Who is this guide for?

Student who takes recordings with them

If you copy large recording files between home and school, consider whether the connections are suitable, how you usually copy files and how easy the drive is to carry. Testaankoop and Western Digital Support both identify data transfer and the computer port in use as important considerations.

Recording archive creator

If you store several full recordings but don’t copy them often, weigh up the storage space you need against how quickly you want to transfer files. Testaankoop discusses storage capacity as one difference between HDDs and SSDs; Seagate specifies 2 TB for the EMEA version of the Basic Portable Drive STJL2000400.

Student using Windows and Mac

If you want to save files on both computers, check that the drive can read and write on both systems before transferring or formatting files. Apple Support explains the limitations of NTFS on a Mac, while Western Digital says that certain My Passport models are supplied in NTFS format.

What should you look for?

First decide whether you’ll be taking the drive with you regularly or mainly using it to store a recording archive. Then check the capacity, connections and file systems you need.

Portable external SSD

A good fit for: regular copying, carrying the drive with you or using files directly from it.

Bear in mind: the quoted speed depends partly on your computer port and cable. Maximum speeds don’t guarantee a particular copying time.

Portable external HDD

A good fit for: a large recording archive that you mainly store and transfer less often.

Bear in mind: according to Testaankoop, mechanical drives are more susceptible to knocks than SSDs.

Consideration What to look for Who should think about this most?
Quick copying and easy to carry Check the USB ports on both computers and the cable you’ll need. Bear in mind that the host device and cable can limit transfer speeds. If I often take recordings between home and school, I want to transfer them quickly and connect the drive easily. Around 33% of consumers say copying and portability are their top priorities.
Space for recordings Add up the size of your recording and project files, then choose a suitable capacity. Remember that some space won’t be available after formatting. If I store several full recordings, having enough archive space matters more to me than speed. Around 25% of consumers say storage space is their top priority.
Sharing files between computers Check that both computers can read and write to the file system. Only format the drive after copying important files elsewhere. If I use different computers at home and school, I want to be able to open and save project files on both. Around 25% of consumers say sharing files between computers is their top priority.
Keeping recordings safe and limiting access Keep a separate copy in addition to the working drive and check that the files open. Decide who should be able to access recognisable footage. If the recordings are important or show identifiable people, I want to be able to restore files and manage access carefully. Around 17% of consumers say keeping files safe and limiting access are their top priorities.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming the maximum MB/s figure is your actual copying speed

    Choosing a suitable drive isn’t the only factor that affects transfer speeds. Western Digital Support lists the speed of the computer port, adapters and the type of files as some of the factors involved.

    Check the ports and cables on both computers before choosing a drive based on its quoted speed.

  • Formatting without first securing your existing files

    Formatting can erase the contents of a drive. Apple Support also says that NTFS is read-only by default on a Mac.

    First check that your files are stored elsewhere and find out which file system both computers can use. Only format the drive afterwards, if necessary.

  • Assuming a robust drive is a complete backup

    A sturdy casing or plenty of storage space won’t, on its own, give you a second copy of your recordings.

    Keep the original recording and a separate copy on different devices or in different locations. Also check that the copied files open.

  • Assuming you can share recordings just because they’re for school

    The Rijksoverheid distinguishes between a private copy for personal use and distributing or making protected music available to the public. Rules on educational use don’t automatically apply to every recording or way of sharing it.

    Before sharing, check who owns the rights, who can view the recording and what rules the school follows.

Brands to compare

Kingston

The XS1000 range is worth comparing if you’re looking for a compact SSD with USB-A and USB-C connectivity.

  • Kingston quotes maximum read speeds of 1.050 MB/s and write speeds of 1.000 MB/s for the XS1000.
  • According to Kingston, the quoted speeds require a suitable USB 3.2 Gen 2 host. The manufacturer offers a five-year limited warranty, subject to the applicable warranty terms.

Samsung

The T7 Shield is an SSD range to consider if you carry your drive around often and specified levels of protection matter to you.

  • For the black 1 TB T7 Shield, MU-PE1T0S/EU, Samsung quotes sequential read speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s and sequential write speeds of 1.000 MB/s, along with IP65 and password protection.
  • These are the manufacturer’s specifications for this version, not a guarantee that your files will be safe without a separate copy.

Crucial

The 1 TB X9, CT1000X9SSD9, is a USB-C SSD worth comparing if you need to move files between devices.

  • Crucial quotes read speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s and says the drive is supplied in exFAT format.
  • The manufacturer says performance depends on the host device and cable. Formatting erases existing data on the drive.

Seagate

The Basic Portable Drive is a portable HDD range to compare if you mainly want to store a recording archive.

  • For the EMEA version STJL2000400, Seagate lists a capacity of 2 TB, USB 3.0 and power supplied through the cable.
  • Seagate offers a two-year limited warranty for this version. According to the data sheet, the drive needs to be reformatted for use with a Mac.

Western Digital

The My Passport HDD range is an alternative to compare if storage space and access security are important to you.

  • Western Digital says that the My Passport models described are supplied in NTFS format, have a Micro-B connection and support AES hardware encryption.
  • According to Western Digital, NTFS needs to be changed to write to the drive from macOS. Check the version and the terms of the security software.

Joybuy product picks

This selection includes portable SSDs for regular copying and HDDs for storing recording files.

SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD, 1 TB

SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD, 1 TB

A portable SSD to compare if you regularly take files with you and copy them.

1 TB of storage and read speeds of up to 2.000 MB/s; this maximum speed requires a suitable USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 host, and the write speed is lower.

The product description lists IP65, drop protection from up to 3 m and 256-bit AES password protection.

Joybuy
Portable SSD, 1 TB

Portable SSD, 1 TB

A portable SSD to consider if you want to move files between compatible devices.

The product description lists 1 TB of storage, read speeds of up to 1.000 MB/s and compatibility with Windows, macOS, iPadOS and Android.

A USB-C to USB-A adapter is mentioned for devices with a suitable USB-A port.

Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport, 2 TB, black

Western Digital My Passport, 2 TB, black

A portable HDD to compare if you mainly want to store several recordings.

This version is listed with 2 TB of storage, USB 3.2 Gen 1, USB bus power and 256-bit AES hardware encryption.

As an HDD, this model is more susceptible to knocks than an SSD, according to Testaankoop. Bear this in mind if you carry the drive around often.

Joybuy
Samsung Portable SSD T7, 2 TB, blue

Samsung Portable SSD T7, 2 TB, blue

A portable SSD to compare if you regularly move recordings between computers.

This version is listed with 2 TB of storage, read speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s and write speeds of up to 1.000 MB/s.

The product description lists USB 3.2 Gen 2, AES 256-bit encryption, drop resistance from up to 2 m, and USB-C to USB-C and USB-C to USB-A cables included.

Joybuy
Toshiba Canvio Ready external hard drive, 2 TB

Toshiba Canvio Ready, 2 TB

A portable HDD to consider if you want to store several recordings and take the drive with you.

This version is listed with 2 TB of storage, a 2.5-inch design, Micro-USB B, USB 3.2 Gen 1 and USB bus power.

As an HDD, this model is more susceptible to knocks than an SSD, according to Testaankoop. Bear this in mind when transporting it.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Which file system should I use if I have a Mac at home and use Windows at school?

First check that both computers can read and write to the file system. Apple Support lists exFAT as a format the Mac can write to and says that NTFS is read-only by default; Crucial says the X9 is supplied in exFAT format. Don’t format the drive until important files are safely stored elsewhere, as formatting erases its contents.

Is one external drive enough to store the original concert recordings?

Not if those are your only copies. VeiligInternetten describes a backup as a copy of files stored elsewhere. So, as well as your working drive, keep a separate accessible copy and check that the copied file opens.

Do I need a faster USB connection to copy concert recordings?

Only if your computer port and cable support that speed and it benefits the way you work. Western Digital Support lists the speed of the host port, adapters and the type of files as some of the factors that affect transfer speeds. A product’s maximum speed isn’t a promise of how long copying will take.

Can I give copied concert recordings to classmates or post them online?

Not automatically. The Rijksoverheid distinguishes between a private copy for personal use and distributing or making copyright-protected music available to the public. Guidance on educational use depends on the situation and doesn’t give general permission to copy and distribute concert recordings. Check which rights and school rules apply to this recording and how you plan to use it.

What do I need to arrange if students are recognisable in the concert video?

For the situation described, where a school records and publishes footage in which students are recognisable, the Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens says that consent and good security are required. According to the AP, the school must ask students aged 16 or over for their consent, and parents for consent on behalf of younger students. This guidance concerns the school’s use of footage in the situation described and doesn’t mean that every private recording is treated in the same way.