Who is this choice relevant to?

Detective game player checking compatibility

You play a particular detective game on PC or console and want to check in advance that both your device and the game work with your chosen controller.

Player without a spare socket for charging

You don’t want to use a separate controller charger, so you’re comparing AA batteries, USB power and charging through a console dock that’s already in use.

Player who wants to play wirelessly from the sofa

You want to sit wherever you like during a relaxed investigation game, while keeping in mind that a wireless controller still needs batteries or charging.

What should you look for when choosing?

First, check that the game and platform are supported. Then compare how the controller is powered and whether a cable or receiver will work with your setup.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important to?
Game and platform support Check that your game supports controller input and that the exact model lists your platforms as compatible. If I play a particular detective game, I want to know whether the controller will actually work with that game on my device. Around 33% of consumers put compatibility first.
Power supply Check whether the model uses AA batteries, a rechargeable battery or USB power, and whether the required connection is available. I want to play without using a separate power socket to charge my controller, so I look at how it gets its power. Around 27% of consumers give this the highest priority.
Freedom to sit where you like Compare the cable length with your playing distance, or check the wireless connection required and whether you’ll need a receiver. If I play from the sofa, I don’t want a cable to limit where I can sit. Around 20% of consumers consider freedom of movement the most important factor.
What’s included Check the battery type and which cables or other accessories are included with the exact version. I want to know in advance what else I’ll need besides the controller. Around 20% of consumers focus most on the total cost of buying and using it.

Buying pitfalls

  • Assuming ‘wireless’ means ‘no need to plan for batteries’

    A wireless controller may still need replaceable batteries or recharging. Xbox states that rechargeable AA batteries aren’t charged inside the controller.

    Before buying, check the battery type, what’s included and where you can charge the controller or its batteries.

    Depending on the version you choose, you may need to buy spare batteries or a separate rechargeable power solution.

  • Assuming that a working connection means the game supports the controller

    A controller connecting to your device doesn’t automatically mean you can use it to play your detective game.

    First, check the information for the specific game, then compare its listed platforms with those for the exact controller model.

  • Assuming every version in a product range has the same connections

    According to 8BitDo, the 8BitDo Ultimate 2C Wireless uses 2.4 GHz on Windows and Bluetooth on Android. That doesn’t mean it supports Bluetooth on Windows.

    Check the connection options for the exact version and make sure you have a suitable port available for a receiver.

Brands to consider when choosing a controller

The features listed below apply to the specific product ranges and versions mentioned, not automatically to every product from the same brand.

Xbox / Microsoft

Xbox describes the wireless Xbox controller as supporting Xbox consoles and Windows PCs. It can use AA batteries.

  • Microsoft lists Bluetooth and support for the platforms mentioned.
  • Xbox states that rechargeable AA batteries aren’t charged in the controller. Check which battery solution suits your needs.

PowerA

According to PowerA, the Enhanced Wired Controller for Xbox Series X|S also works with Xbox One and Windows and uses a USB cable.

  • PowerA lists a detachable 3 m cable and two mappable buttons for this version.
  • The cable uses a port while you play and limits where you can sit. Other models may have different features.

PlayStation / Sony

DualSense is a controller for PS5. PlayStation also describes using it via USB or Bluetooth with certain other devices.

  • PlayStation lists haptic feedback and adaptive triggers for DualSense.
  • Support on other devices depends on the game and connection. For haptic feedback on PC, PlayStation lists USB and game support as requirements.

Nintendo

The Switch Pro Controller is designed for use with Switch; Nintendo also describes pairing it with Switch 2.

  • Nintendo estimates battery life at around 40 hours, depending on use, and describes charging via the dock.
  • The stated battery life is Nintendo’s estimate, not an independent measurement. Check that the dock and game suit your setup.

8BitDo

According to 8BitDo, the Ultimate 2C Wireless is designed for use via 2.4 GHz on Windows and Bluetooth on Android.

  • 8BitDo lists an included USB-A receiver and around 19 hours of use via 2.4 GHz under the manufacturer’s ideal test conditions.
  • For this version, 8BitDo doesn’t list Bluetooth connectivity on Windows or support for Xbox, PS5 or Switch.

Joybuy products

This Joybuy selection focuses on wired Xbox controllers. Check each model to make sure your device and detective game support controller input.

GameSir G7 SE wired Xbox game controller in Dynamic Blue

GameSir G7 SE wired Xbox game controller, Dynamic Blue

A wired option if you use an Xbox Series X/S, Xbox One or Windows 10/11 and have a USB port within cable reach.

Joybuy
Hyperkin Duchess wired Xbox controller in Black

Hyperkin Duchess Wired Controller for Xbox, Black

A wired Xbox controller to consider if you have an accessible USB port and the cable is long enough for your playing distance.

The product information lists Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows 10/11, as well as a detachable 3 m USB-C cable.

Joybuy
GameSir Kaleid Flux wired Xbox game controller in Smoke Transparent RGB

GameSir Kaleid Flux wired Xbox controller, Smoke Transparent RGB

This wired controller may suit a fixed gaming setup with an available USB port.

The product title lists Xbox Series X/S, Xbox One and Windows 10/11. Bear the cable length in mind and check game support.

Joybuy
GameSir T7 wired Xbox controller in Blue

GameSir T7 Wired Xbox Controller, Blue

A wired option if you use a compatible Xbox or Windows device with a free USB port.

The product title lists Hall Effect Joysticks and Triggers, with support for Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One, Windows 10/11 and Steam.

Joybuy
GameSir G7 Pro Tri-Mode controller in Shadow Ember

GameSir G7 Pro Tri-Mode Xbox Wired, PC & Mobile Wireless Controller, Shadow Ember

Worth considering if you want to play wired on Xbox and check the listed wireless options for PC or mobile.

The title lists wired use with Xbox Series X|S and Xbox One, and wireless use with PC, Android and Steam. Check which connection your device uses.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Will every gamepad work with a detective game on PC?

No. Check whether the specific game supports controllers and whether the controller can connect to your PC. Then compare the platforms supported by the game with the information for the exact controller model.

Can you charge rechargeable AA batteries by connecting your Xbox controller to USB?

No. Xbox states that rechargeable AA batteries aren’t charged inside the controller; charge them according to the battery manufacturer’s instructions. A compatible rechargeable Xbox battery for controllers with USB-C is a separate solution.

How can you charge a Switch Pro Controller without a separate controller adapter?

Nintendo describes charging through the USB port on a compatible Switch dock, using the included USB charging cable. The dock must be connected to power, and Nintendo says a full charge takes around six hours.

Should you buy an extended warranty for a controller?

No. Dutch statutory consumer rights apply even if you haven’t bought an extended warranty. ACM ConsuWijzer explains that the retailer is responsible for providing a suitable solution if a product doesn’t perform as you could reasonably expect during normal use.

Which regulatory framework applies to wireless controllers in the Netherlands?

Radio equipment placed on the EU market is covered by the European framework set out in Directive 2014/53/EU, the Radio Equipment Directive. The European Commission describes this framework for placing radio equipment on the market; this alone doesn’t prove that an individual controller meets the applicable requirements.