Who is a controller right for?

Console detective on the sofa

You play on an Xbox, PS5 or Switch and want to make sure the controller works with both your console and your game. Microsoft, Sony and Nintendo describe support for their own platforms; check the game’s compatibility too.

PC player in front of the TV

You use a Windows PC with a big screen and need to check that both the game and the controller connection suit your set-up. Logitech and 8BitDo describe different connection options for their PC controllers.

Point-and-click player

You want to select clues from the sofa, but need to know in advance whether your game supports every action with a controller. Steam lists different levels of controller support for detective adventures.

What should you look for in a controller for detective games?

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Device compatibility Compare the platform list for the exact model with the console or PC you play on. I want to play on my own Xbox, PS5, Switch or PC, without discovering after purchase that they don’t work together. Around 31% of consumers put compatibility with their gaming device first.
Game controls Check the input and controller information for the exact detective game you play. I want to control clues and menus from the sofa without having to reach for a mouse or keyboard for certain actions. Around 25% of consumers prioritise full control of the game.
Reach from your seat Measure the cable route to your PC or check which wireless connection your device supports. I sit further away from my PC and don’t want to find out mid-game that the cable won’t reach. Around 19% of consumers say reach from their seat is their main concern.
Control layout Compare the positioning of the sticks and directional buttons, and check that button mapping works with your game. For a relaxed game of sleuthing, I want a stick and button layout that feels comfortable for the way I play. Around 13% of consumers prioritise how the controls feel during play.
Power and connections Check whether the package includes a charging cable or receiver, and what type of power the controller uses. I want to know in advance which connections or power supplies my set-up needs. Around 12% of consumers make practical requirements their main buying concern.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming every detective game works fully with a controller

    Steam lists full controller support for Loco Motive and partial support for Duppy Detective Tashia. Support therefore varies from game to game, even within the same genre.

    Check the input information for your game and think about how you’ll carry out any actions that aren’t supported by a controller.

    You may still need a mouse or keyboard nearby for some actions.

  • Assuming Bluetooth on one device means Bluetooth on every device

    For the 8BitDo Ultimate 2C Wireless, the manufacturer lists Bluetooth for Android and a 2.4GHz connection or USB for Windows.

    Check the connection options for the exact model, as well as the ports on the device you play on.

    For wireless use with Windows, you may need a USB port for the receiver.

  • Waiting until after purchase to check the distance to a wired PC controller

    Logitech lists a USB cable of around 1.8 metres for the F310. Whether that’s long enough depends on the route between your PC and your seat.

    Measure the route before choosing a wired controller.

  • Confusing an extra warranty package with your statutory rights

    ACM ConsuWijzer distinguishes between a warranty from the retailer or manufacturer and your statutory guarantee rights.

    Check what additional cover a package provides, and don’t treat it as a replacement for your statutory rights.

Brands worth comparing

Xbox / Microsoft

Xbox controllers for Xbox consoles and the PC and mobile platforms listed by Microsoft.

  • For the controller reviewed, Microsoft lists Bluetooth, Xbox Wireless, textured grips and button mapping.
  • The connection and support for a specific game still depend on your device and game; the features listed aren’t the result of an independent ergonomics test.

PlayStation / Sony

DualSense controllers for PS5 and supported PC, Mac and mobile uses.

  • Sony lists haptic feedback and adaptive triggers for games that support these features.
  • Features may vary by game and device; some features on PC may require a USB connection.

Nintendo

The Nintendo Switch Pro Controller is for Switch; Nintendo also confirms that this model can be paired wirelessly with Switch 2.

  • Nintendo lists motion controls, HD Rumble and amiibo support for the Switch Pro Controller.
  • The Switch 2 Pro Controller is a different model with its own features; don’t assume both controllers offer the same capabilities.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C Wireless is an option for Windows or Android if its stated connection method suits your set-up.

  • For this model, 8BitDo lists Hall Effect sticks, extra bumpers and a 2.4GHz adapter.
  • The stated connection options list Bluetooth for Android, but not Windows; check that the connection method you need is supported.

Logitech G

The F310 is a wired gamepad for a PC set-up where the cable can reach your seat.

  • For the F310, Logitech lists XInput/DirectInput and a USB cable of around 1.8 metres.
  • The cable needs to be long enough to cover the distance between your PC and where you play; controller compatibility doesn’t guarantee full support in every game.

Controllers at Joybuy

This selection includes controllers for Xbox and Nintendo systems, as well as options for wired or wireless PC set-ups. Check the connection and controls supported by each model and game.

Xbox Wireless Controller Robot White

Xbox Wireless Controller Robot White

An option for Xbox or a Windows PC; Microsoft lists support for these platforms. Check the connection options for your set-up and whether your detective game supports it.

View at Joybuy
Hyperkin DuchesS wired controller for Xbox

Hyperkin DuchesS wired controller for Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows 10/11

A wired option for the listed Xbox and Windows platforms, provided the cable reaches where you play. Check game support before choosing.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Pro Controller Black

Nintendo Switch Pro Controller Black

For a Nintendo Switch set-up; Nintendo also confirms that the Switch Pro Controller can be paired wirelessly with Switch 2. Check controls for your game separately.

View at Joybuy
BEITONG PanGu Modular Wireless Gaming Controller

BEITONG PanGu Modular Wireless Gaming Controller

The product name lists PC, Nintendo Switch, Switch 2 and Android as platforms. Check the connection method for your device and whether your game supports the controller.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller Black

Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller Black

For a Nintendo Switch 2 set-up. Check whether your detective game supports this controller and whether the features you want to use are available in the game.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does every controller work with every detective game on PC?

No, support varies by game. For example, Steam lists full controller support for Loco Motive and partial support for Duppy Detective Tashia. Check your game’s input information before relying on a controller alone.

How do I connect a controller when playing from the sofa?

Follow the connection instructions for the exact model and device. According to 8BitDo, the Ultimate 2C Wireless uses a 2.4GHz receiver for wireless use with Windows and Bluetooth for Android. For the wired Logitech F310, the USB cable, which is around 1.8 metres long, needs to reach your PC.

What should I check if my Switch Pro Controller isn’t responding properly?

First, check the pairing and power supply by following Nintendo’s instructions. If you’re having problems, Nintendo recommends checking that the controller is synchronised with the system and charged.

Am I entitled to a return or warranty when I buy a controller online in the Netherlands?

For online purchases by consumers, there is usually a statutory cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery; ACM ConsuWijzer lists some exceptions. You also have statutory guarantee rights if a product used normally doesn’t meet the expectations you’re entitled to have. Statutory guarantee rights don’t automatically give every controller a fixed two-year guarantee.