Who is this choice relevant to?

PC detective game player

You want to select clues without constantly switching between your controller and mouse. Check your game’s input support first; Steam, for example, lists controller support for certain detective games.

Console player

You’re looking for a controller that works with your PlayStation, Xbox or Nintendo system, as well as the features supported by your game.

Daylight player

You play in a bright room and want to know whether the controls are difficult to use, or whether text and clues are simply hard to see on screen.

What should you look for when choosing?

PC game with controller support

Choose this option: if your game supports controller input and you want to use a controller with a compatible Windows PC.

Bear in mind: PC compatibility alone doesn’t confirm that your game supports the controller.

PC game with lots of pointing

Choose this option: if a mouse and keyboard work better for your game, or it doesn’t offer usable controller support.

Bear in mind: a configurable controller with trackpads, such as the Steam Controller, may take some experimentation to set up and won’t necessarily feel right for every detective game.

PlayStation 5

Choose this option: if you play your detective game on PS5, or if the PC version supports your DualSense controller.

Bear in mind: haptic feedback and adaptive triggers on PC depend on the game; PlayStation says a USB connection is required for haptic feedback.

Nintendo Switch or Switch 2

Choose this option: based on your console, game and the controller features you want to use.

Bear in mind: Nintendo says the Switch 2 Pro Controller is exclusively for Switch 2. If you have an older Pro Controller, check that the features you want work with your Switch 2 game.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Compatibility Check your platform, the game page and whether your controller type is listed. I want to check first that my PC or console and detective game support my controller; around 36% of consumers put compatibility first.
Selecting clues See which input methods your game supports and whether you can try out the controls. If I want precise control over small clues and menus, I check which input methods work in my game; around 29% of consumers prioritise this.
Readability in daylight Work out whether the problem is with the controls or with screen glare and brightness. I want to see clues clearly in a bright room, so I check my screen and the lighting first; around 21% of consumers put visibility first.
Comfort and power Check the connection and power source, and whether the controller feels comfortable to hold. If I want to play for longer periods, I consider grip, freedom of movement and power; around 14% of consumers make this their main buying consideration.

Common buying mistakes

  • Confusing a PC connection with support from the game

    A controller may connect to your PC even if a particular game doesn’t support that controller or the type of controller you want to use.

    Before buying, check both platform compatibility and the input methods listed for your game.

  • Buying a controller to fix screen glare

    A different controller won’t change the lighting, screen brightness or display.

    First check where your screen is positioned and the brightness settings available.

  • Confusing the Switch Pro Controller with the Switch 2 Pro Controller

    Nintendo says the Switch 2 Pro Controller is exclusively for Switch 2. Don’t assume that both models work with the same console or features.

    Check the full model name, your console and the features your game needs.

  • Assuming there’s a fixed warranty period

    According to the Dutch government, the Netherlands has no fixed statutory warranty period. This doesn’t affect your legal rights if a product isn’t as it should be.

    Check what any additional cover includes, and contact the seller if your product is faulty.

Brands to consider

Microsoft Xbox

An option for compatible Xbox consoles and Windows PCs, with wireless play or a USB-C connection.

  • Microsoft lists Bluetooth, button mapping through the Xbox Accessories app and AA batteries.
  • Battery life depends on usage; platform support doesn’t guarantee that every detective game supports the controller.

Sony PlayStation

DualSense is a good fit for PS5 players and for PC games that support the controller.

  • PlayStation lists USB and Bluetooth connections with compatible devices.
  • Haptic feedback and adaptive triggers on PC depend on the game; PlayStation specifies a USB connection for haptic feedback on PC.

Nintendo

The right Pro Controller depends on your Switch console and the features you’re looking for.

  • Nintendo lists motion controls for the Switch Pro Controller and estimates battery life at around 40 hours.
  • Nintendo says the Switch 2 Pro Controller is exclusively for Switch 2; the stated battery life is an estimate and depends on usage.

Valve

The Steam Controller is a configurable PC option for anyone who wants to customise input for Steam games.

  • Valve mentions configuration through Steam Input; the product description lists trackpads.
  • This doesn’t prove that a particular detective game will be easier or more enjoyable to play with it.

GameSir

The G7 SE is a wired option for compatible Xbox systems and Windows PCs.

  • The manufacturer lists Hall Effect sticks, two adjustable rear buttons and a wired USB-C connection.
  • The cable limits your freedom of movement. The manufacturer’s claims about preventing stick drift aren’t based on independent long-term testing.

Controllers at Joybuy

This selection includes controllers for PC and Xbox games, as well as Nintendo Switch systems. Check which controller inputs are supported for each game and platform.

Xbox Wireless Controller, Heart Breaker Special Edition

Xbox Wireless Controller, Heart Breaker Special Edition (Xbox Series/PC)

For Xbox Series and PC according to the product name; check that your detective game supports controller input.

Microsoft lists Bluetooth and AA batteries for the Xbox Wireless Controller; battery life depends on usage.

View at Joybuy
GameSir Cyclone 2 controller with charging station, black bundle

GameSir Cyclone 2 Multiplatform Controller, Black Bundle

According to the product information, it’s designed for PC and Switch; check support for your specific game.

The product name lists TMR sticks and a charging station; this version is a bundle.

View at Joybuy
GameSir G7 SE wired controller in Dynamic Blue

GameSir G7 SE wired controller, Dynamic Blue (Xbox Series X/S, Xbox One, Windows 10/11)

For the Xbox systems and Windows listed in the product name; check your game’s input support.

The controller is wired, which limits your freedom of movement.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Pro Controller, black

Nintendo Switch Pro Controller, black

For use with Nintendo Switch; check which controller features your game supports.

Nintendo lists motion controls and an estimated battery life of around 40 hours; actual battery life depends on usage.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller, black

Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller, black

According to Nintendo, this is exclusively for Switch 2; also check that your game supports it.

The product information lists Bluetooth and an included USB charging cable.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does every controller work with every detective game on PC?

No. Check your game’s page to see which controller support and controller types are listed. Steam, for example, lists full controller support and Xbox controller support for two detective games; this doesn’t confirm support for other games.

How do I connect a DualSense to a compatible PC?

According to PlayStation, you can connect via USB or Bluetooth on compatible devices. For haptic feedback on PC, the game and controller feature must be supported; PlayStation specifies a USB connection for this.

Will a controller fix screen glare in a bright room?

No, a controller won’t change screen brightness or lighting. If you’re struggling to see the screen, first check its position and the brightness settings available.

What should I look for in terms of power and connection?

Check whether the model uses AA batteries, has a rechargeable battery or is wired, and what’s included. The Xbox Wireless Controller uses AA batteries; Nintendo says the Switch Pro Controller charges via USB-C. Battery life depends on the conditions.

What are my rights when buying a controller online in the Netherlands?

According to the Dutch government, you usually have a 14-day cooling-off period when buying at a distance. You’re also entitled to a product that meets legal requirements; the Netherlands has no fixed statutory warranty period. If your product is faulty, contact the seller and check the terms of your purchase.