mobile project worker

You take large folders with you or copy them between computers. That means the connection and transfer-speed requirements are important factors in your choice.

What should you look for when buying?

Desktop HDD

A good fit if: you back up large project archives from a fixed workstation and have a power socket available.

Consider: the Seagate Expansion Desktop we reviewed needs a power adapter as well as USB, making it less convenient to take with you regularly.

Portable HDD

A good fit if: you copy folders periodically and want to unplug and put the drive away afterwards, without a separate power adapter.

Consider: check the cable and formatting. Toshiba specifies NTFS as the Windows file system for the Canvio Basics USB-C and says reformatting is required for macOS.

Portable SSD

A good fit if: you regularly move large project folders between workstations and your computer supports the required connection.

Consider: manufacturers' stated maximum speeds are no guarantee of your backup speed. An SSD also doesn't replace a separate, tested copy.

Before choosing a drive type, decide which files and earlier versions you want to be able to restore. Then compare capacity, connection and formatting.

Buying consideration What to look for Who should consider this most?
Space for project folders Count the folders and spreadsheets you want to keep, and allow for your version history. For Time Machine, Apple recommends a storage capacity of at least twice that of your Mac. If I want to be able to restore complete project folders, I choose capacity based on my files and backup method; around 36% of consumers are most concerned about having enough space.
Earlier spreadsheet versions Check that your backup method includes the right folders and that you can restore both a spreadsheet and a project folder. Microsoft Support explains how to restore versions using File History; the National Cyber Security Centre advises testing your backups. If I might need an earlier version after a spreadsheet has been overwritten, I look for version recovery; around 29% of consumers say this is their main buying consideration.
Taking and copying folders with you Check the USB ports and cable against your computers. The Seagate Expansion Portable we reviewed is powered via USB; the Toshiba Canvio Basics USB-C comes with a USB-C cable. If I move large folders between workstations, I weigh portability and connection against my storage needs; around 21% of consumers focus mainly on this type of use.
Access to confidential files Consider what data is stored on the drive, who can access it and whether you should enable encryption. The Dutch Data Protection Authority emphasises the need for appropriate security when an organisation processes personal data. For backups containing confidential records, I want to be able to restrict access and keep a recovery key safe; around 14% of consumers say this is their main buying consideration.

Common pitfalls

  • Confusing the latest copy with version recovery

    A current copy won't help if you need an earlier spreadsheet version. Version recovery only works if the relevant files are included in the backup.

    Include the right folders in your backup method and test restoring both a spreadsheet and a project file. Microsoft Support explains how to select folders for File History; the National Cyber Security Centre advises testing backups.

  • Treating one connected drive as a complete backup

    If your only copy is on a single connected drive, an incident could affect that backup too. The National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping important data on multiple media and in multiple locations.

    Alongside your chosen external drive, keep a separate copy and check that you can restore files from it.

  • Formatting a Windows drive without securing its contents

    Apple notes that reformatting a drive for Time Machine can permanently erase existing data.

    Before formatting, check which drive you have selected and save any existing files somewhere else first.

  • Assuming an SSD's maximum speed is your backup speed

    The stated maximum speed is no guarantee of the transfer speed you'll get from your computer. Crucial's maximum speed for the X9 Pro is based on test conditions and requires a suitable USB 3.2 Gen 2 host and USB-C cable.

    Check that the drive, cable and computer port are compatible before making speed the deciding factor in your purchase.

Relevant brands and product ranges

Seagate

The Expansion Portable and Expansion Desktop offer a portable HDD and a model for a fixed backup location.

  • According to the product specifications, the 4TB Expansion Portable STKM4000400 is USB-powered; the 4TB Expansion Desktop STKP4000400 needs a power adapter.
  • Seagate warns that Rescue Data Recovery Services aren't available in every country. Check availability for the specific model before factoring in this service.

Toshiba

The Canvio Basics USB-C is a portable HDD option for USB-C backups.

  • For the 4TB model HDTB440EKCCA, Toshiba specifies USB power and an included cable.
  • Toshiba lists NTFS as the Windows file system; according to the manufacturer, reformatting is required for macOS.

Samsung

The Portable SSD T7 Shield is a portable SSD range for moving project folders.

  • For the 4TB model MU-PE4T0S/EU, Samsung Netherlands lists USB 3.2 Gen 2 and maximum sequential read and write speeds of 1,050 and 1,000 MB/s respectively.
  • These are maximum speeds stated by Samsung, not independently measured speeds for your spreadsheet backup.

Crucial

The X9 Pro is a portable SSD where the host connection and formatting are important considerations.

  • For the X9 Pro 4TB CT4000X9PROSSD9, Crucial lists a maximum speed of 1,050 MB/s under its own test conditions and exFAT formatting out of the box.
  • According to Crucial, achieving the stated top speed requires a suitable USB 3.2 Gen 2 host and USB-C cable. Reformatting erases existing data.

Joybuy products

The Joybuy options below are portable SSDs and HDDs for project and spreadsheet backups. Check that the stated capacity is suitable for your full folders and the version history you need.

SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

Could be a good fit if your project and spreadsheet files fit within 1 TB and you want a portable SSD to take with you.

1 TB; USB-C and USB 3.2 Gen 2; stated read speed of up to 1,000 MB/s.

A stated maximum is no guarantee of your backup speed; check that the connection is compatible with your computer.

Joybuy
SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB

SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB

Could be a good fit if your project files fit within 1 TB and you're looking for a portable SSD with USB-C.

1 TB; USB-C; stated read speed of up to 2,000 MB/s.

Check your computer's connection; the stated maximum speed doesn't guarantee the same speed for your backup.

Joybuy
My Passport for Mac 2TB Blue portable hard drive

My Passport for Mac 2TB Blue

Could suit portable Mac backups if 2 TB is right for your files and backup method; the product description says it works with Time Machine.

2 TB; USB 3.0; USB-C adapter included according to the product description.

Check the formatting before setting up the drive for Time Machine; reformatting may erase existing data.

Joybuy
My Passport 2TB Red portable hard drive

My Passport 2TB Red

Could be a good fit if your documents and project files fit within 2 TB and you want a portable HDD to take with you.

2 TB; USB 3.2 Gen 1; USB-powered. The product description mentions password protection and 256-bit AES hardware encryption.

Check how to set up and maintain the security features; a product feature alone doesn't provide a tested, restorable backup.

Joybuy
Toshiba Canvas Basics 1TB Black 2.5-inch portable hard drive

Toshiba Canvas Basics 1TB Black 2.5"

Could suit regular backups if the selected files fit within 1 TB and you're looking for a portable HDD.

1 TB; USB 3.2 Gen 1; powered via a single USB cable according to the product description.

Check that the connection is compatible with your computer and that the formatting suits your backup method.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How can I make sure I can restore an earlier version of a spreadsheet?

Use a backup method that keeps versions and includes the folder containing your spreadsheet. Microsoft Support explains that Windows File History can restore earlier versions when the relevant folders are included. Then test that you can restore a file.

Can a drive formatted for Windows be used straight away as a Time Machine drive?

Not without checking the formatting and possibly changing it. Apple explains that reformatting a drive for Time Machine can erase existing data, so save those files somewhere else first.

Does a desktop HDD need a separate power adapter?

It depends on the model. The Seagate Expansion Desktop we reviewed needs a power adapter, while the Expansion Portable we reviewed is powered via USB. Check the specifications of the exact model you're considering.

Is encryption required for every external backup drive in the Netherlands?

The information consulted does not support a general requirement for every external drive. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says that organisations must protect personal data properly; the appropriate measures depend on how the data is processed. Encryption may be a security measure for confidential files.

Must an organisation always report the loss of a drive containing personal data?

Not automatically. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, an organisation must assess the circumstances and risks to the people affected. Whether a report to the Dutch Data Protection Authority is required depends on that assessment; the rules on informing the people affected depend, among other things, on the likelihood of a high risk.