First, choose a style that suits where you listen: noise-isolating in-ear earbuds can help on noisy public transport, while open earbuds are a good fit if you want to keep hearing people or announcements. Then compare listening time per charge, fit and case size. The total battery life, including the case, is not the same as uninterrupted listening time.
Who are these earbuds for?
For listening at home for long periods
If you listen to several stories in a row, a comfortable fit and a compact charging case are important considerations. The Dutch Consumers’ Association highlights fit and portability as factors to consider when choosing.
For listening on public transport
If you want to follow spoken content on the train or bus, compare how well the earbuds seal and whether noise cancellation is available. Check the stated listening time with this feature switched on, too.
For staying aware of your surroundings
If you want to remain approachable while doing quiet activities or when you’re out and about, an open or non-isolating design may suit you. The Dutch Consumers’ Association points out that this type of design lets ambient sound through. Keep the volume low when you’re out and stay alert.
What should you look for when choosing?
Noise-isolating in-ear earbuds
Best suited to: listening on noisy public transport, where background noise drowns out the spoken content.
Bear in mind: the earbuds may put pressure on your ear canals. Compare the fit and listening time with noise cancellation switched on.
Open or non-isolating earbuds
Best suited to: listening in a quiet setting when you want to keep hearing people or announcements around you.
Bear in mind: ambient sound will come through while you’re listening, which can make speech harder to follow in noisy places.
The Dutch Consumers’ Association describes open earbuds as a way to let ambient sound through; for noisy environments, a noise-isolating fit is another option to consider. Choose based on where you listen, then check the following points.
| What to consider |
What to look for |
Who should prioritise this? |
| Fit and compactness |
Compare open and noise-isolating styles, and check whether the case is easy to carry. |
If I listen to several stories in a row, I want earbuds that feel comfortable and a case that’s easy to carry. Around 28% of consumers give fit and compactness top priority. |
| Clarity in noisy environments |
Compare the seal and noise cancellation; check listening time with noise cancellation switched on. |
On public transport, I want to follow spoken content despite the background noise. Around 22% of consumers prioritise clarity in noisy environments. |
| Hearing ambient sound |
Check whether the design is open or non-isolating, and bear your listening volume in mind when you’re out and about. |
If I want to keep hearing people or announcements around me, an open listening experience is a better fit for my situation. Around 22% of consumers give awareness of their surroundings top priority. |
| Listening time per charge |
Compare the stated hours per charge using the same noise-cancellation setting. |
When listening to several stories in one session, I don’t want to have to recharge halfway through. Around 17% of consumers give uninterrupted listening time top priority. |
| Controls |
Check whether you can pause and resume playback using the earbuds, and whether the features you want work with your phone. |
If I often pause while I’m out, I want to be able to do it easily without having to reach for my phone each time. Around 11% of consumers prioritise easy-to-use controls. |
Common pitfalls when choosing
-
Confusing total battery life with listening time per charge
The hours added by the charging case are not the same as the time you can use the earbuds continuously. You can’t listen to them while they’re charging in the case.
Compare the stated listening time per charge, and check whether it was measured with noise cancellation switched on or off.
-
Choosing noise cancellation without considering the fit
Noise-isolating in-ear earbuds may feel uncomfortable during a long listening session. Noise cancellation also won’t remove every sound.
Start by choosing a style that feels comfortable, then compare how much noise isolation you need.
-
Assuming an open design means you’ll hear traffic signals
Letting ambient sound through doesn’t guarantee you’ll notice every signal, especially if you turn the volume up high.
Keep the volume low when you’re out and stay alert. The Government of the Netherlands recommends keeping ambient sounds audible as a safety measure.
-
Confusing AirPods 4 with AirPods 4 with Active Noise Cancellation
Apple distinguishes between the standard AirPods 4 and a version with Active Noise Cancellation. Choosing the wrong one could mean missing out on a feature you want.
Check the full model name and the features included with that version before you choose.
Relevant brands
Sony
Among the models listed, Sony offers both an open listening style and a noise-isolating version with noise cancellation.
- Sony describes the LinkBuds Open as having an open ring design, and the WF-1000XM5 as featuring noise-isolating earbuds and ANC.
- An open design is less focused on blocking out noise; fit and how much contact you want with your surroundings are still personal considerations.
JBL
According to JBL, the JBL Tune Buds 2 combine a noise-isolating fit with Adaptive Noise Cancelling and Smart Ambient.
- JBL states that they offer up to 48 hours of playback, including charging via the case.
- That total playback time is not the same as uninterrupted listening time per charge. JBL’s description of call quality doesn’t, by itself, tell you how easy it is to follow stories.
Apple
Apple distinguishes between the standard AirPods 4 and AirPods 4 with Active Noise Cancellation.
- Apple states that the standard AirPods 4 offer up to 5 hours of listening time per charge.
- The standard AirPods 4 can work as Bluetooth earbuds with non-Apple devices, but Apple warns that some features may be limited.
Samsung
The Galaxy Buds4 and Galaxy Buds4 Pro are separate models. Check which version you’re looking at and whether its features suit your phone.
- Samsung identifies the black Galaxy Buds4 as model SM-R540NZKAEUB.
- Comfort and design claims for the range don’t automatically tell you how the earbuds will fit or how clearly you’ll hear stories.
Earbuds at Joybuy
This selection of Joybuy products includes noise-isolating in-ear earbuds for listening around background noise, as well as open-ear models for anyone who wants to keep hearing ambient sounds.
No image available
JBL Wave Buds 2 - White
An option to consider if you want to compare a noise-isolating fit and noise-cancellation features for listening around background noise. This model is listed as featuring ANC and Smart Ambient.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Samsung Galaxy Buds4 Pro True Wireless, black
A noise-isolating in-ear option to consider if you want to factor in background noise when choosing. The product name specifies Active Noise Cancellation.
View at Joybuy
No image available
NE66 Bluetooth 5.4 Open-Ear Earbuds (Black)
An open-ear option for anyone who wants to stay more connected to their surroundings while listening. The product name specifies Bluetooth 5.4.
View at Joybuy
No image available
MS218 OWS Open-Ear Bluetooth 6.0 (Gunmetal)
An open-ear model for anyone who wants to keep hearing ambient sounds. The product name specifies Bluetooth 6.0.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Fairphone Fairbuds White
A noise-isolating in-ear option for listening to stories in noisy surroundings; this model is listed as featuring Hybrid ANC.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Are open earbuds better for listening to stories?
Open earbuds may suit you if you want to keep hearing ambient sounds. On a noisy train, a well-sealed in-ear pair may help you follow spoken content more easily. Choose based on where you listen.
How can you avoid continually turning the volume up?
Fit your earbuds carefully and don’t turn the volume up unnecessarily. The World Health Organization recommends keeping the device volume to a maximum of 60% as a practical precaution. It also advises using well-fitting earbuds or noise cancellation to reduce the temptation to turn the volume up in noisy environments.
Can you cycle in the Netherlands while wearing earbuds?
The Government of the Netherlands allows you to listen to music and make hands-free calls while driving. Keeping ambient sounds audible, for example by using a low volume or wearing just one earbud, is safety advice; you’re not required to buy a particular type.
What if the battery stops working too soon?
Contact the seller. In addition to any manufacturer’s warranty, statutory rights in the Netherlands apply if a product doesn’t meet the expectations you’re entitled to have when used normally. These rights don’t give every product a fixed warranty period of exactly two years.
Can you always return earbuds bought online after trying them on?
Online purchases generally come with a cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery. The Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets lists exceptions for hygiene products that have been removed from their packaging, but doesn’t specify separately how that exception applies to every pair of earbuds. Check the product and returns information before opening the packaging.