Photo editor tackling tricky edges
Wants to refine hair, clothing and other fine outlines in photos using selections and layer masks. Adobe describes techniques including refining hair selections and editing layer masks.
If you already work on a laptop or desktop, choose between a screenless pen tablet and a pen display: with the first, you look at your computer screen; with the second, you draw directly on the image. For complex masks, the selection tools and editing options in your software matter too. Choose a standalone tablet if you want to edit without a computer, and check the pen, app, connections and included accessories beforehand. A drawing tablet cannot mask the background of a live video call on its own.
Wants to refine hair, clothing and other fine outlines in photos using selections and layer masks. Adobe describes techniques including refining hair selections and editing layer masks.
Already has a computer and wants to put their drawing setup away easily after editing. A screenless tablet lets you keep using your computer screen; Wacom lists Bluetooth and a cable option for the Wacom One S.
Wants to edit photos outside their student room too, and needs to check that the tablet, pen and app work together for the tasks they want to do. Apple lists Apple Pencil Pro and Apple Pencil (USB-C) as compatible pens for the iPad Air reviewed here; available features also depend on the app you choose.
Best for: working on an existing laptop or desktop, and saving desk space.
Consider: you draw on the tablet but view the result on a separate screen.
Best for: refining outlines directly on the image you can see.
Consider: you’ll need extra space and should check your computer’s video output and connections.
Best for: editing photos without a connected computer.
Consider: check that your chosen pen and app support the masking steps you need; don’t assume they’ll work in the same way as desktop software.
| What to consider | What should you check? | Who is it for? |
|---|---|---|
| Complex mask edges | Check that your computer or app supports selections and editable masks; also consider whether pen input feels comfortable for making manual adjustments. | If I want to refine fine outlines, I look at how the pen and software work together. Around 36% of consumers prioritise precision when working on complex mask edges. |
| Limited desk space | Compare the overall dimensions and active drawing area with the space available; also check whether the model connects via Bluetooth or cable. | If you already have a computer and want to put your setup away after use, consider the space it takes up and how it connects. Around 29% of consumers prioritise a workspace that fits on a small desk. |
| Drawing directly on the image | Check that your computer has the required video output and find out which cables and power supply the specific model needs. | If I prefer to follow the pen tip and image in the same place, drawing on screen matters more to me than having a smaller, screenless setup. Around 21% of consumers prioritise drawing directly on the image. |
| Editing without a computer | Check that the tablet supports the pen you want to use and that the mobile app has the selection and masking features you need. | If you want to edit outside your room too, you’ll need a tablet app and a compatible pen, rather than just an input device for a computer. Around 14% of consumers want to edit photos without a connected computer. |
A pen display shows the image you draw on, but it doesn’t automatically replace the computer running your editing software.
Before buying, check your computer’s ports, the connections required and what comes with the model you’ve chosen.
A pen display may need compatible cables, a power supply or a stand; check which accessories are included with the model.
A stated number of pressure levels doesn’t prove that photo masks will be better. Adobe describes separate tools for hair selections and editable layer masks.
Choose a software workflow that suits your photo-editing task, and assess the input setup separately from its stated number of pressure levels.
A photo mask and a virtual background during a video call are different uses.
First, check the background or blur feature in your video app, along with the system requirements for the feature you want.
If your video app already offers the feature you need, an extra device may be unnecessary for this purpose.
The Wacom One S CTC4110WLW2B is a compact, screenless pen tablet for use with a computer.
Huion offers two different options here: the screenless Inspiroy 2 M and the Kamvas 13 (Gen 3) pen display.
The Artist 12 3rd is a pen display for drawing directly on the image when connected to a computer.
An iPad Air with a compatible Apple Pencil offers a standalone tablet option for editing without a connected computer.
The order below groups products by scenario; it isn’t a performance ranking. It starts with input devices for an existing computer and a small workspace, then moves on to drawing directly on a screen and editing without a connected computer. The order says nothing about mask quality or overall suitability.
| Rank | Product name | Key specifications | Why it’s included | Platform |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Wacom One S CTC4110WLW2B | Bluetooth and a cable option, according to Wacom. | A compact, screenless input option for an existing computer; Wacom eStore identifies this model as CTC4110WLW2B. | Wacom eStore |
| 2 | Huion Inspiroy 2 M | Programmable keys and a scroll wheel, according to Huion. | A screenless option for use with a computer, worth considering if programmable controls suit your editing workflow; Huion describes these features for this model. | Huion |
| 3 | XPPen Artist 12 3rd | Pen display with a pen, shortcut keys and a dial, according to XPPen. | An option for drawing directly on the image, provided your computer supports the required connection. XPPen describes USB-C with DisplayPort output or an alternative connection via USB-A and HDMI. | XPPen |
| 4 | Apple 13-inch iPad Air (M4) Wi-Fi 128 GB - Starlight (2026) | Apple lists Apple Pencil Pro and Apple Pencil (USB-C) as compatible with the iPad Air reviewed here. | A standalone tablet option for editing without a connected computer; the right pen and app will help determine whether it suits your mobile workflow. The product is listed on Joybuy. | Joybuy |
This selection includes screenless pen tablets for use with a computer, a pen display and an Android tablet with pen input. The right setup for you will depend on factors including the space you have, your computer connection and whether you need to work without a computer.
No image available
A screenless pen option for making manual adjustments while working on a computer; this isn’t a standalone tablet.
Active area: 349 × 195 mm. The product name lists Pro Pen 3, 8.192 pressure levels, Bluetooth and USB-C. The description mentions ExpressKeys and a touch ring.
No image available
A screenless option for manual photo adjustments on a computer; its compact design may suit a desk with limited space.
Active area: 152 × 95 mm. The description lists 4.096 pressure levels, four customisable ExpressKeys and a USB connection.
No image available
A screenless pen tablet for use with a computer, ideal if you want pen input in a compact setup.
Active area: A6. The description lists a battery-free pen and Bluetooth 5.1 or USB-C. This isn’t a standalone tablet.
No image available
An Android tablet with pen input for anyone looking for a tablet rather than an input tablet connected to a computer. Check that your chosen app offers the photo-masking features you need.
The product name lists Android 15, a 12.7-inch screen, T-Pen compatibility and 256 GB of storage. The description mentions a pressure-sensitive stylus.
No image available
A pen display for anyone who wants to refine outlines directly on the image on screen; it connects to a computer and isn’t a standalone computer.
Full HD screen and 309 × 174 mm active area. The description lists a battery-free pen and a single USB-C cable.
No, you’ll need to use the background feature in your video app. Zoom offers virtual backgrounds and blur; some options that don’t use a green screen have higher system requirements.
Start with a selection, then refine tricky edges such as hair where needed. Adobe also describes editable layer masks, which let you make adjustments without relying solely on automatic background removal.
Not necessarily. For the XPPen Artist 12 3rd, the manufacturer specifies USB-C with DisplayPort output or an alternative connection via USB-A and HDMI. Check the ports and connections required for your own setup.
When you buy from a business remotely, you’ll usually have a 14-day cooling-off period. You’re also entitled to a product that meets reasonable standards; according to the Dutch government, there’s no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands, and you should contact the seller if a product is faulty. Check the applicable exceptions and terms of sale.