Who is this buying guide for?

You’re looking for the right console version

You want to practise on your existing Switch, PlayStation, Xbox or Windows PC. So check the compatibility of the exact version: models with similar names may be designed for different systems. 8BitDo and HORI list separate versions for different systems.

You want to practise a particular directional movement

You’re choosing between an arcade joystick and individual direction buttons. First decide which movement you want to practise, then check that your game’s controls are suitable. 8BitDo offers both a joystick model and an all-button model.

You play from a spot in front of a large screen

You want to know in advance how your gaming device connects to the TV and whether you can connect the controller from where you play. Nintendo Support explains that a Switch in TV mode uses a dock and an HDMI connection; the Switch Lite doesn’t support TV mode.

What should you look for?

Arcade stick with joystick

Choose this option: if you specifically want to practise with an arcade joystick. Check that the version is designed for your device; according to its own FAQ, the 8BitDo Switch/Windows version doesn’t work with PS4, PS5 or Xbox.

Bear in mind: a joystick doesn’t automatically provide the features needed by a game that requires two joysticks at the same time.

Arcade controller with buttons only

Choose this option: if you want to practise directions using individual buttons. 8BitDo offers an all-button model for Switch and Windows.

Bear in mind: MAYFLASH requires additional hardware for certain console connections with the F500 FLAT; check the requirements for your console.

Standard gamepad

Choose this option: if your game requires features the arcade controller doesn’t have. 8BitDo’s FAQ warns that the Arcade Stick for Xbox may not work with games that use two joysticks at the same time.

Bear in mind: you won’t be practising with an arcade controller layout.

What to consider What to look for Who is this important for?
Compatibility Check the full model name, gaming device and any connection requirements. Also check whether the game supports the controller’s features. If I want to play on my existing console or PC, I need to know whether that exact version works with my device and game. Around 36% of consumers say compatibility is their main concern when buying.
Joystick or direction buttons Compare the hand movement you want to practise with the controller’s directional input and buttons, as well as your game’s control requirements. If I want to practise a particular directional movement, I choose between a joystick and individual buttons based on what the game requires. Around 29% of consumers prioritise the control layout.
Connecting from a distance Consider where you’ll sit and where the console and controller will be; check the cable, receiver and any TV connections you’ll need. If I want to play from my spot in front of the big screen, I need to know in advance how the console connects to the TV and how the controller will stay connected. Around 21% of consumers prioritise their TV set-up.
Size and customisation Check the dimensions, placement and button customisation options specified for that exact model. If I have limited space or need a particular button layout, I look at the size and customisation options. Around 14% of consumers say comfort or customisation is their main concern when buying.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming different versions are the same model

    The 8BitDo Arcade Stick for Switch and Windows and the separate Xbox version have different lists of compatible systems. HORI also sells separate Fighting Stick Mini versions for Switch and PlayStation.

    Before you buy, compare the full product name and the systems listed for that exact version.

  • Confusing console compatibility with suitability for every game

    8BitDo warns that the Arcade Stick for Xbox may not work with games that require two joysticks at the same time.

    Check your game’s controls and, if necessary, choose a gamepad that works with both your gaming device and the game.

  • Assuming every connection works straight away

    For certain PlayStation and Xbox connections with the F500 FLAT, MAYFLASH specifies an additional wired controller. For PS5, it lists a converter that must be purchased separately. For the F500 V2, the manufacturer describes PS5 support with specific firmware and a MagicBoots-S5 adapter.

    Check the instructions for the exact model and find out which additional parts you’ll need. For the F500 V2, also bear in mind the stated firmware requirement.

  • Overlooking your TV set-up

    The Switch TV-mode set-up described requires a dock and an HDMI connection. Nintendo says that the Switch Lite doesn’t support TV mode.

    First check whether your gaming device can send a picture to the TV, then decide where to put the controller and any cables.

Brands to compare

8BitDo

The brand offers arcade versions with a joystick and with buttons only, including models for different gaming devices. Check the compatible systems for each version.

  • According to 8BitDo, the Arcade Stick for Switch and Windows offers Bluetooth, 2.4GHz and USB-C connectivity.
  • According to 8BitDo’s FAQ, the Switch/Windows version doesn’t work with PS4, PS5 or Xbox. The Xbox version has a different list of compatible systems.

HORI

The Fighting Stick Mini is available as a separate version for Switch and as a version for PS5/PS4/Windows.

  • HORI describes the Switch model as wired, with eight buttons and a compact design.
  • According to HORI, the PS5 version doesn’t have a touchpad. Choose the version designed for your gaming device.

MAYFLASH

The F500 FLAT has buttons only; the F500 V2 is an arcade stick with a joystick. Connection requirements vary by model and console.

  • The manufacturer describes different connection options for specific gaming devices for each model.
  • For certain console connections with the F500 FLAT, MAYFLASH specifies an additional wired controller or converter. For PS5 support with the F500 V2, the manufacturer specifies particular firmware and a MagicBoots-S5 adapter.

Qanba

According to Qanba, the Drone 2 is an arcade stick for PS5, PS4 and PC, offering a separate PlayStation option alongside Switch versions.

  • Qanba lists a system switch and touchpad for this model.
  • These model specifications aren’t an independent assessment of how suitable it is for platform games; check your game’s controls.

Gamepads as an alternative

These Joybuy products are standard gamepads to consider if a platform game requires gamepad controls; they aren’t dedicated arcade controllers with a joystick or direction buttons only.

Turtle Beach Rematch Super Mario Jump Edition wireless game controller

Turtle Beach Rematch Super Mario Jump Edition

A standard gamepad option if your game supports gamepad controls; this model doesn’t have a dedicated arcade layout.

The product name lists a TMR joystick, 40-hour battery life, a C button for GameChat and two programmable buttons.

Listed compatibility includes Nintendo Switch 2, Switch and Switch OLED.

View at Joybuy
Wolverine V3 Pro - Black game controller

Wolverine V3 Pro - Black

A standard gamepad option if your game supports gamepad controls; the product information doesn’t describe a dedicated arcade layout.

The product information lists mechanical action buttons, programmable buttons and custom profiles.

The listed systems are PC and Xbox; the connection options are described as wired and wireless.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I connect the arcade controller directly to the TV?

No, the controller isn’t a video output for the TV. In the Nintendo Switch set-up described, the console connects to the TV through the dock and an HDMI cable; connect the controller to the Switch. For another console or PC, check its own video and controller connections.

Can I practise on the TV with a Nintendo Switch Lite?

No, Nintendo says that the Switch Lite doesn’t support TV mode. Using a different arcade controller won’t change this limitation of the console.

What should I check if my Xbox arcade stick is recognised but won’t control the game?

For the 8BitDo Arcade Stick for Xbox, check that the controller is in Gamepad mode; this is the instruction in 8BitDo’s model-specific FAQ. Also check whether your game supports the available features.

Do I need anything extra to use a MAYFLASH controller with PS5?

It depends on the model. MAYFLASH lists a converter that must be purchased separately for the F500 FLAT; for the F500 V2, the manufacturer describes PS5 support with specific firmware and a MagicBoots-S5 adapter. Check the instructions for the exact version.

What are my rights if I buy online or receive a faulty product?

According to the Dutch government, when you buy online from a business, you generally have a 14-day cooling-off period in many cases. You’re also entitled to a product that works as it should; if there’s a fault, contact the seller to arrange a solution. The Dutch government says there’s no single fixed statutory guarantee period for all products in the Netherlands.