Who is this relevant to?

Switch player sharing a bedroom

You play puzzle games on Switch and want to avoid vibration without losing controller functionality. Nintendo explains how to turn off HD Rumble on the original Switch.

PC or Xbox player looking for precise controls

You want to check that the game, platform and D-pad work together first; wireless convenience is less important than controls that work. Xbox and 8BitDo explain the platform-specific features and compatibility of their controllers.

Player who wants to avoid charging breaks

You’re considering a cable to avoid charging or changing batteries, and can check in advance whether the cable’s length and route to the screen will work for you. PowerA lists a 3 m cable for the Switch model reviewed.

What should you look for?

If you’re considering a controller for puzzle games in a shared bedroom, these are four possible priorities to focus on.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important to?
Compatibility Check the exact platform and model, and whether your game supports controller input. I want to know first whether this controller works with my puzzle game on my device; around 34% of consumers put compatibility first.
Disturbance for your roommate Check whether vibration can be turned off, and assess button noise separately. If I share a room, I want to be able to reduce vibration without assuming the buttons are quiet; around 33% of consumers put minimising disturbance first.
D-pad and controls Look at the button layout and the controls the game actually uses. I want a D-pad that suits the controls in my puzzle game, not just extra features; around 20% of consumers consider the layout the main priority.
Power and cable Check the cable length, dock requirements and where the cable will run near the bed or walkway. I don’t want to have to charge while playing, or I’d rather not have a cable running past my bed; around 13% of consumers consider power and cables the most important factor.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming no vibration means quiet buttons

    PowerA says the wired model reviewed has no HD Rumble, but that doesn’t tell you how much noise the physical buttons make.

    Assess button noise separately. Choose a controller with switchable vibration or no vibration function only if that’s the feature you want to avoid.

  • Treating the two 8BitDo Ultimate 2C versions as the same model

    8BitDo lists Windows and Android compatibility for the Ultimate 2C Wireless, and Switch compatibility for the Ultimate 2C Bluetooth. The manufacturer describes the Wireless version’s D-pad as clicky, so neither version has been shown to be quiet.

    Check the full model name, platform and connection type before choosing.

  • Buying a wired Switch controller to play without the dock

    PowerA says the Wired Controller model reviewed can only be used when the Switch is in its dock.

    Check the dock requirement, cable length and cable route before ordering.

  • Seeing paid extra cover as a replacement for your legal rights

    An extended warranty may come at an additional cost. According to ACM ConsuWijzer, a commercial guarantee is in addition to your statutory warranty.

    Compare the extra cover with your rights against the retailer before paying for it.

Brands to compare

Nintendo

The official Switch Pro Controller is designed for players who want a separate D-pad and Switch features.

  • Nintendo lists motion controls, HD Rumble and amiibo functionality. You can turn off controller vibration on the original Switch.
  • Turning off vibration doesn’t mean physical button presses are quiet.

PowerA

The wired Switch model reviewed is designed for use with a docked Switch when you don’t need wireless play or vibration.

  • PowerA lists a detachable 3 m cable for this model.
  • PowerA says it doesn’t have HD Rumble, motion controls or amiibo support. These details apply to the Wired Controller model reviewed, not all PowerA controllers.

Xbox

The Xbox Wireless Controller is designed for Xbox and compatible Windows PCs.

  • Microsoft lists Bluetooth, button mapping and a hybrid D-pad.
  • Check that your chosen game supports the controller, and bear in mind the power requirements of the version you choose.

PlayStation

DualSense is designed for PS5 and PC games that support the controller.

  • PlayStation describes USB and Bluetooth connections with supported devices.
  • According to PlayStation, haptic feedback on PC requires game support and a USB connection; not every feature works on every device.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C product range includes different versions for Windows and Android, or for Switch.

  • The listed platforms and connection types vary by version.
  • 8BitDo describes the D-pad on the Windows and Android version as clicky; this doesn’t show that the controller is quiet or universally compatible.

Joybuy products

This selection includes wired controllers for Nintendo Switch systems and Xbox or PC, as well as a wireless Nintendo Switch Pro Controller. Check that each product is supported by your game and device.

HORI Wired Controller HORIPAD Turbo for Switch and Switch 2 – Green

HORI Wired Controller HORIPAD Turbo for Switch and Switch 2 – Green

A good fit if you’re looking for a wired controller for Switch systems and don’t want to charge it while playing.

The product information lists compatibility with Switch, Switch 2 and Switch OLED, programmable rear buttons and a Turbo function. The USB connection means you’ll need a cable while playing.

Joybuy
HORI Wired Controller HORIPAD Turbo for Switch and Switch 2 – Pokémon Eevee Cottage Core Edition

HORI Wired Controller HORIPAD Turbo for Switch and Switch 2 – Pokémon Eevee Cottage Core Edition

A good fit if you’re looking for a wired Switch controller with programmable buttons.

The product information lists compatibility with Switch, Switch 2 and Switch OLED, programmable rear buttons and a Turbo function. A USB cable is not included; a standard cable is required.

Joybuy
HORI Wired Controller HORIPAD Turbo for Switch 2 – Black

HORI Wired Controller HORIPAD Turbo for Switch 2 – Black

A good fit if you’re looking for a wired controller for Switch systems with customisable controls.

The product information lists compatibility with Switch, Switch 2 and Switch OLED, programmable buttons and a Turbo function. The USB connection means you’ll need a cable while playing.

Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Pro Controller – Black

Nintendo Switch Pro Controller – Black

A good fit if you want to play wirelessly on Switch and prefer a separate D-pad.

Nintendo lists motion controls, HD Rumble and amiibo functionality. You can turn off controller vibration on the original Switch; this won’t affect the sound of the buttons.

Joybuy
HyperX Clutch Gladiate RGB Gaming Controller for Xbox and PC

HyperX Clutch Gladiate RGB Gaming Controller (Xbox/PC)

A good fit if you’re looking for a wired controller for Xbox or PC.

The product information lists compatibility with Xbox One, Xbox Series X|S and PC, customisable rear buttons and force feedback features. The USB connection means you’ll need a cable while playing.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do I turn off controller vibration on the original Nintendo Switch?

Open System Settings and go to Controllers and Sensors to turn off Controller Vibration. Nintendo says this applies to all synced controllers. The setting won’t change the sound of physical buttons.

Can I use the wired PowerA Switch controller reviewed without the dock?

No. PowerA says this model is designed for use only while the Switch is in its dock. Check the usage requirements for other models.

Do all DualSense features work automatically on PC over Bluetooth?

No, the features depend on the device and game. PlayStation says haptic feedback on PC requires USB and only works when supported by the game.

What can I do if my controller breaks too quickly during normal use?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, if a product breaks sooner than you could reasonably expect with normal use, the retailer must put it right free of charge, for example by repairing or replacing it, or giving you a refund. A commercial guarantee does not replace your statutory warranty.

Where can I dispose of an old controller or used batteries?

The Dutch government lists collection points for electrical appliances and a take-back scheme when you buy a similar appliance; check whether the scheme applies to your situation. Used batteries must not go in general waste and can be taken to shops that sell batteries, among other places.