Who is this controller choice relevant to?

Switch group with limited seating space

You want to know whether your existing or extra Joy-Con controllers can be used individually, so everyone has their own controls without needing more full-size controllers than necessary. This depends on the Switch model and the game. Nintendo UK explains that a Joy-Con 2 can be used horizontally as a separate controller in supported software.

PC or Xbox group

You’re looking for a suitable game controller for each player and weighing up wireless play against a wired connection. Xbox lists Xbox Wireless for consoles and Bluetooth for supported Windows PCs; check compatibility with your specific device and game.

PS5 group or mixed PC group

You want to make use of your existing DualSense controllers and, if playing on PC, check in advance that your device and game support the controller. PlayStation Support explains how to connect via Bluetooth and USB on supported devices; features may vary by game and device.

What should you look for in controllers for local arena battles?

Start by checking platform and game compatibility, then work out how many separate sets of controls you need. Only then consider which connection suits the space available.

Separate Joy-Con 2 controllers

Choose this when: you’re playing on Switch 2 and the game supports using Joy-Con 2 controllers separately. Nintendo UK lists horizontal use as a separate controller.

Bear in mind: a pair of Joy-Con won’t automatically work for two players in every game; Joy-Con 2 is not compatible with the original Switch.

Full-size wireless controller for Xbox or PC

Choose this when: each player needs a full-size controller and you’re playing on Xbox or a supported Windows PC. Xbox lists Xbox Wireless for consoles and Bluetooth for supported PCs.

Bear in mind: check the connection for your exact device and make sure you have the power supply needed for each controller.

DualSense for PS5 or PC

Choose this when: you’re playing on PS5, or on a PC where both the device and game support the controller. PlayStation Support explains how to connect via Bluetooth and USB on supported devices.

Bear in mind: not every PC game uses all DualSense features, so check compatibility for each game.

Another full-size Switch controller

Choose this when: you’re playing on Switch and would rather give each player a controller with two grips than use separate Joy-Con.

Bear in mind: check the exact version. The Bluetooth and Wireless versions of the 8BitDo Ultimate 2C have different platform compatibility.

Wired controller for Xbox or PC

Choose this when: there’s a suitable connection point close to the seats and you’d rather not use a wireless connection.

Bear in mind: plan the cable route around players and walkways before choosing a wired option.

Consideration What should you check? Who does this matter to?
System and game compatibility Note your console or PC, the exact controller version, supported connection methods and the game’s controller requirements. If I want to avoid buying a controller that won’t work with my system or game, I check compatibility in advance. Around 33% of consumers rank compatibility as their top priority.
Separate controls for everyone Check the game’s maximum player count, permitted controller layouts and how many usable controllers you already have. If every player needs their own controls, I look beyond the number of controllers and check the game’s play style too. Around 27% of consumers rank having enough separate inputs as their top priority.
Room to move between players Check where the system and seats are positioned, and whether a cable can be kept safely out of the way. If players are sitting close together, I want to know whether a cable will get in the way. Around 20% of consumers rank having room to move freely as their top priority.
Everything the group needs Count how many controllers you’re missing and check the power and charging method for the exact version. If I need controllers for several players, I want to know what we can already use and what power supply each one needs. Around 20% of consumers rank the total group purchase as their top priority.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming a pair of Joy-Con will always work for two players

    Using each Joy-Con horizontally depends on the game, so the number of controllers alone doesn’t tell you how many players can join in.

    Before buying, check the play style and the buttons each player needs.

  • Confusing the 8BitDo Ultimate 2C Bluetooth with the Ultimate 2C Wireless

    The Bluetooth and Wireless versions have different platform compatibility.

    Compare the full model name and list of supported platforms, not just “Ultimate 2C”.

  • Assuming Switch 2 compatibility includes every feature

    According to PowerA, the Enhanced Wireless version reviewed here lacks, among other things, a C button, HD rumble, IR and amiibo NFC.

    Before choosing this version, check which features your game actually uses.

  • Choosing a wired option without checking the seating layout

    In a small seating area, a controller cable may run between players or along a walkway.

    Plan where the connection will be and how the cable will run before choosing wired over wireless.

Brands to compare for this choice

Nintendo

Joy-Con 2 is designed for separate use in supported Switch 2 games.

  • Nintendo UK explains that a Joy-Con 2 can be used horizontally as a separate controller, depending on the software.
  • Joy-Con 2 is not compatible with the original Switch. Existing Switch Joy-Con cannot be attached to or charged through Switch 2.

Microsoft Xbox

The Xbox Wireless Controller is a full-size controller for Xbox systems and supported Windows PCs.

  • Xbox lists Xbox Wireless for consoles and Bluetooth for supported PCs.
  • Check the connection and power supply for the exact version; compatibility with Xbox or Windows doesn’t automatically mean it works with Switch or PS5.

Sony PlayStation

DualSense is designed for PS5 and may also be suitable for supported PC games.

  • PlayStation Support explains how to connect via Bluetooth and USB on supported devices.
  • Not every game or device supports all DualSense features, so check compatibility for the combination you plan to use.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C Bluetooth and Ultimate 2C Wireless are different versions with different platform compatibility.

  • For the Bluetooth version, 8BitDo lists Switch compatibility and Switch 2 support from system version 20.1.1.
  • 8BitDo specifies the Wireless version for Windows and Android; check the full model name before ordering.

PowerA

The Enhanced Wireless Controller Rechargeable is a full-size controller for use with Switch.

  • PowerA lists Switch 2 compatibility for the version reviewed here.
  • PowerA states that this version does not support a C button, HD rumble, IR or amiibo NFC.

GameSir

The G7 SE is a wired controller for Xbox and PC.

  • GameSir describes the G7 SE as featuring Hall Effect sticks.
  • A manufacturer’s claim about resistance to stick drift is not an independent measure of product lifespan. If you choose a wired controller, remember to plan the cable route too.

Controllers on Joybuy for different gaming systems

This selection of Joybuy products includes wireless controllers for Switch, Xbox, PC and PlayStation. Check that each version is compatible with your setup and the games you play.

Turtle Beach Afterglow Wave wireless controller, transparent

Turtle Beach Afterglow Wave Wireless Controller – Transparent

For anyone looking for a full-size wireless controller for one of the Switch versions listed.

The product name lists Bluetooth, TMR sticks, 40-hour battery life, four RGB modes and two programmable buttons.

Joybuy
Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series and PC, Heart Breaker Special Edition

Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series/PC – Heart Breaker Special Edition

For anyone looking for a full-size controller for Xbox Series or PC.

If you’re using it with a PC, check that your chosen game supports this controller and find out what power supply the version requires.

Joybuy
Black wireless game controller for PS4 and PC

Wireless game controller for PS4 and PC

For anyone looking for a wireless controller for the PS4 or PC setup listed.

Before buying, check that your specific device and game support this controller.

Joybuy
PlayStation DualSense wireless controller, Grand Theft Auto VI White Limited Edition

PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller – Grand Theft Auto VI White Limited Edition

For anyone looking for a DualSense for PS5, or for a supported device and game on PC, Mac or mobile.

On PC, haptic feedback and adaptive triggers are only available in compatible games; some games may require a USB connection.

Joybuy
Game controller with dual vibration and gyroscope for Switch and PC

Game controller with dual vibration and gyroscope for Switch and PC

For anyone looking for a controller for the Switch or PC setup listed.

Before choosing it for local multiplayer, check that your game and specific system support the controller.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions about controllers for local multiplayer

Are two Joy-Con 2 controllers always enough for two players?

No, it depends on the game. Nintendo UK says that on Switch 2, each Joy-Con 2 can be used horizontally as a separate controller if the software supports that play style. So check the controller layout for your chosen game; a Switch 2 comes with one left and one right Joy-Con 2.

Can I use and charge my old Switch Joy-Con on a Switch 2?

Nintendo says existing Switch Joy-Con can be used wirelessly with Switch 2, but cannot be attached to or charged through the system. Check which other charging options are suitable for your controllers.

How do I connect a controller for PC gaming?

This depends on the exact model and game. Xbox lists Bluetooth for supported Windows PCs with the Xbox Wireless Controller; PlayStation Support lists Bluetooth and USB for DualSense on supported devices. Also check that your chosen game supports the controller.

What are my rights in the Netherlands if an online controller purchase isn’t suitable or breaks too soon?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, online purchases usually come with a statutory cooling-off period that ends 14 days after delivery. You’re also covered by the legal guarantee: if a product breaks sooner than reasonably expected when used normally, the seller must resolve the issue free of charge under the applicable terms. A manufacturer’s warranty does not replace this legal right.