Who is this guide for?

Switch players inviting extra chefs

You want to know how many individual controllers you need for the same Switch and game before buying another pair. Nintendo says that Overcooked! 2 on Switch supports one Joy-Con per player.

Housemates with limited space to play

You want to play together on one screen and weigh up whether wireless play is more convenient than running a cable across the room. The wired PowerA controller we looked at has a 3 m cable and, according to the manufacturer, is designed for use with the Switch in its dock.

Players looking for one gamepad to use across several games

You want to use a full gamepad with your existing console or PC. So check that the exact model is compatible and that the game supports the controller features you want.

What should you look for?

First, check that the controller works with your system and game. Then make sure there are enough controls for everyone and that the connection suits your space.

Buying priority What should you check? Who is this important for?
Compatibility Check your console or PC, the game version and the controller’s full model name. Nintendo says that Joy-Con 2 only work with Switch 2. If you’re buying a controller for a specific system, you’ll want to make sure it works with your game. Around 36% of consumers prioritise compatibility.
Controls for everyone Count the players and the working controllers you already have. Check whether your game supports individual Joy-Con. If you’re having guests over to play, you’ll want to know whether everyone can use a single Joy-Con before buying extra gamepads. Around 29% of consumers prioritise having enough controls for all players.
Cables and playing space Think about where everyone will sit and whether a 3 m cable can be positioned safely. The wired PowerA controller we looked at is designed for use with the Switch in its dock. In a small room, you’ll want to play together without a controller cable crossing a seating or walking route. Around 21% of consumers prioritise having a clear space to play.
Power and aftercare Check how your model is powered and which accessories it needs. If it develops a fault, keep information about your rights when dealing with the retailer. If you want your controller ready for when guests arrive, factor in batteries, charging and what to do if it develops a fault. Around 14% of consumers put power and aftercare first.

Common buying mistakes

  • Buying an extra pair without counting your Joy-Con

    For Overcooked! 2 on Switch, Nintendo says each player can use one individual Joy-Con. If you already have enough working Joy-Con, you may not need another pair.

    Count the players and test the Joy-Con you already own with the game version you want to play before buying more.

  • Buying Joy-Con 2 for the original Switch

    Nintendo says that Joy-Con 2 only work with Switch 2, so they are not a replacement for controllers on the original Switch.

    Check which generation of Switch you have and compare it with the controller’s compatibility.

  • Choosing a wired Switch controller for play away from the dock

    According to the manufacturer, the PowerA Enhanced Wired Controller we looked at is designed for use only when the Switch is in its dock.

    Consider how you play and position the cable so it doesn’t cross a seating or walking route.

  • Replacing a Joy-Con straight away if it has response problems

    The Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets describes Nintendo’s commitment to repair Joy-Con with drift or response problems free of charge, following the procedure set out by Nintendo, even after the statutory warranty period.

    Check Nintendo’s current repair terms, and contact the retailer too if your product isn’t working as it should.

Brands to consider

Nintendo

Joy-Con are a good option for individual controls on Switch; Joy-Con 2 are a separate range for Switch 2.

  • Nintendo says that the Switch version of Overcooked! 2 supports one Joy-Con per player.
  • Joy-Con 2 don’t work with the original Switch. Original Joy-Con can connect wirelessly to Switch 2, but can’t be attached to the system; you’ll need a compatible system or accessory to charge them.

Xbox

The Xbox Wireless Controller we looked at is a full gamepad for supported Xbox consoles and Windows PCs.

  • For the version we looked at, Microsoft lists support for Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows 10/11.
  • The battery tests mentioned use standard AA batteries; they don’t guarantee a set battery life in every situation.

PlayStation

Sony says the DualSense for PS5 can also connect to devices including Windows PCs via USB-C or Bluetooth.

  • You can connect it to a PC via USB-C or Bluetooth.
  • A PC connection doesn’t mean every feature will be available in every game. Check whether your cooking game supports them.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C Bluetooth is a full gamepad for Switch; the Ultimate 2C Wireless is a separate version for Windows and Android.

  • For the specified firmware version, 8BitDo lists Switch 2 compatibility for the Bluetooth version.
  • The Wireless version is a different model: for Windows, the manufacturer specifies 2.4 GHz or a wired connection.

PowerA

The Enhanced Wired Controller we looked at is a wired gamepad for Switch when the console is in its dock.

  • The manufacturer specifies a detachable 3 m USB cable, so no batteries are needed.
  • According to the manufacturer, this model is designed for use only with the Switch in its dock and does not support features including motion controls or HD rumble.

Joybuy products

This selection includes full gamepads for different systems and individual Joy-Con for Nintendo Switch and Switch 2. Before buying, check that the specific controller and the game you want to play work with your system.

PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller V3, Remix Green

PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller V3 – Remix Green

A full wireless gamepad for anyone looking for a controller for PlayStation 5.

The product name also lists Mac, Android, iOS and PC; check that your specific game and the features you want are supported.

View at Joybuy
GameSir Cyclone 2 Multiplatform Controller, Black-Bundle Edition

GameSir Cyclone 2 Multiplatform Controller – Black-Bundle Edition

A full gamepad for anyone looking for a controller for several of the systems listed; check that it’s supported by the specific game you want to play.

The product name lists PC, Switch, iOS and Android, TMR sticks, a 1000 Hz polling rate, Hall and Micro triggers, RGB lighting and a charging dock.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Pro Controller, Black

Nintendo Switch Pro Controller – Black

A full gamepad for anyone who plays on a Nintendo Switch and prefers to use a Pro Controller.

Check that this controller is compatible with your console and the cooking game you want to play.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Joy-Con pair, Neon Green/Neon Pink

Nintendo Switch Joy-Con pair – Neon Green/Neon Pink

A pair of individual controllers for anyone who wants to invite extra players to join in on Nintendo Switch. Nintendo says that a Joy-Con can be used on its own in supported games.

Check how many players your game supports and count the Joy-Con you already own.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con 2 pair, Light Blue/Light Red

Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con 2 pair – Light Blue/Light Red

An extra pair of Joy-Con 2 for anyone looking for individual controls on Nintendo Switch 2.

Nintendo says that Joy-Con 2 only work with Switch 2. Check whether your game supports local multiplayer with these controllers.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do you need to buy two full controllers straight away to play Overcooked! 2 on one Switch?

No, not necessarily: Nintendo says that the Switch version supports one individual Joy-Con per player, for up to four players. Count the Joy-Con you already have and check which controls another cooking game supports.

Can you use Joy-Con and Joy-Con 2 interchangeably with your Switch?

Not both ways. According to Nintendo, Joy-Con 2 only work with Switch 2; original Joy-Con can connect wirelessly to Switch 2, but can’t be attached to the console. You’ll need a compatible system or accessory to charge original Joy-Con on Switch 2.

How do you get an extra controller ready for a gaming session?

First, check that your controller’s connection is suitable for your system and pair it in advance. For the wired PowerA controller we looked at, this means playing with the Switch in its dock; if you’re using individual Joy-Con, check beforehand that they’re sufficiently charged.

Who can help if a new controller develops a fault too soon during normal use?

In the Netherlands, the retailer is your point of contact under the statutory warranty if the product doesn’t meet the reasonable expectations you had when buying it. A manufacturer’s warranty or paid extended warranty doesn’t replace this right.

Can you always return a controller bought online within 14 days?

The Dutch government says that online purchases usually come with a 14-day cooling-off period. Check the retailer’s information and the terms that apply to your purchase before buying; “usually” isn’t an unconditional promise for every transaction.