Who is this choice relevant to?

Student comparing recording takes

You listen to existing versions at one desk and want to judge the differences without changing playback levels or sound settings affecting the comparison. Audacity describes normalisation based on perceived loudness or RMS as ways to bring the volume of audio projects closer together.

Student who also records

As well as listening back, you want to record external signals, so you need inputs and monitoring. Focusrite describes direct monitoring as listening to the input signal; edited files should be played back in software for comparison.

Student who listens with others

You want to listen to one recording with other people and set the level for each pair of headphones. Behringer and Mackie describe their HA400 and HM-4 as headphone distribution amplifiers for one stereo source, with individual level controls.

What should you look for when choosing?

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Comparing recordings fairly Use the same playback chain and headphones, keep sound settings the same and compare at a similar level. Audacity offers normalisation based on perceived loudness or RMS. If I want to assess existing takes at my desk, I don’t want differences in volume to influence my judgement. Around 36% of consumers say fair comparisons are their top buying priority.
Connecting headphones to a laptop Check your laptop output, headphone plug and the relevant specifications of your headphones. Compare output power only at the same load and under the same measurement conditions. If I want to use my own headphones with my laptop, the plugs and output level need to be compatible. Around 29% of consumers give compatibility top priority.
Listening to one recording together Check how many wired pairs of headphones you want to connect, whether the stereo source is compatible and what power supply is required. A headphone distribution amplifier shares one source; don’t assume it provides separate signals for each listener. If I want to listen to the same recording with others, I want to be able to adjust the level for each pair of headphones. Around 21% of consumers say listening together is their main priority.
Recording yourself Decide whether you want to record external signals and check that the necessary inputs and monitoring are available. Direct monitoring is not the same as listening back to an edited file. If I want to record signals as well as compare them, I need recording inputs, not just a headphone output. Around 14% of consumers put recording functionality first.

Common buying mistakes

  • Mistaking a difference in volume for a difference between recordings

    A new amplifier won’t automatically match the volume of different files. As a result, a louder file may sound different when you compare them.

    Use the same playback chain and keep the settings unchanged. If necessary, check the loudness of the files in your playback software; Audacity describes normalisation based on perceived loudness or RMS for this purpose.

  • Expecting a headphone distribution amplifier to provide several sources

    The Behringer HA400 and Mackie HM-4 are both documented as distributing one stereo source. Their individual volume controls don’t mean each listener gets a different recording.

    Decide in advance whether everyone will hear the same recording or whether you want to route separate signals. If it’s the latter, check what additional equipment and connections you’ll need.

    Additional routing equipment may be needed for separate signals.

  • Looking only at the highest output power

    FiiO lists different power ratings for the K11, depending on the output and load. One figure therefore doesn’t tell you what to expect from a different output or headphone load.

    Compare specifications at the same load and under the same measurement conditions. Also check your headphone plug, the source connection and which power supply is included with the version you’re considering.

  • Confusing direct monitoring with listening back to an edited file

    Focusrite describes direct monitoring as listening straight to the input signal. It doesn’t replace playing edited files back in software.

    Use direct monitoring while recording. To compare edited versions, play the files through your software.

Brands and models for reference

FiiO

The K11 is a desktop DAC and headphone amplifier for digital sources.

  • FiiO lists USB, optical and coaxial inputs, three gain settings, a volume knob, and 6.35 mm and 4.4 mm headphone outputs.
  • FiiO lists power ratings for each output and load. According to the manufacturer, the K11 requires an external 12 V/2 A power supply; these are specifications, not an independent listening test.

iFi audio

According to iFi, the ZEN DAC 3 combines a USB DAC with a headphone amplifier.

  • The manual lists USB power, 6.35 mm and 4.4 mm outputs, PowerMatch and XBass+.
  • Keep the settings the same when comparing. The manual states that a separate DC power supply is not included.

Focusrite

The Scarlett 2i2 4th Gen is an audio interface for anyone who wants to record external signals as well as listen back.

  • Focusrite documents two line/instrument inputs, a headphone output, a separate level control and direct monitoring.
  • Direct monitoring is designed for the input signal; use playback software for edited files.

Behringer

The HA400 distributes one stereo source to several pairs of headphones.

  • Behringer lists support for up to four pairs of headphones, each with its own volume control.
  • The stated function is to distribute one source; USB DAC functionality or separate recording inputs are not specified.

Mackie

The HM-4 is designed to distribute one stereo source to several pairs of headphones.

  • Mackie lists support for up to four pairs of headphones, individual level controls and an included 12 V adapter.
  • Check that your existing source is compatible with the input; the stated function is not to provide different signals to individual listeners.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need an audio interface to compare existing recordings?

Not if you’re only listening back to existing files. An interface such as the Scarlett 2i2 4th Gen is useful if you also need recording inputs and monitoring; compare files using playback software.

How can I make comparisons between recordings more meaningful?

Use the same headphones and playback chain, keep the gain and any sound settings the same, and listen at a similar level. Audacity describes normalisation based on perceived loudness or RMS; turn the headphone volume up carefully after connecting your headphones or changing the gain.

Can a Behringer HA400 or Mackie HM-4 play two different recordings at the same time?

The stated functions of both models are designed to distribute one stereo source, with separate level control for each pair of headphones. Check what additional routing you’ll need if listeners want to hear different signals.

What should I check about product safety when buying from a Dutch retailer?

Check that the specific version complies with the applicable European product safety rules and carries the CE marking where required. The rules that apply depend on the product; a listing on a brand’s website does not, by itself, prove that a specific offer complies.

What rights apply to an online purchase in the Netherlands?

For an online purchase by a consumer in the Netherlands, you generally have a 14-day cooling-off period from delivery, subject to applicable exceptions. The product must also be of satisfactory quality; ACM ConsuWijzer explains that the seller must resolve any fault covered by the statutory guarantee.