Listener on a noisy train
Wants to follow spoken audio without continually turning up the volume. The World Health Organization advises considering well-fitting, noise-cancelling earbuds in noisy situations.
If train noise drowns out the recording, sealed in-ear earbuds with active noise cancellation are worth considering, provided the ear tips fit comfortably and you can easily let in ambient sound. An open design may suit you better if you want to prioritise announcements or don’t want silicone tips in your ears, although you’ll hear more train noise too. Compare listening time per charge, and avoid continually turning up a recording to drown out background noise.
Wants to follow spoken audio without continually turning up the volume. The World Health Organization advises considering well-fitting, noise-cancelling earbuds in noisy situations.
Prioritises hearing what’s going on around them, so compares an open design with in-ear earbuds that have an ambient sound mode. Consumentenbond explains that open earbuds let in more ambient sound.
Wants to listen comfortably during the journey and check that silicone ear tips fit well. According to Consumentenbond, in-ear earbuds with silicone tips seal off the ear canal, while some people find earbuds without tips more comfortable.
Choose these if: you mainly want to follow spoken audio while there’s noise all around you on the train.
Bear in mind: fit is personal, and a seal lets in less ambient sound. ANC doesn’t guarantee that every recording will be easy to understand.
Choose these if: you want to hear announcements more easily or find silicone ear tips uncomfortable.
Bear in mind: a more open fit also lets in more train noise.
Choose these if: a good seal matters more to you than active noise cancellation.
Bear in mind: passive isolation and active noise cancellation are not the same thing. What you hear also depends on the fit.
| What to consider | What to look for | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Clarity in train noise | Compare the seal, ANC and the option to let in ambient sound. Try spoken audio at a comfortable volume. | If I want to follow a recorded sermon on a noisy train, I look for a good fit and noise cancellation so I don’t have to keep turning up the volume. Around 33% of consumers prioritise clarity. |
| Announcements and ambient sound | Compare an open design with the controls for an ambient sound mode, and check how to switch between settings. | If I want to hear announcements, being aware of my surroundings matters more to me than maximum isolation. Around 27% of consumers prioritise awareness of their surroundings. |
| Fit during your journey | Check the wearing style and which sizes of ear tips are included. Read the returns policy before breaking any seal. | If earbuds need to stay comfortable for a long time, I want to check that the shape suits my ears. Around 20% of consumers choose primarily based on fit. |
| Listening time per charge | Compare the stated listening time per charge with the ANC setting you plan to use; don’t count the case as part of a single uninterrupted listening session. | If I want to listen to a long recording without stopping to recharge, I check the listening time of the earbuds themselves. Around 20% of consumers focus mainly on battery life per charge. |
An ANC label is not the same as an independent speech test on a train. The recording and the fit also affect what you can hear.
Check that the ear tips feel comfortable and compare spoken audio at a comfortable volume.
A charging case can recharge your earbuds, but that’s not the same as uninterrupted playback on a single charge. Stated battery life can also vary depending on whether ANC is on or off.
Compare listening time per charge using the setting you plan to use on your journey.
Online purchases in the Netherlands generally come with a statutory cooling-off period, but exceptions may apply to certain hygiene products. ACM ConsuWijzer distinguishes between the cooling-off period and your rights if a product is faulty.
Before breaking any seal, check the returns policy that applies to the product. Your statutory rights if a product is faulty are separate from the manufacturer’s warranty.
The WF-C710N is an example of sealed earbuds with noise cancellation, an ambient sound mode and silicone ear tips.
According to JBL, the Tune Beam 2 has adaptive noise cancellation, Smart Ambient and TalkThru.
AirPods 4 with Active Noise Cancellation is a separate version of AirPods 4. Apple lists ANC and a Transparency mode for this version.
According to soundcore, the Liberty 4 NC is an in-ear model with adaptive ANC, adjustable EQ and multipoint connectivity.
This selection includes in-ear models for listening to spoken audio on the go, and an open-ear model for anyone who wants to stay more aware of their surroundings.
No image available
An in-ear model to consider if you’re looking for a wired option for spoken audio on the go.
No image available
These sealed in-ear earbuds are worth comparing if you want noise cancellation on the train and the option to let in ambient sound.
Sony Netherlands states that the WF-C710N offers up to 8.5 hours of continuous playback with noise cancellation on. This manufacturer’s claim is not a measured result for your journey.
No image available
A wireless in-ear model to compare if you want to be able to let in ambient sound while listening.
The product title states a battery life of 22 hours; check the conditions of use and whether this figure refers to the earbuds, the case or both.
No image available
The product description mentions adaptive noise cancellation for everyday commuting. This is not an independent measure of how clearly you can hear on a train, so compare the model for fit and spoken audio.
No image available
The open-ear design may suit you if you want to stay more aware of your surroundings without putting ear tips in your ear canals.
The more open fit also lets in train noise, which can make spoken audio harder to hear.
Yes, as long as you don’t disturb other passengers. NS’s house rules ask passengers to keep quiet in quiet zones and prohibit noise that disturbs fellow travellers, so listen in a way that means others can’t hear your recording.
Choose an open design or switch on ambient sound mode if your earbuds have this feature. Don’t assume you’ll hear every announcement with ANC on.
First, check that the ear tips fit properly, and consider using noise cancellation in a noisy environment. The World Health Organization advises keeping the volume low, taking listening breaks and using well-fitting earbuds. Its listening advice is not a product specification or a legal limit in the Netherlands.
In the Netherlands, online purchases generally come with a 14-day statutory cooling-off period from the date of delivery. ACM ConsuWijzer lists exceptions for certain hygiene products that have been removed from their packaging. Before breaking any seal, check which conditions apply to the product. Your rights if a product is faulty are separate from the manufacturer’s warranty.