If train noise is drowning out an existing voice note, compare well-fitting in-ear earbuds with adjustable noise cancellation, focusing on speech playback rather than just claims about the call microphone. If you want to hear announcements or find close-fitting earbuds uncomfortable, also compare a transparency mode or a more open fit. NS says that trains have announcements with up-to-date travel information, but you’ll need to judge for yourself how well you can hear them with a particular pair of earbuds.
Who are these earbuds for?
Travellers who want to catch every word
If you’re listening back to an existing voice note that may be quiet in a noisy train, compare speech playback and a comfortable fit that helps reduce noise. The Consumers’ Association also includes speech clips in its assessments of headphones and earbuds.
Travellers who want to hear announcements
If you want to keep up with travel information while listening, look for an easily accessible ambient mode or a more open fit. NS says that trains have announcements with up-to-date travel information; the Consumers’ Association explains that open-ear earbuds let in ambient sound.
Travellers with sensitive ears
If you find close-fitting earbuds uncomfortable, compare different ear-tip sizes or try a more open fit. Comfort and how much ambient sound gets through are important things to consider.
What should you look for when choosing?
A call microphone won’t tell you how an existing voice note sounds, so test speech playback with a recording of your own. The Consumers’ Association includes speech clips in its testing method, while NS says that trains have announcements with up-to-date travel information.
| Concern |
What to look for |
Who is this important for? |
| Hearing speech clearly |
Listen to a voice note of your own; check the fit and adjustable noise cancellation. |
When I listen back to a quiet voice note in a noisy carriage, I want to follow the words without constantly turning up the volume. Around 31% of consumers prioritise speech clarity. |
| Hearing announcements |
Check whether you can quickly pause or switch to an ambient mode. |
I want to keep up with travel information while listening back, without having to search for the controls each time. Around 25% of consumers give top priority to awareness of their surroundings. |
| Comfort during longer listening sessions |
Compare ear-tip sizes and, if needed, try a more open fit. |
If close-fitting earbuds feel uncomfortable, I want a style that stays comfortable, even if it blocks out less noise. Around 19% of consumers prioritise wearing comfort. |
| Battery life per charge |
Compare the stated battery life in the listening mode you use; consider the earbuds’ playback time separately from the total including the charging case. |
I want to listen to a voice note during my journey without having to recharge the earbuds along the way. Around 13% of consumers give battery life top priority. |
| Essential features |
Check which features you’ll actually use, such as noise cancellation, an ambient mode and on-earbud controls. |
I want to choose features that suit listening back and staying aware, rather than being swayed by extras I don’t need. Around 12% of consumers prioritise the features they need. |
Avoiding common buying mistakes
-
Assuming claims about clear phone calls mean voice notes will sound clear
A call microphone records or transmits your voice; when you listen to an existing recording, you hear it through the earbuds’ speakers. These are two different tasks.
Where possible, listen to a voice note of your own and judge how clearly you can hear the voice.
-
Confusing battery life including the charging case with continuous playback time
Total battery life including the case accounts for recharging between listening sessions. You’re not wearing the earbuds while they recharge.
Compare the stated battery life of the earbuds themselves, ideally in the noise-cancelling mode you plan to use while travelling.
-
Choosing only for maximum noise isolation
A close-fitting design may feel uncomfortable, while announcements on the train could be important.
Try the fit and check whether you can quickly pause or switch to an ambient mode. You could also compare a more open fit.
Brands to compare
Sony
The WF-1000XM6 is worth comparing if you’re looking for close-fitting in-ear earbuds with an ambient sound mode, Quick Attention and multipoint connectivity.
- Sony quotes up to 8 hours of music playback with noise cancellation on for this model. This is the manufacturer’s figure, not a measurement of listening back to voice notes.
- Check that the fit and controls are comfortable for the way you plan to use them.
Apple
AirPods Pro 3 are worth comparing if you’re looking for in-ear earbuds with active noise cancellation, Transparency mode and five sizes of ear tips.
- Apple quotes up to 8 hours of listening time per charge with active noise cancellation switched on.
- Apple says functionality as Bluetooth headphones may be limited with devices from other manufacturers. Check that the features you want work with your device.
JBL
The Tune Beam 2 is worth considering if you want to compare noise cancellation with Ambient Aware and TalkThru.
- JBL quotes up to 48 hours of playback including charging from the case; this isn’t the battery life for a single listening session.
- JBL’s claims about call quality don’t prove how clearly you’ll hear a previously recorded voice note.
soundcore
The Liberty 4 NC and semi-in-ear Liberty Buds offer two different styles of fit to compare.
- soundcore quotes 10/50 hours for the Liberty 4 NC and up to 6 hours with noise cancellation on for the Liberty Buds. These figures apply to different models and conditions.
- Claims about noise reduction and clear calls are made by the manufacturer and aren’t an independent comparison of how these models reproduce speech.
Samsung
The Galaxy Buds4 Pro is another ANC option to compare for its controls and device features.
- Samsung describes improvements to ANC, EQ and fit compared with an earlier design.
- These brand claims alone don’t show how clearly you’ll hear voice notes on a train.
Joybuy products for travel
This Joybuy selection includes wireless earbuds for listening on the go, including in-ear models with active noise cancellation and options with controls or modes that let you take ambient sound into account.
No image available
Samsung Galaxy Buds4 Pro, black
An option if you’re looking for in-ear earbuds with noise cancellation and on-earbud controls for travelling.
The product description lists touch and gesture controls, and 6 hours of playback with noise cancellation switched on.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Bose QuietComfort Earbuds, black
A good fit if you want to switch between noise cancellation and a mode that lets in ambient sound.
The product description lists touch controls for play and pause, Quiet and Ambient modes, three sizes of ear tips and stability bands.
View at Joybuy
No image available
HONOR Earbuds A Pro
An option if you want to switch between noise cancellation and ambient sound while listening.
The product description lists ANC, Transparency and Off modes, which you can select using the earbuds or the app. It also says you can adjust the fit by rotating the earbuds.
View at Joybuy
No image available
soundcore Liberty 4 NC, white
A close-fitting in-ear option if you want to compare noise cancellation and different ear-tip sizes.
The product description lists touch controls, active noise cancellation and up to 10 hours of playback per charge.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Redmi Buds 6 Play, white
A wireless option for travelling if you want to try a different fit.
The product description lists up to 7.5 hours of playback per charge and additional S- and L-size ear tips.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
How can I check whether earbuds are suitable for my voice note?
If possible, listen to a speech recording of your own and pay attention to clarity, fit and the controls for pausing or rewinding. An assessment of the call microphone relates to recording or transmitting your voice, not playing back an existing voice note.
Should I leave noise cancellation on for the whole train journey?
No, not if you want to hear announcements while listening. NS says that trains have announcements with up-to-date travel information; pause the voice note or switch to an ambient mode, then judge for yourself whether you can hear the announcements clearly.
Which battery life should I compare for a long journey?
Compare the playback time per charge in the listening mode you plan to use. A total that includes the case accounts for recharging between sessions, while you’re not wearing the earbuds.
How can I keep my listening volume at a safe level?
The World Health Organization recommends well-fitting noise-cancelling headphones to help reduce the temptation to turn up the volume in noisy places. Also consider how long you listen for, and take regular breaks.
Can I always return in-ear earbuds after trying them out if I bought them online?
No, don’t assume that you can. ACM ConsuWijzer generally refers to a 14-day cooling-off period for online purchases, but also notes an exception for hygiene products that have been removed from their packaging. Check the returns policy for the product you’ve chosen before buying; the stated exception doesn’t automatically mean that every model of earbuds is covered by it.