Listening back to recordings with background noise
You want to follow the lecturer when other voices are already in the recording. ANC targets sound around you, rather than removing voices from the audio file. Sony explains this limitation.
If conversations are already part of your lecture recording, ANC won’t reliably remove them: it’s designed to target sound around you while you listen. So start by comparing earbuds with a recording of your own, and also consider fit, controls and compatibility with your playback device. Sony warns that voices may still be audible despite noise cancelling.
You want to follow the lecturer when other voices are already in the recording. ANC targets sound around you, rather than removing voices from the audio file. Sony explains this limitation.
You don’t always listen somewhere quiet, and want to switch between noise cancelling and a mode that lets in ambient sound. Stay aware of your surroundings in traffic.
You listen to several lectures in a row and want to consider fit, comfort and keeping the volume at a sensible level. The World Health Organization recommends well-fitting headphones and taking care to listen safely.
First, work out whether the distracting sound is already in the recording or only present where you’re listening. Then compare fit, controls and features using a clip of your own.
| What to consider | What to look for | Who is this most important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Clarity in the recording | Listen to the same difficult clip and compare the sound settings and controls for pausing and rewinding. | If voices overlap in the file, I mainly want to know whether I can follow the lecturer. Around 31% of consumers say clarity in the recording is their top buying priority. |
| Sound where you’re listening | Compare ANC on, ANC off and ambient mode at the same volume; check how quickly you can switch between modes. | When background noise masks my recording, I want to assess whether another listening mode helps. Around 25% of consumers focus mainly on sound during playback. |
| Fit and long sessions | Check the available ear tip sizes, comfort and battery life per charge in the listening mode you use. Don’t automatically turn up the volume to follow speech more easily. | For long lectures, I want to listen comfortably without continually turning up the volume. Around 19% of consumers prioritise long, comfortable listening sessions. |
| Phone and computer | Check that the required app works with your devices and that the connection and settings you want are available on them. | If I switch between my phone and computer, I want to know whether the controls work with both. Around 13% of consumers make switching between devices and settings their top priority. |
| Purchase and terms | Weigh the features against your own listening needs, and check the returns policy before opening any seal. | I don’t want to pay for features I don’t need, and want to know the terms in advance. Around 12% of consumers prioritise purchase costs and confidence in their purchase. |
ANC is designed to target sound around you while you listen. Sony says voices may still be audible despite noise cancelling.
Distinguish between sound in the audio file and sound where you’re listening. Test a difficult clip before choosing a model.
A feature that reduces sound around you won’t automatically solve the problem of overlapping voices in the recording.
Microphones and voice features for phone calls are different from making voices in an existing audio file easier to understand.
Assess playback using the recording you actually want to listen to again.
JBL lists up to 40 hours of total playback for the Wave Buds 2, including the charging case and with ANC off. That isn’t the same as listening continuously on a single charge.
Compare battery life per charge using the same ANC setting, and bear in mind the conditions attached to the manufacturer’s specifications.
You may need to pause a long listening session to charge the earbuds in their case.
ACM ConsuWijzer notes an exception to the cooling-off period for hygiene products that have been removed from their packaging. This is separate from your statutory guarantee rights if a product is faulty.
Check the applicable returns policy before opening any seal. Remember that the cooling-off period is different from your rights if a product doesn’t meet statutory requirements.
The WF-C710N is one model to consider when comparing ANC, ambient sound, EQ and multipoint against your own listening needs.
The AirPods Pro 3 are an in-ear option with ANC and a Transparency mode.
The Wave Buds 2 are an option to compare for ANC, Smart Ambient and app settings.
The Galaxy Buds3 FE are worth considering if you want to assess features for use with compatible Galaxy devices.
These products are options to compare for listening back to lecture recordings, with a focus on ambient sound, fit and adjustable sound settings.
No image available
Compare these JBL earbuds with a recording of your own to see whether the playback and controls suit the way you listen back.
Check that the settings you want work with your playback device.
No image available
An option to compare if you want to assess ambient sound and sound settings while listening back to recordings.
JBL lists ANC, Smart Ambient and adjustable EQ via the JBL Headphones app. ANC won’t remove conversations that are already in the recording; the app and its listed features need to work with your devices.
No image available
A straightforward in-ear option to compare with a lecture recording of your own; focus particularly on clarity and fit.
The product name lists Bluetooth 5.4 and USB-C.
No image available
Compare this model with a recording of your own. For longer listening sessions, consider the fit and how much ambient sound you want to hear.
No image available
Compare the playback with a recording of your own and see whether the fit suits how long you listen for.
ANC is designed to target sound around you; it won’t remove conversations that are already in the recording.
No. ANC is designed to reduce ambient sound during playback. Sony says voices may still be audible despite noise cancelling. So assess playback using a clip from the recording.
Compare battery life per charge using the same ANC setting, rather than just looking at a total figure that includes the case. Sony specifies up to 8.5 hours of music playback with noise cancelling on for the WF-C710N; Apple lists up to 8 hours of listening time with ANC on for the AirPods Pro 3. These are manufacturer specifications based on their own conditions.
Follow the care instructions for the exact model. For the WF-C710N, Sony recommends checking the earbuds and charging area, among other things, and warns against using compressed air because it can push dirt into the openings.
According to ACM ConsuWijzer, online purchases generally come with a 14-day cooling-off period from delivery, with exceptions including certain hygiene products that have been removed from their packaging. You also have statutory guarantee rights if a product doesn’t perform as you could reasonably expect under normal use; these are separate from a manufacturer’s warranty.
The Dutch government states that listening to music hands-free while driving is permitted, but you must not hold an electronic device. Stay aware of the road when listening.