Who are these earbuds suitable for?

Listening near other visitors

Want to follow theatre dialogue at a modest volume without anyone at the next table hearing your recording? The Consumentenbond and Shokz describe factors that affect fit and sound leakage in a quiet space.

Listening for long sessions

Listen to lengthy discussions and pay attention to fit, controls and the earbuds’ own battery life, rather than just the extra time provided by a charging case? The Consumentenbond discusses speech reproduction and points to consider when choosing wireless earbuds.

Staying aware of your surroundings

Want to remain aware of the library around you, or find sealing tips uncomfortable, and weigh this against possible sound leakage? The Consumentenbond and Sony respectively describe the trade-offs of open designs and an open-ring design.

What should you look for when choosing?

Start with the fit and check that you can follow the recording at a modest volume. Then consider sound leakage, awareness of your surroundings and battery life per charge.

What to consider What to check before buying Who is this important for?
Speech clarity Listen to a speech sample on your usual source device and check that you can follow the voices at a low volume. If I want to follow a recorded discussion at a low volume, clear voices are my priority. Around 29% of consumers put speech clarity first.
Whether others can hear them At your usual listening volume, check whether someone nearby can hear the recording. Don’t assume that noise cancellation prevents sound leakage. When I’m sitting near other visitors, I don’t want them to hear the recording. Around 36% of consumers give top priority to minimising disturbance to others.
Fit and ambient sound Check how they feel to wear and what tip sizes or ambient modes are available. With open earbuds, check for sound leakage too. If sealing tips feel uncomfortable or I want to stay aware of my surroundings, I weigh comfort against possible sound leakage. Around 21% of consumers prioritise comfort and awareness of their surroundings.
Battery life and components Compare battery life per charge using the same settings, and check the exact product generation when looking for replacement parts. For a long listening session or future maintenance, I want to know when the earbuds need charging and whether parts will fit my model. Around 14% of consumers prioritise battery life and product lifespan.

Pitfalls to avoid when buying

  • Assuming noise cancellation means others can’t hear anything

    Noise cancellation is designed to reduce the ambient sound you hear. In a library, you also need to consider whether the recording is leaking to someone nearby.

    Check both the fit and sound leakage at the volume you plan to use for listening to the discussion.

  • Confusing battery life with the case for continuous listening time

    The case recharges the earbuds when you put them back in, so total battery life with the case isn’t the same as battery life per charge.

    Compare battery life per earbud using the same noise-cancellation setting.

  • Choosing open-ear earbuds without checking for sound leakage in a quiet space

    An open design lets ambient sound in, but can also let sound out. This may be noticeable in a quiet library.

    Only choose this option if nearby visitors can’t hear the recording at the volume you need.

  • Assuming replacement parts fit different generations

    A part designed for a different generation may not fit your earbuds.

    Check the exact generation and compatibility before relying on a replacement.

Brands to consider

Sony

Offers both noise-isolating models and an open-ring design for listeners who want to stay aware of their surroundings.

  • Sony lists an ambient sound mode and up to 8 hours of playback with noise cancellation on for the WF-1000XM5.
  • The stated battery life and features don’t tell you how clearly theatre dialogue will come through or how much sound will leak out in a library. Check the fit and sound leakage for yourself.

Apple

AirPods Pro 3 are noise-isolating in-ear earbuds with Transparency mode, designed for those who find the fit and controls work well with their devices.

  • Apple lists five tip sizes and up to 8 hours of listening on a single charge with Active Noise Cancellation on.
  • The stated battery life and fit won’t be the same for every user. Also check that the controls work with your devices.

Fairphone

Fairbuds 2 are worth considering if replaceable parts matter to you.

  • Fairphone says the Fairbuds 2 have seven replaceable parts.
  • The battery page mentioned doesn’t confirm separately whether that battery fits the Fairbuds 2. Check the generation and compatibility before relying on a replacement.

JBL

The Tune Beam 2 is a noise-isolating wireless option with adjustable ambient sound.

  • JBL lists active noise cancellation, as well as Ambient Aware and TalkThru features.
  • These features don’t tell you how much sound someone nearby will hear in a quiet library. Check for sound leakage at your own listening volume.

Shokz

Open-ear designs are an alternative for anyone who doesn’t want to wear anything in their ear canal.

  • An open design may suit you if you want to stay aware of your surroundings.
  • Shokz acknowledges that open designs can leak sound and that this may be noticeable in quiet surroundings. A brand claim about reducing leakage isn’t a guarantee for a specific model or listening volume.

Joybuy product picks

These Joybuy picks are in-ear earbuds for listening to theatre discussions in a quiet library, and include both wired and wireless models. Compare the fit, ambient settings and battery life of each model to find what suits your listening habits.

JBL Wave Buds 2, black

JBL Wave Buds 2 – black

May suit anyone who wants to adjust ambient sound and use their own sound settings.

Joybuy’s product information lists ANC, Smart Ambient and EQ adjustment through the JBL Headphones app. The stated 10 hours per charge applies with ANC off; the total 40 hours includes the charging case.

View at Joybuy
Samsung Galaxy Buds4 Pro

Samsung Galaxy Buds4 Pro

May suit anyone who wants to reduce ambient sound and adjust the audio.

Joybuy’s product information lists active noise cancellation and an adjustable 9-band equaliser. The stated battery life per charge is up to 6 hours with ANC on and 7 hours with ANC off; total battery life with the case is longer.

View at Joybuy
Bose Noise Cancelling Wired Earbuds, black

Bose Noise Cancelling Wired Earbuds – black

May suit anyone looking for wired in-ear earbuds with fit options and controls on the cable.

Joybuy’s product information lists a USB-C connection, in-line controls, a microphone, three ear tip sizes and two sizes of stability wing. These are wired earbuds; Bluetooth isn’t listed.

View at Joybuy
Fairphone Fairbuds, black

Fairphone Fairbuds – black

May suit anyone who wants to use their own sound settings and values replaceable parts.

Joybuy’s product information lists an adjustable equaliser and up to 8 hours of playback with ANC off. Check the exact generation and compatibility before buying replacement parts.

View at Joybuy
Bose QuietComfort Earbuds, black

Bose QuietComfort Earbuds – black

May suit anyone who wants to reduce or let in ambient sound and values a choice of fit options.

Joybuy’s product information lists ANC, an Aware mode, three ear tip sizes and stability bands. The stated battery life is up to 8.5 hours per charge; extra listening time depends on the charging case.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do you need active noise cancellation in a quiet library?

Not necessarily. First, choose a fit that lets you follow voices at a low volume, then check whether anyone else can hear the recording. Active noise cancellation reduces ambient sound for the wearer, but it doesn’t replace checking for sound leakage and may reduce battery life.

How should you set up earbuds for a long spoken recording?

Start at a modest volume and check battery life per charge using the sound settings you plan to use. For in-ear earbuds, choose tips that fit and clean the sound outlets and charging contacts according to your model’s instructions. Sony advises against using sharp tools in the sound outlet of the LinkBuds Open.

Can you return in-ear earbuds bought online after trying them?

In the Netherlands, online purchases generally come with a statutory 14-day cooling-off period from the day of delivery, according to ACM ConsuWijzer. ACM lists exceptions for hygiene products that have been removed from their packaging. Before breaking any seal, check with the seller how this exception applies to the specific packaging and use of the earbuds.

Does the statutory guarantee always end after two years?

No. According to ACM ConsuWijzer, the statutory guarantee is separate from any manufacturer’s or seller’s guarantee, and there is no set statutory guarantee period of exactly two years for all earbuds. If a product develops a fault too soon under normal use, the seller is responsible for providing an appropriate solution.

What rules should you follow when using earbuds in a library?

Follow the rules of the library where you’re listening. The European Radio Equipment Directive sets requirements for radio equipment placed on the EU market, but these requirements don’t tell you whether a particular model is suitable for use in a quiet library.