Who are these console options suitable for?

Organiser of a group games night

Wants several neighbours to play the same cooking game at once, so checks the game’s player limit and how many compatible controllers are needed. Team17 lists a maximum of four players for Overcooked! All You Can Eat; Nintendo says each multiplayer participant needs a compatible controller.

Host for players of mixed experience

Wants a setup that lets new players join in and game settings that can make the fast pace of a cooking game less intense. Nintendo describes an Assist Mode for Overcooked! All You Can Eat.

Club that plays at different venues

Wants to switch between playing on a TV and playing without a permanent TV setup. Nintendo describes TV play for Switch and Switch 2, while Switch 2 also supports tabletop and handheld modes.

What should your community club consider?

If your community club wants to play cooking games together, these questions will help you assess the console, game and controllers as one complete setup.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Playing together locally Check the local multiplayer limit and supported controller setup for the exact game edition. Count how many compatible controllers you’ll need and how many are included with the console. If we want to cook together as a whole group locally, I want to know whether the game and controllers suit the number of players. Around 36% of consumers make local multiplayer their top priority.
Welcoming new players Check whether the game has the accessibility and readability options you want. If possible, try the controller setup with the people who will be playing. When players have different levels of gaming experience, I want to check whether the settings make the time pressure and controls more accessible. Around 29% of consumers prioritise an easy introduction to the game.
TV play and different venues Decide whether the club will play on a TV and check that the console supports TV mode. Also compare the play styles available for use at other venues. If we won’t always use the same TV, I want to be able to use the console in different places. For around 21% of consumers, being able to move between venues is their main purchasing priority.
Game format and complete setup Check whether the console can read discs, how many compatible controllers are included and whether an online subscription is needed for online play. To compare the complete setup and the games we already own, I want to know whether digital games or discs are right for the club. Around 14% of consumers prioritise game format and the overall setup.

Buying pitfalls to avoid

  • Choosing a Switch Lite for a TV setup

    The Nintendo Switch Lite cannot connect to a TV. This makes it unsuitable if your club wants to play together on a TV screen.

    Before you buy, check that your chosen Switch model supports TV mode and that the dock and connections are suitable for your planned setup.

  • Assuming four players means four controllers are included

    A game may support up to four players according to its publisher, but that doesn’t mean the console bundle includes four compatible controllers. Nintendo requires one compatible controller per player for multiplayer; the PS5 Digital Edition and Xbox Series S models described here each come with one controller.

    Make a note of how many people will be playing at once and check how many compatible controllers are actually included with the console before you buy.

  • Choosing a digital console for an existing disc collection

    The Xbox Series S 512 GB is all-digital. PlayStation says a PS4 disc won’t work for the upgrade described here on a PS5 Digital Edition without a disc drive.

    Before choosing a model without a disc drive, check which game versions your club already owns and whether they’re compatible with the console you’re considering.

  • Assuming all Switch games and accessories work fully with Switch 2

    Nintendo warns that some older Switch games and accessories aren’t supported or may not be fully compatible. Older Joy-Con controllers can be paired wirelessly, but can’t be attached to a Switch 2.

    Before reusing existing accessories, check Nintendo’s information on compatibility for the specific game and controllers.

Relevant brands to consider

Nintendo

A good fit for clubs that want to combine TV play with other ways to play. The Switch Lite is designed specifically for handheld play and doesn’t support TV mode.

  • Nintendo describes TV play for Switch and Switch 2. Switch 2 also supports tabletop and handheld modes.
  • Nintendo lists versions of Overcooked! for Switch and Switch 2; according to Nintendo, Overcooked! All You Can Eat has an Assist Mode.
  • Not every older Switch game or accessory is fully compatible with Switch 2. Check the specific game and controller.

PlayStation

An option for a permanent TV setup if the cooking game you want is available for PlayStation.

  • The Dutch PlayStation Store lists Overcooked! All You Can Eat for PS4 and PS5, for one to four players.
  • The PS5 Digital Edition reviewed here comes with one controller. A PS4 disc won’t give you access to the digital upgrade described here on a PS5 without a disc drive.

Xbox

An option for a permanent TV setup with an Xbox version of Overcooked! All You Can Eat available.

  • Microsoft describes the Xbox Series S 512 GB as all-digital and the Series X model compared here as having a disc drive.
  • The Series S and Series X bundles mentioned each include one controller. Team17’s four-player limit applies to the cooking game, not to all Xbox games.

Joybuy consoles for cooking games

These consoles suit the setups we’ve looked at: playing on a TV, gaming at different venues or using a digital PlayStation setup.

Nintendo Switch OLED Neon-Red/Blue

Nintendo Switch OLED Neon-Red/Blue

Suited to a club that wants to play on a TV and at other venues; Nintendo describes TV play for the Switch OLED.

The product description lists handheld and tabletop play. For multiplayer, check that the game you choose and the Joy-Con controllers available suit your group.

View at Joybuy
Sony PlayStation 5 Console Slim 825GB Digital Edition

Sony PlayStation 5 Console Slim 825GB Digital Edition

Suited to a permanent TV setup if your club wants to play the cooking game it has chosen digitally on PlayStation.

Digital Edition with 825 GB; this model has no disc drive. Check the game version and how many controllers your group will need.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 Console EU

Nintendo Switch 2 Console EU

Suited to a club that wants to switch between TV, tabletop and handheld play; Nintendo lists local multiplayer for Overcooked! 2 – Nintendo Switch 2 Edition.

Before using older Switch games and accessories, check whether the specific model is compatible.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can four neighbours cook together on one console?

Yes. According to publisher Team17, Overcooked! All You Can Eat supports up to four players, both offline and online. For local multiplayer, each player needs a compatible controller, so check the game edition and the controllers included with the console bundle.

Do we need an online subscription for a games night in the same room?

The publisher describes offline play for up to four players. The Dutch PlayStation Store specifically lists PS Plus as a requirement for online play; that doesn’t mean you need a subscription to play locally in the same room.

How do we connect a Switch to the club TV?

To connect a Nintendo Switch or Switch OLED, use the dock and an HDMI cable, then select the corresponding HDMI input on the TV. Nintendo describes TV play with a dock for Switch 2. The Switch Lite doesn’t support TV mode.

What should we check if children are playing?

Check the age rating for the exact game. Nintendo lists PEGI 3 for the Overcooked! versions reviewed here; according to the Dutch government, PEGI is an age recommendation and doesn’t indicate how easy a game is to play.

What rights does the club have if a console is faulty?

For a product sold to a consumer, the Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets describes a legal guarantee under which the seller is responsible for resolving the issue if the product is faulty. Whether these consumer rules apply when a club buys in its own name depends on who is legally making the purchase; check the buyer and the applicable terms of sale.