Listener in a noisy household
You follow the action, score and analysis while the television or conversations at home are still audible. A good seal matters more to you than simply turning up the volume.
If you want to follow cricket commentary while household noise is a distraction, start with well-fitting, noise-isolating in-ear headphones and check that speech is clear at a comfortable volume. If you need to be able to hear the people you live with, choose an option that lets in some ambient sound. Also check the connection and fit: the World Health Organization points out that both volume and listening time matter.
You follow the action, score and analysis while the television or conversations at home are still audible. A good seal matters more to you than simply turning up the volume.
You listen for a long spell of play and want to follow the commentary comfortably, without ear pressure or a flat battery interrupting your listening session.
You want to follow the commentary but also notice when someone speaks to you. Maximum isolation is therefore not necessarily the right choice.
Choose this when: household noise is your biggest problem and you don't need to be available to talk while listening.
The trade-off: the seal depends on the fit and you'll hear less of your surroundings; also check that the connection is compatible with your listening device.
Choose this when: you listen for long periods and want to try different tips or an adjustable way of wearing them.
The trade-off: a sound description such as ‘balanced’ doesn't prove that commentary will be easier to hear in your room; assess the fit and seal separately.
Choose this when: you want to keep hearing the people you live with during the match.
The trade-off: letting in sound can actually make the commentary harder to hear if voices or the television dominate the room.
Choose this when: freedom of movement and the option to switch to ambient sound are important to you.
The trade-off: you'll need to keep them charged. Which? says ANC is mainly helpful against low, constant humming; it doesn't guarantee that conversations from housemates will be cancelled out.
| Concern | What to look for when buying | Who is this important to? |
|---|---|---|
| Blocking out household noise | Check that the tips create a good seal and see which sizes are included; noise-reduction claims are no guarantee for your home. | If I want to follow the commentary while household noise is a distraction, a good seal is my first priority. Around 36% of consumers say isolation is their main buying priority. |
| Hearing speech comfortably | Assess voices separately from music and, if possible, listen to a speech sample on the device you usually use. | I want to follow the match comfortably, so I look beyond claims about bass or sound quality in general. Around 29% of consumers prioritise speech reproduction. |
| Fit for long listening sessions | Look at the choice of tips and whether the fit works for your ears; a secure seal should also remain comfortable. | For a long listening session, I want a fit that stays comfortable. Around 21% of consumers say long-wearing comfort is their most important consideration. |
| Connection and staying approachable | Check the connection on your listening device and decide how much of your surroundings you want to keep hearing. | I don't want connection problems while listening, and sometimes I need to hear when someone speaks to me. Around 14% of consumers give connection or staying approachable top priority. |
The figures quoted by Etymotic and Shure are manufacturers' claims. The seal depends on the fit; these claims don't show which model will best reduce household noise for you.
Compare the available tip sizes and check whether you can follow the commentary at a comfortable volume.
A close-fitting seal also reduces how well you can hear sounds you want to hear around you. A monitor with an ambient filter lets sound in, which can in turn make the commentary harder to hear.
Before choosing, decide whether listening in peace or staying in touch with the people you live with matters more to you.
A wired connection won't automatically work with every listening device. When buying online, conditions for hygienic products may also apply.
Check the output on your device and, before breaking any seal, ask which returns conditions apply.
Depending on the connection or fit, you may need a suitable adapter or a different size of tip.
The wired ER2SE is worth comparing if passive isolation and a sound signature that Etymotic describes as flat are important to you.
The wired SE215 comes with sealing tips in different sizes and a detachable cable.
The IE 200 is a wired option to compare if you want to assess different tips and an adjustable way of wearing them.
The AM Pro X10 is another option for anyone who wants to keep hearing ambient sound while using an IEM.
The wired IER-M500 is another model to compare if a secure fit is important to you.
These are in-ear headphones to compare if you want to reduce household noise: wireless models with ANC or noise cancelling, and a wired USB-C option. Which? notes that ANC can mainly help with low, constant humming; it isn't guaranteed to cancel out conversations from housemates.
No image available
An option to compare if you're looking for wireless earbuds with ANC for a noisy environment.
The product information specifies Bluetooth 6.0 and a charging case. Its ANC performance against speech has not been established.
No image available
A wireless option to compare if you want ANC and the ability to adjust the sound settings.
The product specifications state 6 hours of playback with ANC on and up to 26 hours with the charging case, plus an adjustable 9-band equaliser.
No image available
A wired option to compare if you don't want to charge earbuds and would like to try different fit accessories.
The product information specifies a USB-C connection, three sizes of ear tips and two sizes of stability wings. Check that your listening device supports USB-C.
No image available
A wireless option to compare if you want ANC and value parts that you can replace yourself.
The product information states up to 8 hours of playback per charge with ANC off and up to 40 hours with the charging case; the longer total playback time includes the case.
No image available
A wireless option to compare if you want noise cancelling and cable-free listening.
The product information specifies Bluetooth 5.4 and a USB-C charging case. Its effect on conversations at home has not been established.
Don't assume that it does. Which? highlights low, constant motor hum as the type of noise ANC can help with; check the fit and how well it works in your home.
Try a suitable size without forcing it if it causes pain. Shure recommends a good seal for the SE215 and explains how to keep the earbuds and tips clean and dry; follow the care instructions for other models. Don't automatically turn up the volume when noise is distracting: according to the World Health Organization, both volume and listening time matter.
According to ACM ConsuWijzer, online product purchases generally come with a cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery. ACM lists an exception for hygienic products that have been taken out of their packaging; before buying, ask whether and why that exception applies to the ear tips you've chosen. If a product is faulty, the seller is responsible for the statutory guarantee, which is separate from any manufacturer's guarantee.
The Shure SE215 and Sennheiser IE 200 mentioned above have a 3.5 mm cable and don't need charging as wired earbuds. Check that your phone, radio or other listening device has a compatible connection. Wireless earbuds have a battery; Which? lists battery life as something to consider.