Who is this buying guide for?

Listening in a noisy space

If you play recorded theatre clips repeatedly, you’ll want to follow the words without constantly turning up the volume. Compare the fit and listening modes using the same clip; research into competing voices helps explain why background speech can be distracting, but it doesn’t prove how a particular pair of earbuds will perform.

Visiting a live rehearsal

If you need to hear the actors in the same room, it’s important to weigh isolation against the sound coming in from outside. Sony describes the open design of LinkBuds Open as a way to let ambient sound through, which means you’ll also hear conversations around you.

Studying at home for long periods

If you’re listening to several scenes in a row, fit and comfort can make a difference. If you switch between your phone and computer, also check that the connections or connectivity features suit the way you listen.

What should you look for when choosing?

Start by asking whether you’ll be playing a recording or listening to voices live. For recordings, compare the settings using the same clip at a moderate volume; for live use, consider how much ambient sound you want to continue hearing.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this most relevant to?
Following recorded dialogue Compare sealing tips and ANC on and off using the same clip at the same volume. If I’m studying a recording while other people are talking, I want to be able to judge whether the words are easy to follow in my own space. Around 36% of consumers rank intelligibility as their top buying priority.
Hearing voices live Check how much sound an open design or ambient mode lets through, and how to operate the mode. At a rehearsal, I want to hear the actors without being completely cut off from the room, while bearing in mind that other conversations will come through too. Around 29% of consumers prioritise being able to hear live dialogue.
Fit for long listening sessions Check which tip sizes or sleeves are included and, if possible, try the fit during a longer session. If I’m listening to several scenes in a row, I’m mainly looking for a comfortable fit that stays in place, without assuming one design will suit everyone. Around 21% of consumers put fit first.
Switching between devices Check the connection or multipoint support, and whether switching works with your devices. If I listen on my phone and computer in turn, I don’t want to have to pair them again each time; being connected to both at once doesn’t automatically mean playing audio from both at once. Around 14% of consumers prioritise connecting between devices.

Common buying mistakes

  • Confusing clear calls with intelligible recordings

    A claim about the microphone for phone calls doesn’t necessarily tell you how recorded actors’ dialogue will sound or how much speech in the room you’ll hear.

    Test the sound with a theatre clip of your own; don’t use call microphone claims as a substitute for that comparison.

  • Choosing maximum isolation for live listening

    When actors are performing live, the voices you want to hear are coming from the room. According to Sony, a design that lets ambient sound through will also let other conversations through.

    For live use, compare an open design or an adjustable ambient mode, and decide how much background noise you’re happy with.

  • Assuming a manufacturer’s warranty covers all your legal rights

    An additional manufacturer’s warranty doesn’t replace your legal rights if a product is faulty. The Dutch government says there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands.

    If there’s a problem, contact the seller. If you have an additional warranty, check exactly what extra cover it provides.

Brands to consider

Apple

AirPods Pro 3 are a wireless, sealing option for comparing listening modes with recorded dialogue.

  • Apple lists ANC, Transparency mode and five sizes of silicone tips. The stated listening time with ANC is up to 8 hours per charge; this is the manufacturer’s figure.
  • Conversation detection isn’t the same as enhancing actors’ voices in a recording. You’ll need to judge the fit and intelligibility for yourself.

Sony

WF-1000XM5 and LinkBuds Open represent different approaches: a sealed model and an open design.

  • Sony says the WF-1000XM5 supports multipoint for two Bluetooth devices; the feature needs to be set up in the Sound Connect app.
  • The open design of LinkBuds Open lets ambient sound through, including conversations. Features of this model and the WF-1000XM5 are not interchangeable.

Samsung

Galaxy Buds4 Pro are a wireless, sealing option for anyone playing recorded theatre clips.

  • Samsung lists ANC and adaptive EQ in its announcement of the model.
  • The sound and comfort benefits are claims from Samsung’s own announcement; they don’t prove better intelligibility for theatre dialogue. Check the features with your own playback device.

Shure

SE215 are wired, passively isolating in-ear earphones for listening to recordings.

  • The model has a detachable cable and interchangeable sleeves.
  • Shure claims up to 37 dB of sound isolation; this isn’t a guaranteed level of attenuation for every user. The cable needs a compatible connection, and the sealed fit may be less suitable if you want to listen in to a live performance.

Product picks at Joybuy

These product picks are aimed at listening to recorded dialogue in noisy, distracting surroundings. Compare the available connections, fits and listening modes with your own devices and the same clip.

Bose Noise Cancelling Wired Earbuds, black

Bose Noise Cancelling Wired Earbuds – Black

A wired option for comparing noise cancellation with your own recording, without having to charge the earbuds.

The product description lists QuietControl noise cancellation, a USB-C connection, in-line controls and earbuds in several sizes. Check that USB-C is compatible with your playback device.

View at Joybuy
Fairphone Fairbuds Black

Fairphone Fairbuds Black

Wireless in-ear earbuds for comparing ANC settings with the same theatre clip in a noisy space.

The product description lists hybrid ANC, multipoint for two devices and up to 8 hours of playback with ANC off. The stated playback time does not apply with ANC on.

View at Joybuy
Bose QuietComfort Earbuds Black

Bose QuietComfort Earbuds Black

The ANC and Aware mode described give you settings to compare using the same playback clip.

The product description lists small, medium and large earbuds, app controls and up to 8.5 hours of battery life per charge. Check that the controls work with your devices.

View at Joybuy
Bose QuietComfort Ultra Earbuds, second generation, Deep Plum

Bose QuietComfort Ultra Earbuds (2nd Gen) Deep Plum

Sealing in-ear earbuds with adjustable noise cancellation, letting you compare different listening modes with your own recording.

The product description lists nine sizes of ear tips and stability bands. The most comfortable size varies from person to person.

View at Joybuy
soundcore Liberty 4 NC, wireless in-ear earbuds

soundcore Liberty 4 NC

The ANC described gives you a setting to compare with noise cancellation switched off, using the same clip.

The product description lists Bluetooth 5.3, up to 10 hours of playback per charge and extra ear tips. The stated playback time is a product specification, not an assessment of intelligibility.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can ANC help when people talk over a recording?

It depends on the room, the fit and the earbuds; the presence of ANC doesn’t predict how much of the theatre dialogue you’ll understand. Compare ANC on and off using the same clip at the same volume. Research into competing voices shows that recognising speech can become more difficult, but it didn’t test any of these earbuds.

Which earbuds are suitable if I need to hear live actors?

An open design or adjustable ambient mode may suit you if you want to keep hearing voices from the room. Bear in mind that other conversations will come through too; there’s no evidence that a mode like this separates actors from people around you.

What should I look for if I switch between my phone and computer?

Check whether the earbuds support the connections or connectivity features your devices need. Multipoint can connect two devices at once, but that doesn’t mean you’ll hear audio from both at the same time; also check how switching between them works.

What can I do if my earbuds are faulty after purchase?

If there’s a problem, contact the seller about your legal rights. The Dutch government says there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands; what you can expect from a product depends, among other things, on the product and the sales information. Any manufacturer’s warranty does not replace those rights.

Can I always return earbuds bought online within 14 days?

For online consumer purchases, you generally have a 14-day cooling-off period from delivery, subject to conditions and exceptions. The European Union does not give a definitive answer on the hygiene exception for a specific opened pair of earbuds, so check the applicable returns policy before opening the packaging.