Choose drive capacity based on your existing recordings, expected growth and the usable space available in your chosen NAS configuration, and check that the exact model is compatible. Mirroring can help you maintain access if one drive fails, but Seagate stresses that RAID is not a backup. For irreplaceable recordings, make sure you also have a separate copy that you can restore.
Who is this choice relevant to?
Keeper of unique recordings
If you keep concert files that can’t be obtained again, you’ll need a plan for storing and restoring copies as well as a suitable drive. The Library of Congress recommends keeping copies on different types of storage media and in separate physical locations.
Manager of a growing archive
If you keep adding new concert recordings, compare your current storage needs and expected annual growth with the NAS’s usable capacity. Western Digital lists Red Plus options including 4 TB and 8 TB models; the right capacity depends on your archive and storage configuration.
Coordinator of shared access
If you share recordings with several authorised colleagues, you can set up NAS accounts and access permissions as well as drive storage. The Dutch Data Protection Authority lists authorisation and network segmentation as examples of security measures.
What should you look for in a NAS drive for a concert archive?
One NAS drive with a separate backup
Suitable when: one drive provides enough space for your archive and you mainly use the NAS to store files.
Bear in mind: if the drive fails, there is no second NAS drive to maintain access; your separate copy must be restorable.
Mirrored drives plus a separate backup
Suitable when: maintaining access if one drive fails is important and your NAS supports a suitable mirroring configuration.
Bear in mind: both drives contain the same files, so you can’t add their capacities together to calculate usable archive space; mirroring is not a substitute for a backup.
A copy in another location
Suitable when: you also need to protect recordings if the NAS or its location is affected.
Bear in mind: an additional storage destination needs managing; the Library of Congress recommends keeping copies on different types of media and in separate physical locations.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Recoverability |
Set up a separate backup destination and check that you can restore files from it. Seagate points out that RAID is not a backup. |
If I manage unique concert recordings, I want to be able to restore a copy even after losing a drive or NAS. Recoverability is the top priority for around 33% of consumers. |
| Capacity and growth |
Calculate your current storage needs and allow for expected growth and the configuration’s usable space. |
If you manage a growing archive, you’ll want to plan space for both existing and future recordings. Around 25% of consumers prioritise capacity. |
| NAS compatibility |
Check the full model code, connection type and compatibility information from the NAS manufacturer. Western Digital distinguishes between drive variants and recording technologies, including CMR and SMR. |
If I use an existing NAS, I want to know whether the specific drive variant I’ve chosen is suitable for my setup. Compatibility is the top priority for around 25% of consumers. |
| Shared access |
Check the NAS’s account and authorisation options; these are NAS features, not features of the internal drive. |
If you share recordings with several authorised colleagues, you’ll want to manage access without automatically making files available to everyone. Around 17% of consumers prioritise controlled access. |
Buying pitfalls when choosing NAS drives
-
Counting mirrored drives as double the archive space
With mirroring, the same data is stored on both drives. Their combined stated capacities therefore don’t reflect the usable archive space.
Calculate the usable space for your chosen NAS configuration before selecting a capacity.
-
Relying on RAID or a recovery service as your only backup
RAID doesn’t protect against every type of data loss. A recovery service also isn’t a separate copy that you can restore yourself.
Plan a separate storage destination and check regularly that you can restore files from it.
-
Assuming a series name confirms model compatibility
A product range can include variants with different model codes or recording technologies; the series name alone doesn’t confirm that a specific drive is suitable for your NAS.
Before buying, compare the full model code with the NAS compatibility information and the specifications of the drive in question.
NAS brands to compare
Western Digital
Western Digital describes WD Red Plus as a 3.5-inch NAS drive range for RAID-optimised systems with up to eight drive bays. The manufacturer lists models including the 4 TB WD40EFPX and the 8 TB WD80EFPX.
- Western Digital specifies CMR and a rated workload of 180 TB per year for Red Plus.
- Western Digital also describes WD Red variants that use SMR. Check the full model code to make sure that specific variant is suitable for your NAS.
Seagate
Seagate describes IronWolf as a range of internal NAS drives for systems with one to eight drive bays. The specifications list the ST16000VN001 as a 16 TB variant.
- Seagate specifies CMR and a rated workload of 180 TB per year for the IronWolf range reviewed.
- Check each model to see whether health monitoring and any recovery services are supported, and what conditions apply.
Toshiba
Toshiba positions the N300 as a 3.5-inch SATA NAS drive range for uses including archiving and multi-user storage.
- Toshiba lists 24/7 operation and variants starting at 4 TB for the N300 range.
- Toshiba distinguishes between variants and the number of supported drive bays. Check the exact model code and its compatibility with your NAS.
NAS drives at Joybuy
These internal NAS drives are options for an archive on a single drive volume. Choose a capacity to suit your files and NAS configuration, and make sure you also have a separate backup.
No image available
Synology SATA HDD 16 TB, 7,200 rpm
An option for a Synology NAS if 16 TB meets your capacity needs and the exact model’s compatibility has been confirmed.
Specifications: 16 TB, 3.5-inch, SATA 6 Gb/s, 7,200 rpm and CMR. The product description mentions 24/7 NAS use and multi-user applications.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Western Digital WD Red Plus 8 TB
An option for a NAS archive if the stated 8 TB capacity meets your needs and your NAS supports this drive variant.
Specifications: internal 3.5-inch drive, SATA 6 Gb/s, 5,640 rpm, CMR and 256 MB cache. The product description mentions NAS use with up to 8 drive bays and 24/7 operation.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Red Plus 6 TB (256 MB cache)
An option for a NAS archive if 6 TB meets your storage needs and your chosen NAS supports the exact variant.
Specifications: internal 3.5-inch drive, SATA III 6 Gb/s, 5,400 rpm and 256 MB cache. The product description mentions a workload rate of 180 TB per year and data transfer speeds of up to 180 MB/s.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions about NAS storage for concert recordings
Is a mirrored NAS already a backup of my concert recordings?
No. Mirroring can help you maintain access if one drive fails, but Seagate notes that RAID is not a backup. Make a separate copy too, and check that you can restore files from it.
How should you prepare to install a new NAS drive?
First check the full model code and whether it’s supported by the NAS manufacturer. Before replacing or reconfiguring drives, make sure you have a separate backup; the next steps depend on your chosen NAS configuration.
Can concert recordings be copied or shared with a community archive without restriction?
Don’t assume so. According to the Dutch Government, the private copying exception is for personal use and does not allow distribution or making recordings available to the public. Performers and producers may also have related rights; the permission you need depends on the rights applying to the specific recordings and the intended access.
What if archive files contain personal data?
If an organisation processes personal data, it must protect it appropriately, according to the Dutch Data Protection Authority. Consider who needs access, and separately whether personal data may be shared and on what legal basis; the appropriate measures depend on the processing and the risks.