Who is this guide for?

Group playing on one Switch

You want to know how many separate controllers the active chefs need, and whether individual Joy-Cons work with your version of the game. For Overcooked! 2 on Switch, Nintendo says each chef can use one Joy-Con.

PC players with guests

You want to connect multiple input devices without assuming that every controller will work with both your PC and your chosen game. Steam lists controller support for PlateUp!, but check support for your specific controller.

Host with remote spectators

You want to distinguish between watching and actually playing before buying extra controllers. Steam Remote Play Together is designed for games that support this feature.

What should you look for when choosing?

Start with the game and device. Then count only the active players and decide whether you’ll be playing locally or remotely.

What to consider What to look for Who this matters to
Compatibility Check the device, game version and supported inputs. Also check how the controller connects. If I play on PC or console, I want to be sure the controller works with both my device and game; around 36% of consumers put compatibility first.
Active players Check the player limit and permitted controller set-up for your version of the game; count only those controlling the game. When several people are gathered around one screen, I want to match the controllers to those actually playing, not those watching; around 29% of consumers prioritise having enough controls for active players.
Room to move Consider how far away you’ll be sitting, where the cable will run and whether you’ll need to play with the console docked. When players and spectators are sitting close together, I don’t want a cable running across a walkway; around 21% of consumers focus most on having room to move.
Power and accessories Check how the controller is powered or charged, and whether the required cable or receiver is included. Before I order, I want to know what extra connections or charging solutions I’ll need; around 14% of consumers make these requirements their first consideration.

Controller buying pitfalls for cooking games

  • Buying controllers for everyone watching

    The number of spectators isn’t the same as the number of players actually controlling the game. According to Nintendo, the Switch version of Overcooked! 2 supports up to four chefs.

    Decide who’s playing, then check the player limit and controller set-up for your version of the game.

  • Assuming Bluetooth means universal compatibility

    A wireless connection doesn’t guarantee that a controller will work with every device or game. 8BitDo lists Bluetooth for Android and 2.4 GHz or a cable for Windows with the Ultimate 2C Wireless; Nintendo says Joy-Con 2 only works with Switch 2.

    Check the full model and connection mode for the device and game you’ll be using.

  • Choosing a wired Switch controller without checking the dock

    PowerA says its Wired Controller for Nintendo Switch can only be used when the Switch is docked.

    Check whether you’ll be playing with the console docked, and keep the cable away from walkways.

    You may need a different controller to play without the console docked.

  • Assuming original Joy-Cons charge on Switch 2

    Nintendo says original Joy-Cons can connect wirelessly to Switch 2, but can’t be attached to the console or charged directly by it.

    Check how you’ll charge the Joy-Cons before buying.

    Nintendo says you’ll need an original Switch or a compatible charging accessory.

Brands and controller ranges to compare

Nintendo

Joy-Cons are a relevant option for individual players on Switch; check which type of Joy-Con and console you have.

  • For Overcooked! 2 on Switch, Nintendo says each chef can use one Joy-Con.
  • Original Joy-Cons work wirelessly with Switch 2, but can’t be attached to it or charged directly by it. Joy-Con 2 only works with Switch 2.

Xbox

The Xbox Wireless Controller is one option for a supported Xbox or PC set-up.

  • Microsoft lists support for certain consoles and PCs.
  • Compatibility also depends on the device, game and version; check the power requirements and whether a cable is needed.

PlayStation

DualSense is suited to a PS5 set-up and can also be used with supported PC games.

  • PlayStation documents connection via USB-C or Bluetooth for supported devices.
  • Connecting the controller doesn’t mean that every PC game or DualSense feature will automatically be supported.

PowerA

The Wired Controller for Nintendo Switch is a wired option for playing with the Switch docked.

  • PowerA lists a detachable 3 m cable and compatibility with Switch 2.
  • PowerA says this model is designed for use only when the Switch is docked; motion controls, HD rumble and amiibo NFC aren’t supported.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C Wireless is an option for PC players who want to use one of the listed Windows connections.

  • 8BitDo lists 2.4 GHz or a cable for Windows, and Bluetooth for Android.
  • Don’t assume these connection options mean it’s compatible with Switch or PS5.

Joybuy controllers for different gaming set-ups

These product options suit PC and Xbox, PS5, Switch and Switch 2 set-ups. For each game and version, check whether the controller and connection method are supported.

Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series/PC – Ice Breaker Special Edition

Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series/PC – Ice Breaker Special Edition

Suited to active players on a PC or Xbox that supports this controller.

The product information lists Windows 10/11, Xbox Wireless, Bluetooth and USB-C. Check support in your chosen game and which connection accessories are included with this version.

View at Joybuy
HORI Wired Controller HORIPAD Turbo for Switch and Switch 2 – Pokemon Eevee Cottage Core Edition

HORI Wired Controller HORIPAD Turbo for Switch and Switch 2 – Pokemon Eevee Cottage Core Edition

Suited to active players who want to play wired on a Switch or Switch 2.

The product information lists programmable rear buttons and a Turbo function. It also says that the USB cable isn’t included.

View at Joybuy
PS5 DualSense Wireless Controller V3 – Cosmic Red

PS5 DualSense Wireless Controller V3 – Cosmic Red

Suited to active PS5 players who need a DualSense controller.

The product information lists USB-C charging, haptic feedback and adaptive triggers.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Joy-Con Controller Pair – Neon Red/Neon Blue

Nintendo Switch Joy-Con Controller Pair – Neon Red/Neon Blue

Suited to Switch players who want to use individual Joy-Cons as controllers.

This is a pair; the product information says that each Joy-Con can be used as a separate controller. For Overcooked! 2 on Switch, Nintendo says each chef can use one Joy-Con.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con 2 Pair – Light Blue/Light Red

Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con 2 Pair – Light Blue/Light Red

Suited to active players looking for Joy-Con 2 for Nintendo Switch 2.

The product title lists Switch 2 as the platform; Nintendo says Joy-Con 2 can only be used with Switch 2.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do four spectators need four controllers too?

No, only players actually controlling the game need a controller. For Overcooked! 2 on Switch, Nintendo says up to four chefs can play, each using one Joy-Con; spectators who aren’t playing don’t need a controller.

Can friends play remotely using one PC copy of the game?

That’s possible with games that support Steam Remote Play Together. Steam lists this feature for Overcooked! 2 and PlateUp!; one player runs the game and invites others, so check whether the feature is available with your version of the game.

How do you use original Joy-Cons with Switch 2?

You can pair original Joy-Cons wirelessly with Switch 2, but Nintendo says they can’t be attached to the console or charged directly by it. You’ll need an original Switch or a compatible charging accessory to charge them.

What safety mark should a controller sold in the Netherlands have?

According to the Dutch Authority for Digital Infrastructure, electrical and electronic equipment must have the correct CE marking. Check the marking on the specific version of the controller.

Who can help if a controller breaks too soon during normal use?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, the retailer is responsible for the statutory guarantee in the Netherlands. What you could reasonably expect from a product is taken into account; there isn’t simply one fixed time limit for every product.