Which console is right for you?

Players with a specific games list

You have detective or puzzle games in mind and want to check first that the title and console version you want go together. PlayStation, Nintendo and Xbox list games for their consoles; check each title’s store page.

TV players who care about picture quality

You mainly play on a big screen and want to know which display features your game and TV actually support. Nintendo and Sony describe picture enhancements for supported games, not as a guarantee for every title.

Players who want to switch where they play

You may want to play on the TV as well as on the go, or chat about puzzles together. Nintendo describes TV and handheld play for Switch 2; think about which way of playing you’ll actually use.

What should you consider when choosing?

First, check that the games you want are playable on the console and version you’re considering. Then compare where you’ll play, display support and whether you want physical or digital games.

PlayStation 5 with disc drive

Choose this option: if the games you want are available on PlayStation and you also want to play physical games. PlayStation lists The Rise of the Golden Idol for PS5.

Bear in mind: check the console version and available features for each game. You don’t need a disc drive if you only buy digital games.

Xbox Series X or Series S

Choose this option: look at the Series X version with a disc drive if you want to play physical Xbox games. The Dutch Xbox Store lists Duck Detective for Series X|S.

Bear in mind: Series X is also available without a disc drive; Microsoft describes Series S as fully digital. So check the exact version and the requirements for each game.

Nintendo Switch 2

Choose this option: if you want to play mysteries on the TV as well as on the go. Nintendo says LAYTON’S MYSTERY JOURNEY for Switch can be played on a TV.

Bear in mind: check the compatibility of any older Switch game you want to play. Nintendo also says 4K output requires a supported game and a compatible TV.

PlayStation 5 Pro

Choose this option: consider this version if you play on a suitable screen and have checked which games on your list support PS5 Pro enhancements; Sony describes enhancements for supported games.

Bear in mind: a Tweakers review from November 2024 noted that the graphics upgrade isn’t always a major one. So don’t choose this version just because a game is playable on PS5.

What to consider What to look for Who should consider this?
Game availability Check the console version for each title and, for older Switch games, compatibility with Switch 2. If I want to play a specific detective or puzzle game, I first check that the right version is available. Around 33% of consumers put the availability of games they want first.
Picture quality on your TV Check that both the game and the TV support the display feature you want. If you mainly play on a big screen, you’ll want to know whether extra display features are available for your game too. Around 27% of consumers give TV picture quality top priority.
Switching where you play Consider whether you also want to play in handheld mode and check which ways of playing the console offers. If I want to play outside the living room too, or chat about puzzles together, flexibility matters. Around 20% of consumers put flexibility or solving puzzles together first.
Physical or digital Check whether the version has a disc drive and which games or subscriptions you’ll need separately. If you want to keep playing physical games or compare digital purchases and subscriptions, check the exact version. Around 20% of consumers give purchase format and ongoing costs top priority.

Things to look out for when buying

  • Assuming a display specification applies to every game

    A mention of 4K or 120 fps doesn’t mean every mystery game supports that display setting. Nintendo says 4K output requires supported games and a compatible TV; Sony describes PS5 Pro enhancements for supported games.

    Before choosing a console for a particular display feature, check the display capabilities of the specific game and your TV.

  • Choosing a digital version when you want to play discs

    The PS5 Digital Edition and Xbox Series S don’t have a disc drive. Xbox Series X is also available in a version without one.

    Check the full version name and compare it with the games you want to play physically.

  • Assuming every older Switch game works on Switch 2

    Nintendo warns that some Switch games aren’t compatible, or aren’t fully compatible, with Switch 2.

    Check the compatibility status of every title that matters to your decision.

Brands to compare

PlayStation

A good option if the mystery games on your list are available for PS5 and you want to choose between a version with a disc drive, a digital version or PS5 Pro.

  • PlayStation lists The Rise of the Golden Idol for PS5.
  • Sony says the PS5 Digital Edition doesn’t have a disc drive. PS5 Pro picture enhancements are available for supported games.

Xbox

A good option if the games you want are available for Series X|S and you want to choose between a Series X version with or without a disc drive and the fully digital Series S.

  • The Dutch Xbox Store lists Duck Detective for Series X|S.
  • Microsoft describes Series S as fully digital; check which Series X version you’re looking at.

Nintendo

A good option if you want to play mystery and puzzle games on a TV and, potentially, in handheld mode with Switch 2.

  • Nintendo describes TV mode for Switch 2 and says LAYTON’S MYSTERY JOURNEY for Switch can be played on a TV.
  • Nintendo warns that some older Switch games aren’t compatible, or aren’t fully compatible, with Switch 2; check each title.

Joybuy product picks

Joybuy product picks for playing mystery games on a TV with Nintendo Switch and Switch 2.

Nintendo Switch 2 console with replaceable battery (2026)

Nintendo Switch 2 console with replaceable battery (2026)

Ideal if you want to play mystery games on the TV as well as on the go; check each game’s compatibility with Switch 2.

View on Joybuy
Nintendo Switch console bundle, 32GB, with Mario Kart 8 Deluxe game card

Nintendo Switch console bundle, 32GB, with Mario Kart 8 Deluxe game card

A Nintendo Switch console bundle for anyone also considering the physical game card mentioned; check that the bundle suits the games you want to play.

View on Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 console bundle, 256GB, with Mario Kart World download and 3 months of Nintendo Switch Online

Nintendo Switch 2 console bundle, 256GB, with Mario Kart World download and 3 months of Nintendo Switch Online

Ideal if you’re looking for a Switch 2 bundle with the Mario Kart World download mentioned and a 3-month membership; check the requirements for the games you want to play.

View on Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 console (EU)

Nintendo Switch 2 console (EU)

Ideal if you want to use Switch 2 on a TV as well as on the go; Nintendo recommends checking compatibility with older Switch games individually.

View on Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I play every Switch mystery game on Switch 2?

No, not in every case: Nintendo warns that some Switch games aren’t compatible, or aren’t fully compatible. Check the specific title before choosing Switch 2 for it.

How do I connect Switch 2 to the TV?

According to Nintendo, connect the dock to the TV, detach the Joy-Con 2 controllers and place the console in the dock. For wireless use, the controllers need to be paired with the system.

Do I always need a subscription to play a digital detective game?

Not necessarily; check the requirements for the specific game and way of playing. Microsoft lists Game Pass Ultimate as a separate membership. For the cloud gaming option mentioned for Duck Detective, the Xbox Store lists both a suitable subscription and a game purchase.

What should I check when choosing a mystery game for a child?

Check the PEGI age rating and the content of the specific game. Kijkwijzer also outlines Dutch rules on shops and libraries providing games to people below the PEGI age rating; a rating for one game doesn’t automatically apply to other titles.

Who should I contact in the Netherlands about a faulty console?

According to the Dutch government, you should report a faulty product to the seller, who must provide a solution. The Netherlands doesn’t have a fixed statutory guarantee period for all products; what you can expect depends, among other things, on the product and how it’s used.