Who is this choice relevant to?

Collector with several devices

You want to store recordings from, for example, a computer and external storage together on your home network, without using a public cloud. Synology documents USB copying between a NAS and external USB or SD storage.

Recording owner who values recovery

You want to be able to restore a recording if it’s lost or damaged, so you’re looking for a separate backup in addition to your NAS. The National Cyber Security Centre lists an external hard drive as a possible backup destination.

Occasional copier

You mainly copy files from one computer and want to weigh up whether you need a NAS with shared network storage, or whether an external drive is enough for the way you work.

What should you look for?

For concert recordings stored without a public cloud, the main considerations depend on how you copy files, how you want to recover them and how much storage you need.

Consideration What to look for when buying Who should pay particular attention?
Local storage and access control Check that your copying method works without a public cloud and find out which settings for remote access can be managed separately. I want to store recordings from several devices at home without a public cloud and decide for myself who can access them. Around 33% of consumers prioritise local storage and access control.
Being able to recover recordings Check how to make a separate backup and whether you can restore files from it; mirroring is not a separate copy. If I want to recover recordings after an error or fault, I need a separate copy as well as the NAS. Recovery is a priority for around 27% of consumers.
Easy import of recordings Check the USB connection, supported file system, direction of copying and task settings for the exact model. When recordings are already on a USB drive, I want to transfer them to local storage with as few manual steps as possible. Easy importing is the main reason to buy for around 20% of consumers.
Capacity and total cost Work out how much space your archive needs and check whether the offer includes drives; also allow for a separate backup destination. I want to know in advance how much space my archive needs and what the enclosure, drives and separate backup will cost together. Capacity and total cost matter most to around 20% of consumers.

Common pitfalls

  • Mistaking mirroring for a separate backup

    Drives in the same NAS don’t give you a separately stored copy. If files are lost, you’ll need another recovery destination.

    Keep important recordings on a separate storage device too, and check that you can restore files from it.

  • Confusing USB synchronisation with copying

    QNAP explains that the synchronisation action can delete destination files that aren’t in the source; the copy action handles those existing destination files differently.

    Before starting the task, check what will happen to existing recordings and try the setting first with files you can replace.

  • Comparing only the NAS enclosure

    The number of drive bays doesn’t tell you whether drives are included in a particular offer.

    Check what’s included in the offer, which drives you need and where you’ll keep a separate backup.

  • Enabling internet sharing for home use

    Local storage and access over the internet are different features. Even when using your NAS at home, manage your accounts and updates carefully.

    Set up local access first and only enable remote access if you specifically want it.

Brands to compare

Synology

The DiskStation DS223j is a NAS with two drive bays for centralised storage. Synology describes USB Copy as a separate feature for copying between the NAS and external USB or SD storage.

  • Synology’s product specifications list two drive bays for the DS223j.
  • Check whether the USB file system is recognised and whether your chosen model has a physical copy button; the USB Copy feature doesn’t confirm this.

QNAP

QNAP positions the TS-233 for first-time home users who want to store files centrally.

  • QNAP describes file management and account security for this model.
  • Check the USB import process and internet access settings separately; a remote access feature isn’t a requirement for local storage.

ASUSTOR

ASUSTOR describes the Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL as a two-bay model with gigabit Ethernet and USB ports.

  • The manufacturer lists local NAS backup to an external device.
  • Published transfer performance figures are laboratory results, not an independent measurement of copying your concert recordings.

TerraMaster

The manufacturer describes the F2-212 as a two-bay NAS for centralised home storage.

  • TerraMaster documents USB Copy in TOS 7 for importing and exporting, provided the external file system is recognised.
  • Check which version of TOS is installed on the device. Older information about the F2-212 describes TOS 5 and doesn’t confirm that every existing installation uses TOS 7.

Products for local storage

This selection includes NAS devices for centralised home storage, plus an external drive for anyone who mainly copies files from one computer.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Worth considering if you want to manage files centrally from several devices; the product description states that hard drives are not included. Plan for a separate backup too.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q

Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q

An option to compare if you want to manage files centrally. Check which drives are included and whether the USB import method suits where your recordings are stored now.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Worth a look if you’re considering a larger storage setup; work out how much space your archive needs in advance and keep a separate recovery copy.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

Worth comparing if you’re looking for centralised file sharing. The product title states that hard drives are not included; also check how you’ll make a separate recovery copy.

View at Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport 2TB Black

Western Digital My Passport 2TB Black

Worth considering if you mainly want to copy files locally from one computer. The product name specifies 2TB; check that the connection is compatible with your computer and keep important files in a separate location too.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I copy files from a USB drive without using a public cloud?

Yes, a local USB copying method is documented for certain NAS models. Synology describes USB Copy, and TerraMaster describes USB Copy in TOS 7. Check that the import task you need is available for your model, software version and USB file system.

Does my NAS need to be accessible over the internet to store recordings at home?

No, public cloud storage isn’t part of the local USB copying method described here. Some models also offer separate internet access features; manage your accounts and updates even if you mainly use the NAS at home.

What should I buy or set up in addition to the NAS?

Check whether the NAS includes drives, which drives are compatible and where you’ll keep a separate recovery copy. According to Synology, the DS223j has two drive bays; the National Cyber Security Centre lists an external drive as a possible backup destination. Test that you can recover files from that copy.

What warranty applies if the NAS breaks down?

When you buy as a consumer in the Netherlands, the product must meet what you could reasonably expect from it. According to the Dutch government, there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands; if a product is faulty, the retailer is your point of contact. Any manufacturer’s warranty is separate from this.

Can I copy or share any concert recording on my NAS?

No, storing a recording on a NAS doesn’t change the rights attached to it. According to the Dutch government, a private copy of protected material for personal use must not be distributed or made public; Stichting de Thuiskopie also states that the source must be legal. Recording a performance yourself raises a separate rights question: Auteursrecht.nl states that performing musicians can give permission for their performance to be recorded. Check the source of existing recordings and the relevant permissions and event terms before making your own recording.