Who should consider this choice?

Manager of a growing recordings archive

Wants to keep recordings and related files easy to find. Taking stock of the collection and setting up a verifiable backup routine will help you work out how much space you need. Netwerk Digitaal Erfgoed and the National Cyber Security Centre offer practical guidance on preservation and backups.

Volunteer transferring recordings

Copies files between workstations, so needs to consider connections, file systems and transport, as well as whether the receiving computer can read the files. Samsung and Crucial outline connection, host device and file system requirements for specific SSD models.

Manager handling identifiable voices

Needs to decide not only how to store recordings, but also who may receive them and what safeguards are appropriate when handling identifiable people. The Dutch Data Protection Authority explains that identifiable audio recordings may be personal data and that organisations must protect personal data appropriately.

What should you look for in an archive drive?

Portable HDD

A good fit when: the copy will mainly stay in one place and capacity is important. First, work out the size of the collection and how much it is expected to grow.

Keep in mind: an HDD is more vulnerable to knocks. The Consumers’ Association noted this difference in its 2022 buying guide.

Portable SSD

A good fit when: volunteers regularly take the copy between locations or transfer files, provided there’s enough capacity.

Keep in mind: advertised speeds depend on factors such as the host device and cable. They don’t guarantee the speed you’ll get on the archive’s computers.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who should give this more weight?
Verifiable copies Decide where the original and separate copies will be kept. Check files after transferring them, then repeat the checks regularly. I want to be able to check that files are intact after copying them and find them again later. Around 33% of consumers choosing a drive for this archive prioritise recoverability.
Room to grow Measure the current collection and decide what additions the copy needs to include. Compare this with the capacity of the exact model. I want the catalogued collection and planned additions to fit on the drive. Around 27% of consumers focus mainly on storage capacity when choosing.
Transferring files between computers Check the ports and cables at both workstations, then test the file system with a non-unique copy before transferring archive files. I want to be able to open the copy on the computers involved without first altering unique archive files. Around 20% of consumers prioritise being able to transfer files between computers successfully.
Protecting identifiable voices Consider who needs access and whether the security features will work on the computers you use. Password protection does not replace a lawful basis under the GDPR. I want to know who can and may access recordings featuring identifiable people. Around 20% of consumers prioritise appropriate access security when choosing.

Common pitfalls when copying recordings

  • Treating one drive as a complete archive

    A single storage device cannot, on its own, guarantee that recordings will remain available and intact.

    Set up a copy plan and check files after transferring them, then repeat the checks regularly. Netwerk Digitaal Erfgoed recommends using checksums to check backups, while the National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping multiple versions of important files.

  • Choosing an HDD for frequent transport without considering knocks

    An HDD has moving parts. In its 2022 buying guide, the Consumers’ Association described HDDs as more vulnerable to knocks than SSDs.

    Balance capacity against how often you’ll carry the drive, and keep a separate copy regardless of the type of drive you choose.

  • Assuming the manufacturer’s maximum is your own transfer speed

    For specific SSD models, the advertised speed depends in part on the host device and cable.

    Check the connections at both workstations before letting speed determine your choice.

  • Confusing password protection with permission to share recordings

    Technical security does not answer the separate question of whether identifiable recordings may be processed or shared, or the lawful basis for doing so.

    Record who needs access and assess the processing of identifiable people separately. The Dutch Data Protection Authority treats lawful basis and security as separate considerations.

Brands to compare

Western Digital

The My Passport range includes portable HDDs. Western Digital lists a capacity of 4 TB for the black WDBPKJ0040BBK-WESN model.

  • Western Digital lists password protection and hardware encryption for the range.
  • An HDD is more vulnerable to knocks. Check how security and software work on the archive’s computers for the exact model.

Samsung

The portable T7 Shield SSD is available in a black 2 TB model, MU-PE2T0S/EU, according to Samsung Netherlands.

  • Samsung lists USB 3.2 Gen 2 and maximum sequential read and write speeds of 1.050 and 1.000 MB/s respectively.
  • These are maximum speeds quoted under specific conditions. They don’t guarantee a particular transfer speed or data retention.

Seagate

Expansion Portable is a range of portable HDDs. Seagate’s product sheet identifies STKM2000400 as the black 2 TB model.

  • Seagate says this model is powered via the USB cable.
  • The product sheet is dated © 2021. Check the model and included services; any stated data recovery service is not available in every country.

Crucial

The X9 Pro is a portable SSD. The model described, CT2000X9PROSSD9, has a capacity of 2 TB.

  • Crucial lists exFAT as the file system supplied with the drive.
  • The top advertised speed depends on the host device and cable. Crucial warns that reformatting erases the data on the drive.

SanDisk

The Extreme Portable SSD (V3), model SDSSDE70-2T00-G25, is a 2 TB portable SSD model.

  • SanDisk lists a maximum sequential read speed of up to 2.000 MB/s for this model.
  • This is a manufacturer’s maximum, not a verified speed on the archive’s computers or proof of better archive preservation.

Joybuy product picks

These portable SSDs and HDDs are options to compare for transferring and storing audio recordings. Choose based on your catalogued collection, the computers you want to use the copy on and how often you’ll carry the drive.

SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

A portable SSD option for transferring and carrying files between workstations.

The product description lists 1 TB of storage, USB-C and read speeds of up to 800 MB/s. It also mentions drop protection from heights of up to 2 metres.

Joybuy
SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB

SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB

A portable SSD option if you carry files with you and need access security.

The product description lists 1 TB of storage, USB-C, password protection with 256-bit AES hardware encryption and a weight of 46,9 g. According to the description, maximum read speed requires a compatible USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 host; write speed is lower.

Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport for Mac 2TB Blue

Western Digital My Passport for Mac 2TB Blue

A portable HDD option for a Mac workstation. Check compatibility if the copy also needs to be read on other computers.

The product description lists 2 TB, preformatting for Mac and use with Time Machine. It mentions a USB-A cable and USB-C adapter. Password protection and hardware encryption are listed as available.

Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport 6TB White

Western Digital My Passport 6TB White

A portable HDD option if the catalogued collection and planned additions fit within the stated capacity.

The product description lists 6 TB, USB 3.0 and automatic backup software. It also mentions password protection and 256-bit AES hardware encryption; according to the description, these features need to be activated using the supplied software.

Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport 2TB Blue

Western Digital My Passport 2TB Blue

A portable HDD option if 2 TB is enough for the collection and the computers can read the drive.

The product description lists 2 TB of storage, USB 3.0, USB-powered operation and included backup software. According to the description, password protection and 256-bit AES hardware encryption need to be activated using WD Discovery.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is one external drive enough to store recordings long term?

No. Treat one drive as part of a wider preservation plan. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping at least three versions of important files: the original and two backups. Netwerk Digitaal Erfgoed recommends checking backups regularly.

How can you check that files are intact after copying them?

Check that the copied files open, and use checksums where appropriate to spot changes or failed backups. Netwerk Digitaal Erfgoed recommends checksums as a useful tool; also agree who will repeat the check later.

Does a new drive need formatting before you can use it with multiple computers?

Not necessarily. First, test the computers and existing file system with a non-unique copy. Crucial says the X9 Pro is supplied as exFAT and warns that reformatting erases data from the drive.

Can the archive freely copy and share recordings featuring identifiable speakers?

Not simply because there’s storage space available. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, identifiable audio recordings may be personal data. Processing them requires an appropriate lawful basis under the GDPR, and organisations must protect data appropriately. The right lawful basis and sharing arrangements depend on the specific recordings and the archive’s circumstances.

Is password protection enough to manage access to recordings?

Password protection can be one part of access security, but it doesn’t determine who may receive recordings or the lawful basis for processing them. Establish who needs access, then assess security and sharing arrangements separately, as the Dutch Data Protection Authority advises for personal data.