Who is this guide for?

Players who enjoy long sessions

You want a grip, button layout and power option that work for hours of play. Whether a particular shape feels comfortable is a personal matter. Microsoft and Nintendo describe the features and terms of use for their controllers.

Players who switch between platforms

You might play on a PC, console or mobile device, and want to check which controls work with each device and detective game. Steam and Sony explain that support depends on the game and device.

Players who mainly use clues and menus

You want to use a controller to navigate clues and menus without paying for features your game won’t use. Steam lists different levels of controller support for detective games.

What should you look for when choosing?

First, check support for your device and the specific game. Then compare the grip, power options and extra controls with the way you play.

What to consider What to look for Who is this important to?
Platform and game Check compatibility with your device and the game’s controller support. If I want to be sure I can play my detective game with a controller, I check both before choosing. Around 26% of consumers put compatibility first.
Grip and button reach Consider the grip shape, stick layout and how easy it is to reach frequently used buttons; fit is a personal preference. For a long session, I want to hold the controller comfortably and reach the buttons easily. Around 26% of consumers give hand comfort top priority.
Power and freedom of movement Compare the battery type and charging method with wired play. If you use a cable, consider how far you’ll be from your device. If I don’t want to be interrupted, I weigh up wireless freedom against battery management or a cable running to my seat. Around 21% of consumers put power and freedom of movement first.
Extra controls Check whether the game supports features such as haptics or customisable buttons. I want to control actions and menus easily, but extra features are no use if my game doesn’t use them. Around 16% of consumers put those controls first.
What’s included and cost Check which cable, adapter or batteries are included, and whether you need them for the way you play. If I only want to pay for what my games and setup need, I check the included components and features. Around 11% of consumers give this consideration top priority.

Common buying pitfalls

  • Assuming platform compatibility means full support in every game

    The Steam pages for Return of the Obra Dinn and Detective Hank and the Golden Sneeze list different levels of controller support. With partial support, you may still need a mouse or keyboard.

    Before choosing, check the game page and make sure you can carry out the necessary actions with a controller.

    With partial support, you may need to keep a mouse or keyboard handy as well.

  • Assuming ‘Bluetooth’ means it works with every console

    A Bluetooth connection doesn’t automatically mean a controller will work with every console. The 8BitDo Ultimate 2C Wireless lists Windows and Android, while Nintendo describes the Switch 2-Pro controller as being for Switch 2 only.

    Check the platform list for the exact version, rather than relying on the Bluetooth label alone.

  • Treating a stated battery life as a guaranteed play time

    Nintendo says the estimated battery life of the Switch-Pro controller depends on how it is used. 8BitDo’s figures are based on ideal laboratory conditions.

    Check the power method and what’s included, and make sure you have a way to charge it if you play wirelessly.

  • Thinking the manufacturer’s warranty limits your statutory rights

    ACM ConsuWijzer distinguishes between a manufacturer’s or seller’s warranty and your statutory warranty rights against the seller.

    If something goes wrong, first check what you can reasonably expect from the seller under your statutory warranty rights.

Brands to consider

Xbox / Microsoft

A wireless option for Xbox and supported Windows PCs.

  • Microsoft lists textured grip and button mapping among its controller features.
  • Xbox Support says rechargeable AA batteries can’t be charged inside the controller, so you’ll need a separate charging method.

PlayStation / Sony

DualSense is designed for PS5 and can also connect to supported PCs and other devices.

  • Sony lists haptic feedback and adaptive triggers as features.
  • According to Sony, haptic feedback on PC requires support from the game and a USB connection.

Nintendo

The Switch-Pro controller is designed for Switch and, according to Nintendo, can be used wirelessly with Switch 2. The Switch 2-Pro controller is for Switch 2 only.

  • Nintendo estimates the battery life of both Pro controllers discussed here at around 40 hours, depending on use.
  • The specific features Nintendo lists for the Switch 2-Pro controller aren’t available on the older Switch-Pro controller.

GameSir

The G7 SE is a wired controller for Xbox and Windows PC.

  • GameSir lists Hall Effect sticks and customisable rear buttons as features of the G7 SE.
  • These are manufacturer specifications, not independent evidence of durability or comfort. The cable limits how far you can sit from your device.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C Wireless lists different connection options for Windows and Android.

  • 8BitDo lists 2.4 GHz or wired connections for Windows and Bluetooth for Android.
  • The stated battery life is based on the manufacturer’s ideal laboratory conditions and isn’t a real-world measurement.

Controllers at Joybuy

This selection includes controllers for Xbox, PS5, PC, mobile devices and Nintendo Switch 2, among other platforms. Check which features and connections are supported by your specific model and game.

Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series/PC, Heart Breaker Special Edition

Xbox Wireless Controller – Heart Breaker Special Edition

An option if you’re looking for an Xbox or PC controller. Check support for your specific game too.

View at Joybuy
PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller V3, Remix Green Edion

PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller V3 – Remix Green Edion

For anyone looking for a DualSense for PS5 or one of the listed PC or mobile platforms. Check which features work with each game.

The product name lists PS5, Mac, Android, iOS and PC.

View at Joybuy
BEITONG KP70 Elite Wireless Gaming Controller

BEITONG KP70 Elite Wireless Gaming Controller

An option if you’re looking for a controller for the PC and Nintendo platforms listed in the product name. Check support for your game.

The product name lists six programmable buttons, haptic triggers and adjustable joystick resistance.

View at Joybuy
GameSir G7 Pro Tri-Mode, Shadow Ember

GameSir G7 Pro Tri-Mode – Shadow Ember

An option if you’re considering a G7 Pro for Xbox, PC or mobile. Check which connection works with your device.

Wired play is listed for Xbox. Wireless connections are described for PC and mobile devices.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller, Black

Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller – Black

For anyone looking for an official Pro Controller for Nintendo Switch 2. Check that your game supports the features you want.

The product name lists Nintendo Switch 2.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Will every PC controller work with every detective game?

No, it varies by game. Steam lists full controller support for Return of the Obra Dinn and partial support for Detective Hank and the Golden Sneeze. Check the page for your own game.

Can you use DualSense haptics wirelessly in a PC game?

According to Sony, haptic feedback on PC requires both support from the game and a USB connection. Pairing over Bluetooth alone doesn’t confirm that the feature will work.

How do you charge rechargeable AA batteries for an Xbox controller?

Xbox says rechargeable AA batteries can’t be charged inside the controller. Use the charging method recommended by the battery manufacturer, and check which batteries or charging solution are included with your purchase.

What are your rights in the Netherlands if you’re unhappy with a controller bought online or it breaks too soon?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, online purchases generally come with a 14-day cooling-off period after delivery. If the product is faulty, you also have statutory warranty rights against the seller: the product must meet the standard you can reasonably expect.

Where can you take an unwanted controller in the Netherlands?

According to the Dutch government, you can take old devices that need electricity or batteries to a collection point. If you’re buying a similar new device as a private customer, the old-for-new scheme also applies to online purchases.