Who is this choice relevant to?

Switch player on the sofa

Wants to play a farming game on Switch in a dark room, with a particular focus on button layout and compatibility. Nintendo confirms that the Switch Pro Controller can be used wirelessly with Switch 2.

PC player who enjoys long sessions

Wants to connect a controller to their PC and avoid reaching for the keyboard or mouse so often while playing. For Stardew Valley, the developer lists support for Xbox One and Xbox 360 controllers on PC.

Player who struggles to see the buttons

Wants to distinguish the buttons easily in low ambient light. GameSir describes customisable RGB light strips on the Super Nova; this doesn’t automatically mean the button lettering is illuminated.

What should you look for in a controller for playing in the dark?

Start by checking that your platform and game are supported. Then check the button lighting, grip and how the controller connects and gets its power.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important to?
Platform and game Check that your console or operating system and the specific game are supported. If I play on Switch, Xbox or PC, I want to know first whether my game supports the controller. Around 33% of consumers prioritise compatibility with their platform and game.
Seeing the buttons Check whether the button lettering itself is illuminated, or just the casing or light strips. In a dark room, I want to see the controls, not just ambient lighting; around 27% of consumers give clear visibility of the buttons top priority.
Grip and button placement Compare the grip and the position of frequently used buttons; if possible, try holding the controller. For longer gaming sessions, I look at how the controller feels in my hand and whether the buttons are easy to reach. Around 20% of consumers prioritise long-term comfort.
Connection and power Check the connection mode for your device and whether the controller uses batteries or a rechargeable battery. I don’t want to be caught out while playing by an unsuitable connection or a flat battery. Around 20% of consumers give connection and power top priority.

Buying pitfalls to avoid

  • Confusing ambient lighting with illuminated button lettering

    GameSir describes RGB light strips on the Super Nova, but this doesn’t confirm that the lettering on the buttons lights up.

    If you’re choosing a controller specifically for illuminated buttons, look for explicit information about the lettering itself.

  • Mixing up variants in the same controller range

    The 8BitDo Ultimate 2C Wireless and Ultimate 2C Bluetooth have different listed platforms and connection options.

    Check the full variant name and the connection that works with your device before choosing a model.

  • Expecting every controller feature to work in every PC game

    According to PlayStation, DualSense features on PC vary by game and connection method. Haptic feedback requires a USB connection on PC.

    Check which basic controls and extra features your game supports; don’t assume they’ll all be available.

  • Overlooking power and what’s included

    Xbox lists AA batteries or a separate rechargeable battery pack as power options for the Xbox Wireless Controller.

    Check the power requirements and what’s in the box for the exact version you’re considering.

Brands and product ranges to consider

These product ranges suit different platform options. Always check the exact version and whether your game is supported.

Nintendo

The Switch Pro Controller is an option for farming games on Nintendo Switch. Nintendo also confirms that it can be used wirelessly with Switch 2.

  • Nintendo gives the controller a battery life of around 40 hours; actual usage time may vary depending on software and features.
  • The specifications provided don’t confirm illuminated button lettering. Check this separately if it matters to you.

Xbox

The Xbox Wireless Controller is an option for Xbox and compatible Windows devices. The developer of Stardew Valley lists support for Xbox One controllers on PC.

  • Xbox lists Bluetooth and Xbox Wireless for compatible devices.
  • Xbox lists AA batteries or a separate rechargeable battery pack. Check the power requirements and what’s included with the version you choose.

PlayStation

DualSense is an option for PS5 and for PC games that support the controller.

  • PlayStation describes USB and Bluetooth connections with supported PCs.
  • PC features vary by game and connection. PlayStation states that haptic feedback on PC requires a USB connection.

GameSir

The Super Nova is a multi-platform option for players who want to switch between supported devices.

  • GameSir describes the controls as quiet and lists customisable RGB lighting and Hall Effect sticks.
  • These are the manufacturer’s descriptions, not independent noise or performance test results. RGB light strips don’t confirm illuminated button lettering; pairing steps vary by device and mode.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C Wireless is a separate option for Windows and Android.

  • For this Wireless variant, 8BitDo lists 2.4GHz or wired use on Windows and Bluetooth on Android.
  • The Ultimate 2C Bluetooth for Switch is a different variant. Check the full product name and the listed connection for your platform.

Joybuy products for different platforms

This selection includes controllers whose product names mention a Switch, Xbox, PlayStation or PC option. Check that the exact version and the game you play are compatible.

PlayStation DualSense wireless controller, Marvel’s Wolverine Battle Yellow Limited Edition

PlayStation DualSense wireless controller – Marvel’s Wolverine Battle Yellow Limited Edition

The product title describes a wireless PS5 controller; the product description mentions an ergonomic design for longer gaming sessions.

Joybuy
NAXSIR Bluetooth gamepad for Switch with 7-colour LED

NAXSIR Bluetooth gamepad for Switch with 7-colour LED

The product name mentions Bluetooth for Switch and a 7-colour LED; LED lighting doesn’t prove that the button lettering is illuminated.

The product name also mentions vibration feedback and a stated range of 10 m.

Joybuy
Xbox Wireless Controller, Heart Breaker Special Edition for Xbox Series and PC

Xbox Wireless Controller – Heart Breaker Special Edition (Xbox Series/PC)

The product title lists Xbox Series and PC as compatible platforms.

This version uses 2 AA batteries. According to the product description, the USB-C cable for wired use is sold separately.

Joybuy
Black wireless DualShock-compatible controller for PS4 and PC

Black wireless DualShock-compatible controller for PS4 and PC

The product name lists compatibility with PS4 and PC. Check that your game and device support this controller.

Joybuy
NAXSIR wireless PS5 controller with Hall Effect sticks and RGB lighting

NAXSIR wireless PS5 controller with Hall Effect sticks

The product name lists PS5, Hall Effect sticks, programmable buttons, RGB lighting and a 1000 mAh battery.

RGB lighting doesn’t tell you whether the button lettering lights up; check this feature separately.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does every controller work with Stardew Valley?

No, don’t assume universal support. The developer of Stardew Valley lists Xbox One and Xbox 360 controllers for PC, and full controller support on Xbox One, PlayStation 4 and Nintendo Switch. For other combinations, check the information for your game and device.

Can I use a Nintendo Switch Pro Controller with Switch 2?

Yes. Nintendo confirms that you can pair the Switch Pro Controller wirelessly with a Switch 2.

How do I connect the GameSir Super Nova to a Windows PC?

According to the GameSir manual, you can plug the supplied receiver into a USB port and set the controller to 2.4GHz mode, or connect the controller using a USB-C cable. Follow the manual for the pairing steps.

Do RGB light strips mean the button lettering is illuminated?

Not necessarily. GameSir describes customisable RGB light strips on the Super Nova, but this doesn’t confirm that the button lettering is illuminated. Check the information about button lighting for the exact version.

What power source does the Xbox Wireless Controller use?

Xbox lists AA batteries or a separate rechargeable battery pack as options. Check which power source is included with the version you choose.