Joybuy Insights

Choosing Dog Treats: How to Find the Right Reward for Every Dog

A bag of dog treats might seem like a quick purchase, but the differences between them are significant. Whether you're looking for training treats for dogs, a long-lasting chew, or dental care snacks for dogs, size, ingredients and shelf life matter far more than flashy packaging.

Many dog owners in the UK fall into the same common traps:

  • A large pack may look like better value, but soft treats quickly lose their freshness once opened.
  • "With chicken" doesn't automatically mean a high chicken content. Always check the ingredients list and the percentage of meat or chicken.
  • A dental treat doesn't replace full dental care. Brands may support their claims with their own research or studies, but don't treat such claims as a guarantee for every dog.
  • A treat that's too big or too hard may not suit your dog's weight, age or chewing behaviour.

The right choice starts with when you plan to use it. Do you want to reward your dog during a walk, let them chew quietly, or offer variety between meals?

Which features of dog treats should you check?

1. Size and texture

For training, small, soft dog treats are the most practical. You can give them quickly without interrupting the exercise for long. A treat that's gone in one or two bites is usually more convenient than a large chew stick.

For treats for small dogs, don't just check the weight on the packet – also look at the dimensions and hardness. A small dog may struggle with a treat designed for medium or large breeds. Conversely, a large dog might swallow a tiny treat in one go.

Chew treats for dogs should always be given under supervision. Watch out for broken pieces and remove the treat when it becomes too small to hold safely.

2. Ingredients and nutritional value

Look at the ingredients in descending order. In chicken dog treats, chicken may be listed as chicken, chicken broth, chicken liver or chicken breast. According to the product information, the INABA Bites Dog Multipack contains chicken, chicken broth, chicken liver and chicken breast, among other ingredients. The packaging also states 14% crude protein, 3% crude fat and 82% moisture.

A high moisture content makes a treat soft, but it also affects shelf life. Once opened, some products need to be refrigerated and used within 24 hours or a few days. Always check the label and adjust the main meal accordingly.

Treats should never replace complete dog food. As a practical guideline, various product information sheets indicate that treats should make up no more than 10% of daily calorie intake. The exact amount depends on your dog's weight, age, activity level and body condition.

3. Packaging, shelf life and usage

A dog treat multipack can be handy if you want to try different flavours or portion sizes. Just pay attention to the number of pieces, total weight and shelf life after opening. A multipack with individually wrapped portions can help prevent waste with soft treats.

Dry biscuits and chew sticks are generally easier to store. Seal opened bags properly and keep them in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight and out of reach of children and pets. If your dog has a known food sensitivity, check the full ingredients list; terms like "meat and animal derivatives" don't always give full details about the source.

Our recommendations by usage profile

Best for: Budget-conscious beginners
PETSNACK DS MIX BONES 12x500g

PETSNACK DS MIX BONES 12x500g

Why this fits the profile: The bulk pack is designed for daily rewarding, training or use in a Kong or puzzle toy. The soft bone shapes come in a variety of flavours.

How this product avoids the trap

The total weight and quantity – 12 packs of 500 grams – are clearly stated. This lets you compare the price per weight rather than just looking at the size of the box.

Key benefit & highlights

12 x 500 grams, soft bone shape and suitable for training sessions. The product information states 11.7% crude protein and 5.9% crude fat.

Best for: Shoppers seeking top quality
INABA Bites Dog Multipack 4 Chicken Varieties 16 pcs.

INABA Bites Dog Multipack 4 Chicken Varieties 16 pcs.

Why this fits the profile: If you want to compare different flavours, you get four chicken varieties in one pack. The small pieces are designed for hand-feeding and use as a topping.

How this product avoids the trap

The ingredients and analytical values are listed, so you can assess the treat based on its contents and moisture level rather than general marketing language.

Key benefit & highlights

16 portions, four chicken varieties, 64 grams total weight and 82% moisture. According to the information, the product must be used within three days of opening.

Best for: Specific use & heavy users
Pedigree Dentastix Medium Multipack 56-Pack 1.44 kg

Pedigree Dentastix Medium Multipack 56-Pack 1.44 kg

Why this fits the profile: This pack is designed for medium-sized dogs weighing 10–25 kg and suits a regular daily treat routine.

How this product avoids the trap

The size is linked to a clear weight range. According to the product information, Pedigree claims a reduction in tartar build-up; this is a brand claim and not a guarantee for every dog.

Key benefit & highlights

56 pieces, 1.44 kg total weight and a variant for medium-sized dogs. Provide fresh water and supervise chewing.

Best for: Small dogs and short training sessions
INABA Fun Bites Dog Chicken Wraps Chicken with Cheese

INABA Fun Bites Dog Chicken Wraps Chicken with Cheese 12g x 8 Packs

Why this fits the profile: The individual 12-gram portions are easy to take along on walks and during training. The combination of a soft outer layer and creamy filling offers a different texture.

How this product avoids the trap

The portions are pre-divided, so you're less likely to overfeed. According to the product information, once opened a portion should be refrigerated and served as soon as possible.

Key benefit & highlights

8 portions of 12 grams, 15.6 kcal per pack according to the product information, and suitable for hand-feeding or training.

Looking for more options?

We've put together a full, up-to-date list of products that fully meet these strict selection criteria and comply with current European safety regulations.

Frequently asked questions about dog treats

How many dog treats can my dog have per day?

Follow the feeding guidelines on the packaging and keep treats to no more than 10% of daily calorie intake where possible. Give a smaller amount if your dog gets little exercise or receives additional food. If necessary, deduct the calories from treats from the main meal.

Which dog treats are suitable for training?

Small, soft training treats for dogs are generally the most practical. They can be eaten quickly and are easy to portion out. Individual portions, like those in some INABA products, are handy on the go. For a dog with sensitivities, always choose based on the ingredients list.

How long do opened dog treats stay fresh?

This varies by product. Soft treats may need to be refrigerated after opening and used within 24 hours to three days. Dry treats last longer if you seal the packaging properly. Always check the shelf life information on the packaging and don't give any product that smells different, has changed colour or become damp.