Who is this buying guide for?

PC gamers who want a reliable connection

You want to check in advance that your controller, connection method and farming game will work together. Stardew Valley’s creator specifically lists Xbox One and Xbox 360 controllers for the PC version.

Switch players in a bright room

You play on a Switch or Switch 2 and are considering not just the controller, but also the screen’s position and brightness. Nintendo explains the brightness settings for both systems.

Players who enjoy long, relaxed sessions

Once you’ve settled on your device, you can compare grip, button positions and how the controller charges or connects. Microsoft describes features including a textured grip, while Nintendo gives an estimated battery life for the Switch Pro Controller.

What should you look for when buying?

Start by checking that your device and game are compatible, then consider screen visibility, controls and power.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Compatibility Check the exact model name, your device, the connection and whether your game supports the controller. A platform being listed doesn’t confirm that every game will work. I want to make sure my controller and game work together before choosing. Around 36% of consumers give compatibility top priority.
Screen visibility Check where light falls on the screen. On Switch and Switch 2, you can adjust the brightness in handheld or tabletop mode. When I play in a bright room, I want to be able to see the screen clearly; a new controller won’t solve glare. Around 29% of consumers prioritise screen visibility.
Grip and buttons Consider the grip and button positions for your hands. Check whether any extra buttons can be customised on your device and in your game. I want to reach the controls comfortably during repeated actions, without choosing extra buttons I won’t use. Around 21% of consumers focus mainly on controls and comfort.
Power and freedom of movement Check how the controller is powered and whether the cable is long enough for where you sit. Stated battery life can depend on software and features. I want to know whether I’ll need a cable while playing, whether I’ll need to recharge, or whether I’ll have enough room to sit comfortably while playing wirelessly. Around 14% of consumers focus most on power or freedom of movement.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming similar model names mean the controllers are the same

    The 8BitDo Ultimate 2C Wireless and Ultimate 2C Bluetooth have different platform compatibility and connections. The manufacturer lists Windows and Android for the Wireless version, and Switch for the Bluetooth version.

    Check the full model name, compatibility and connection type before you order.

  • Buying a controller to fix a screen visibility problem

    A controller operates the game, but won’t change the light falling on your screen or its brightness. Nintendo explains the brightness settings for Switch and Switch 2.

    First consider the screen’s position and available brightness settings. Then choose a controller that suits your device and game.

  • Confusing the manufacturer’s warranty with your statutory rights

    A manufacturer’s warranty doesn’t replace your statutory rights. According to ACM ConsuWijzer, the seller is responsible for providing an appropriate remedy free of charge if a product breaks sooner than you could reasonably expect during normal use.

    Keep your proof of purchase and contact the seller if a product is faulty.

Relevant brands to compare

Xbox

An Xbox controller is an option for supported Xbox consoles and Windows PCs.

  • Microsoft lists Bluetooth, a textured grip and a hybrid D-pad.
  • Check that your PC game supports the controller; the platform listing doesn’t confirm compatibility with every farming game.

Nintendo

The Switch Pro Controller is designed for Switch systems; the separate Switch 2 Pro Controller is for Switch 2.

  • Nintendo estimates that the Switch Pro Controller lasts for around 40 hours on a full charge, depending on software and features. The Switch 2 Pro Controller has customisable GL/GR buttons.
  • The older Switch Pro Controller can’t wake a Switch 2 from sleep using the HOME button. Check which features matter to you for your console.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C Wireless and Ultimate 2C Bluetooth are versions designed for different platform needs.

  • 8BitDo lists Hall-effect joysticks for both versions.
  • Connectivity and compatibility vary by model. Hall-effect joysticks are a manufacturer specification, not a guarantee that stick drift is impossible.

PlayStation

DualSense is an option for PS5 and for PC games that support the controller.

  • Sony describes USB and Bluetooth connections with supported PCs.
  • On PC, haptic feedback and other extra features depend on the game and connection. Check compatibility with your farming game.

PowerA

The Enhanced Wired Controller for Xbox Series X|S is a wired option for the Xbox consoles and Windows listed by PowerA.

  • PowerA lists two mappable buttons and a detachable 3 m USB cable.
  • The cable limits where you can sit. The listed platform support doesn’t confirm use with Switch or PS5.

Controllers at Joybuy

This Joybuy selection includes controllers for PC and Xbox gaming, as well as Nintendo Switch. Before buying, check that the exact model is right for your device and game.

Green wireless Dualshock controller for PS4 and PC

Green wireless Dualshock controller for PS4 and PC

An option if you’re looking for a wireless controller for the PS4 and PC platforms listed in the product name; also check that your game supports it.

The product name specifies a wireless connection and compatibility with PS4 and PC.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN Wireless Gaming Controller with Hall-effect joysticks

VIELLAN Wireless Gaming Controller

An option if you play on PC and programmable rear buttons matter to you; check that the listed features suit your game and setup.

The product name specifies Hall-effect joysticks, 255-level Hall triggers, programmable rear buttons, RGB lighting, a 1000 mAh battery and USB-C.

View at Joybuy
GameSir G7 SE wired Xbox controller in Dynamic Blue

GameSir G7 SE wired Xbox controller, Dynamic Blue

A wired option if you play on one of the Xbox systems or Windows platforms listed in the product name; check that your farming game supports it.

The product name lists Xbox Series X/S, Xbox One and Windows 10/Windows 11.

View at Joybuy
GameSir Kaleid Flux wired Xbox controller, smoke-transparent RGB

GameSir Kaleid Flux wired Xbox controller

A wired option if you play on one of the Xbox systems or Windows platforms listed in the product name; check that your farming game supports it.

The product name lists Xbox Series X/S, Xbox One and Windows 10/Windows 11, in a smoke-transparent RGB design.

View at Joybuy
Black Nintendo Switch Pro Controller

Nintendo Switch Pro Controller, black

An option if you’re looking for a separate controller for a Nintendo Switch setup. Nintendo also describes pairing it with Switch 2, but the older controller can’t wake that console from sleep using the HOME button.

Nintendo estimates that the battery lasts for around 40 hours on a full charge, depending on software and features.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Will a different controller make my game easier to see in a bright room?

No, a controller won’t change the screen’s brightness. Nintendo explains the brightness settings for Switch and Switch 2 in handheld or tabletop mode; also consider where the screen is positioned and where the light is coming from.

Will every controller work with Stardew Valley on PC?

No, a platform listing on the controller isn’t enough to confirm that. Stardew Valley’s FAQ lists Xbox One and Xbox 360 controllers for PC; for other models, check that your game setup supports them.

How do I pair a Switch Pro Controller?

Nintendo explains that you can pair it using the SYNC button from CONTROLLERS > CHANGE GRIP/ORDER, or via USB in the console setup described. Follow the instructions for the correct console version.

Do I need extra warranty cover when buying a controller online in the Netherlands?

No, you don’t need extra warranty cover to exercise your statutory rights. According to ACM ConsuWijzer, the seller is responsible for providing an appropriate remedy free of charge if a product breaks sooner than you could reasonably expect during normal use.

Can I return a controller bought online in the Netherlands?

For online consumer purchases, ACM ConsuWijzer says you will generally have 14 days from delivery to change your mind. There are exceptions, so check the information about cancellation periods and returns before buying.