Who are these earbuds for?

Listener in a noisy carriage

Wants to follow spoken passages without continually turning up the volume. A comfortable fit and noise reduction are important considerations; the World Health Organization recommends well-fitting earbuds and, where possible, noise cancelling in noisy situations.

Traveller who wants to keep up with travel information

Wants to pause a story quickly or let in ambient sound around stops and changes. NS explains how to receive travel and connection notifications in the NS app; an ambient mode can also make it easier to switch to the sounds around you while listening.

Long-time listener with sensitive ears

Prioritises comfort over extended listening rather than maximum isolation. The Consumers’ Association describes how in-ear fit varies from person to person; an open-ear design may be worth trying if ear tips in the ear canal feel uncomfortable.

What should you look for when choosing?

First decide what matters most to you: clear speech, access to travel information, comfort or uninterrupted listening time. This will help you compare suitable designs and features.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who might value this most?
Hearing spoken audio clearly Check how the ear tips fit and whether the model has noise cancelling. Assess a recording at a sensible volume. If I want to follow quiet spoken passages in a noisy carriage without continually turning up the volume, clear speech is my priority; around 31% of consumers put this first.
Noticing travel information Check whether you can easily pause or switch to an ambient mode. Find out how you’ll receive travel notifications. Anyone who wants to respond quickly to announcements or changes at stops and connections will prioritise access to travel information; around 25% of consumers do.
Comfort during a longer story Check which ear tip sizes are available and how the design feels when worn for a long time. Read the terms before opening the packaging. If sealed ear tips might become uncomfortable over time, comfort matters more to me than maximum isolation; around 25% of consumers choose fit as their main priority.
Listening without stopping to recharge Compare listening time per charge in the mode you’ll use, separately from the extra time available with the charging case. For consumers who want to listen to a story throughout their journey without interruption, listening time per charge matters most; around 19% give uninterrupted listening time top priority.

How to avoid common buying mistakes

  • Assuming the battery life on the packaging is for one listening session

    Total listening time including the case isn’t the same as how long the earbuds themselves last on a single charge. The Consumers’ Association also distinguishes between using the earbuds and charging them in the case.

    Compare the hours per charge in the listening mode you plan to use on the train, not just the combined total.

  • Expecting noise cancelling to make a poor fit comfortable

    A good seal partly depends on how the ear tips fit your ears. Noise cancelling won’t make an uncomfortable or ill-fitting tip comfortable.

    Check which ear tip sizes are available and what terms apply before opening the packaging.

  • Choosing open-ear earbuds for peace and quiet without considering train noise

    An open design lets you hear your surroundings more easily, but it won’t block out carriage noise like a sealed in-ear design.

    Try a representative spoken recording to see if you can follow it at a moderate volume in a similarly noisy environment.

Brands to consider

Sony

The Dutch product information for the WF-C710N lists noise cancelling and an Ambient Sound mode. These features may be useful if you want to switch between listening and hearing your surroundings.

  • Sony lists up to 8.5 hours of listening time, plus a further 21.5 hours with the case. These are manufacturer figures, not measurements from a train journey.
  • Check the fit and listening time in the mode you plan to use.

JBL

JBL describes the Tune Beam 2 as a sealed earbud with Adaptive Noise Cancelling and Smart Ambient.

  • JBL lists Ambient Aware and TalkThru, which let in ambient sound or allow you to talk to others without taking out your earbuds.
  • The stated maximum of 48 hours is the total quoted playback time, not one uninterrupted listening session.

Shokz

The OpenFit 2 is an open-ear alternative for anyone who doesn’t want a sealed ear tip in their ear canal.

  • Shokz highlights awareness of your surroundings and a Vocal Mode for podcasts and spoken recordings.
  • According to Shokz, listening time is up to 11 hours per charge and up to 48 hours with the case. Try them to see whether spoken audio remains clear on your train.

Apple

Apple describes the AirPods Pro 3 as in-ear earbuds with noise cancelling, Transparency mode and five sizes of ear tips.

  • Apple lists up to 8 hours per charge with noise cancelling on, and 24 hours with the case.
  • Check that the features and fit suit your devices and ears; these specifications don’t prove that history stories will be easier to hear.

Samsung

Samsung describes the Galaxy Buds3 FE as having noise cancelling and features for switching between Galaxy devices.

  • Samsung lists Auto Switch and ANC as features of this model.
  • Check that the features work with your device and read the terms of the specific offer.

Joybuy product picks

The Joybuy picks below are sealed in-ear earbuds to compare for listening to history stories on the train. Check the fit, controls for ambient sound and listening time of each model to see what suits your journey.

Fairphone Fairbuds Black

Fairphone Fairbuds Black

An in-ear option in the sealed-earbud category; check that the fit remains comfortable throughout a full listening session.

View on Joybuy
Bose QuietComfort Earbuds Black

Bose QuietComfort Earbuds Black

A sealed in-ear option to compare with other designs; pay particular attention to how the ear tips feel during longer listening sessions.

View on Joybuy
Apple AirPods Pro 3

Apple AirPods Pro 3

Apple lists noise cancelling, Transparency mode and five sizes of ear tips for this model; check the fit and features with your devices.

View on Joybuy
Bose QuietComfort Ultra Bluetooth Earbuds (2nd generation) Black

Bose QuietComfort Ultra Bluetooth Earbuds (2nd generation) Black

An in-ear model to compare if you’re looking for a sealed fit; see how comfortable it feels in your ears.

View on Joybuy
Sony WF-C710N Glass Blue

Sony WF-C710N Glass Blue

Sony describes this model as having noise cancelling and an Ambient Sound mode; check whether switching between modes is practical on your journey.

View on Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Should I still turn the volume up high when using noise cancelling?

No. The World Health Organization recommends well-fitting earbuds and, where possible, noise cancelling to reduce the need to turn up the volume in noisy environments. It also recommends setting your device volume to no more than 60% of the maximum and being mindful of how long you listen.

How can I keep up with my connection while listening?

Check whether you can easily pause or switch to ambient sound. NS explains that notifications for a selected journey can include delays, platform changes, departures, connections and arrivals; remember to stay aware of your surroundings too.

Can I always try and return in-ear earbuds bought online?

Don’t assume you’ll have an unconditional trial period. ACM ConsuWijzer says that online purchases generally come with a 14-day cooling-off period after delivery, but there are exceptions, including for hygiene products that have been removed from their packaging. Before opening the packaging, check the terms that apply to the specific product.

Can I wear earbuds on the train?

NS’s house rules don’t prohibit listening with earbuds. However, NS requires passengers to keep quiet in the quiet zone and not disturb others anywhere on the train with loud conversations or music; this applies specifically to NS’s house rules.

How should I care for my earbuds if they aren’t charging properly?

Follow the instructions for your model. For the Sony WF-C710N, Sony recommends carefully cleaning the earbuds and charging contacts with a dry cloth or cotton bud if you have charging problems, and advises against using compressed air.