Console player with a second player
You’re looking for an extra controller for matches on the same console. Your main priority is checking that it’s right for your console generation and supported by the game.
First, choose a controller that works with your console or PC, then check how many local players your football game supports. Wireless play gives you more freedom to move, while a wired controller keeps you within reach of the cable. If you choose a rechargeable model, you’ll need to plan when to charge it. Playing occasionally during the day doesn’t, in itself, mean you need a different type of controller.
You’re looking for an extra controller for matches on the same console. Your main priority is checking that it’s right for your console generation and supported by the game.
You have several people playing on one system and want to have enough paired, charged controllers ready in advance. The number of players who can join in varies by game and platform.
You play on Windows and are considering using the same controller with another device. Support depends on the full model and connection method.
| What to consider | What should you look for? | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Compatibility | Check the console or operating system, the full controller model and support in your football game. For example, Nintendo states that the Switch 2 Pro Controller only works with Switch 2. | If I’m buying a second controller, I want to be sure it works with both my console and football game. Around 36% of consumers prioritise compatibility with their gaming platform. |
| Playing together locally | Check the number of players supported by your game and game mode, and pair any extra controllers in advance. The PlayStation Store lists EA SPORTS FC 27 on PS4 and PS5 as supporting one to four players; this doesn’t automatically apply to other games. | For a match with several players, I want to be able to pair everyone’s controllers in advance and know how many people the game mode allows. Around 29% of consumers prioritise uninterrupted local multiplayer. |
| Use with multiple devices | Compare the full model and connection for each device. Sony lists USB-C and Bluetooth for DualSense on supported devices; 8BitDo lists different platforms for the Ultimate 2C Wireless and Ultimate 2C Bluetooth. | If I switch between my PC and another device, I don’t want to find out that a similarly named version isn’t compatible. Around 21% of consumers prioritise use with multiple devices. |
| Power and cable | Check whether you’ll need batteries, a way to charge the controller or a cable, and whether the cable will reach where you sit. Sony states that a USB cable isn’t included with the Chroma Pearl DualSense we looked at; PowerA lists a 3 m cable for the Enhanced Wired Controller. | As I only play occasionally, I don’t want to be caught out by a flat battery or an awkward cable during a match. Around 14% of consumers prioritise low running costs for occasional play. |
Nintendo says that the Switch 2 Pro Controller doesn’t work with the original Switch. Check the console generation and the full model name before ordering.
Compare the compatibility information for the exact model with the console you play on.
8BitDo lists Windows and Android for the Ultimate 2C Wireless, and Switch for the Ultimate 2C Bluetooth. So, despite their similar names, the two versions don’t support the same devices.
Check the word after the model name and the compatibility information for the exact version.
Sony says that a USB cable isn’t included with the Chroma Pearl DualSense we looked at. The manufacturer lists a 3 m cable for the wired PowerA Enhanced Wired Controller.
Check which cables you already have, whether you’ll need to charge the controller and whether a cable will reach where you sit.
DualSense is designed for PS5 and, according to Sony, can also connect to supported PCs and mobile devices.
The Xbox Wireless Controller is designed for supported Xbox consoles, Windows PCs and the mobile devices listed by Microsoft.
Nintendo offers separate Pro Controller versions for Switch and Switch 2.
The Enhanced Wired Controller is a wired option for the Xbox systems and Windows listed by the manufacturer.
The Ultimate 2C Wireless and Ultimate 2C Bluetooth are different versions, with different listed platforms.
This selection includes controllers for Xbox and Windows, a DualSense for PS5, and Pro Controllers for Nintendo Switch and Switch 2. It also includes a wired controller for Xbox and Windows.
No image available
A wireless option for playing on a supported Xbox console or Windows PC.
The product description lists Xbox Series X|S and Windows 10/11 PCs, Bluetooth and a hybrid D-pad. 2 AA batteries are included.
No image available
A controller for PS5; the product description also lists connections to supported Windows, Mac and mobile devices.
The description lists a built-in rechargeable battery, haptic feedback and adaptive triggers. The effects depend on game support. A USB cable isn’t included.
No image available
A wired option for the listed Xbox systems and Windows PCs, provided the cable reaches your gaming spot.
The product name lists Xbox Series X/S, Xbox One and Windows 10/11. The description lists Hall Effect joysticks and triggers, two programmable rear buttons and a detachable USB cable.
No image available
A Pro Controller for playing on the original Nintendo Switch.
The product description lists wireless connectivity, motion controls, HD Rumble and a built-in lithium-polymer battery.
No image available
A Pro Controller for Switch 2; Nintendo says this model doesn’t work with the original Switch.
The product description lists HD Rumble, motion controls and a rechargeable battery. According to the description, you can charge it via the console, dock or USB charger.
It depends on the game and game mode. The PlayStation Store lists EA SPORTS FC 27 on PS4 and PS5 as supporting one to four players. Check the listing for the title you’re actually playing and pair the controllers in advance.
No. Nintendo says that the Switch 2 Pro Controller only works with Switch 2. According to Nintendo, the original Switch Pro Controller can be paired with Switch 2.
Check that each controller connects and is sufficiently charged or has the required batteries. Nintendo describes both wireless pairing and pairing via the dock for the Switch 2 Pro Controller.
Check the exact version and which cables you already have. Sony says that a cable isn’t included with the Chroma Pearl version we looked at; according to Sony, you can use a cable supplied with your PS5 to connect or charge it.
It depends on the full controller model, connection and device. Sony lists USB-C and Bluetooth for DualSense on supported devices, while 8BitDo lists different compatibility for the Ultimate 2C Wireless and Ultimate 2C Bluetooth. Check whether your game supports the controller too.