A portable HDD is a good fit for an archive that is copied periodically, usually from a fixed location. An SSD may be more convenient if volunteers often transfer large files between computers or locations. First, measure the collection and allow for planned versions, check the connection and file system, and arrange a separate copy and a recovery test too: one drive is not a complete backup plan.
Who is this guide for?
Manager of a growing teaching archive
You want to keep documents, scans and media, including different versions, so you can find and open them later. So don't just look at the capacity on the box: the National Cyber Security Centre also highlights the importance of backups and recovery tests.
Volunteer who shares files
You move teaching resources between computers or locations. The connection, file system and transfer all matter, as does handling the drive safely while it's being transported.
Manager of sensitive files
If the archive contains identifiable people or other personal data, make sure access and security are appropriate for the way the data is processed. The Dutch Data Protection Authority stresses that security measures should be appropriate to the risks.
What should you consider?
Portable HDD
A good fit for: periodically copying a growing collection that is usually kept in one place.
Bear in mind: you need enough capacity for current files and older versions, should handle the drive carefully when transporting it, and will need a separate copy.
Portable SSD
A good fit for: regularly transferring large teaching videos or scans, or taking the drive between volunteers.
Bear in mind: actual transfer speeds also depend on the computer, USB port and cable; the stated maximum speed is no guarantee of how quickly your backup will run.
The National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping multiple versions of important files and testing recovery. The National Archives stresses that files should also remain accessible with available software.
| Requirement |
What to look for when buying |
Who is this important for? |
| Space for the collection and its versions |
Measure the current size and allow for additions and older versions; then compare the capacity of the exact model. |
If I want to keep teaching resources and earlier versions, there needs to be room for the collection to grow. Around 29% of consumers prioritise having enough archive space. |
| Being able to recover files |
Decide where a second copy will be kept, who will run the backup, and how you will periodically restore and open files. |
If a file is changed accidentally or the drive fails, I want to know that a usable copy is ready. Around 29% of consumers give recoverability top priority. |
| Sharing files between computers |
Check the USB ports, included cables and file system of the model you choose before transferring files to it or reformatting the drive. |
If volunteers use different computers, I want to be able to transfer teaching resources without connection or formatting problems. Around 21% of consumers prioritise smooth file sharing. |
| Access to sensitive files |
Establish whether the archive contains personal data, how security will be configured, and how authorised successors can safely retrieve access credentials. |
If the drive goes missing, I want to prevent unauthorised people from accessing personal data without locking volunteers out. Around 21% of consumers focus on access and privacy. |
Common mistakes
-
Assuming one external drive is a complete backup plan
If the computer and the only backup are lost at the same time, the archive could be gone. A copy that has never been tested may also prove unusable.
Before you buy, decide where a second copy will be kept and who will periodically restore and open files. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping multiple versions and testing recovery.
A separate copy requires extra storage, and someone will need to set aside time for recovery tests.
-
Assuming the stated top speed is the actual transfer speed
The computer, USB port and cable all affect the achievable transfer speed; an SSD's maximum speed doesn't tell you how quickly your backup will run.
Check the connections and included cables on all the computers you use. Choose a faster drive mainly if you regularly move large files.
-
Choosing encryption without managing the keys
Security only helps if authorised volunteers can access the files. Lost passwords or keys can make files inaccessible.
Assign people to manage access and recovery. If the archive contains personal data, make sure security measures are appropriate to the risks involved in processing it.
Managing access and recovery securely takes time and requires an agreed procedure for passwords or keys.
Relevant brands to consider
Seagate
The portable Expansion range includes models with different capacities, including the 2 TB STKM2000400 and the 4 TB STKM4000400.
- The models mentioned offer a clear choice of storage capacity for collections of different sizes.
- Capacity alone doesn't provide a separate backup or a recovery test.
Toshiba
The Canvio Basics HDTB520EK3AA we reviewed is a 2 TB portable HDD.
- According to Toshiba, this model is powered via USB and comes with a Type-A to Micro-B cable.
- According to Toshiba, the model we reviewed is formatted as NTFS; reformatting is required for macOS. This doesn't automatically apply to other Toshiba models.
Samsung
The Portable SSD T7 MU-PC2T0T/WW is the 2 TB portable SSD model we reviewed.
- Samsung specifies maximum read and write speeds of 1.050 MB/s and 1.000 MB/s respectively. USB-C to C and USB-C to A cables are included.
- These are stated maximum speeds, not measured speeds for your archive. Password protection with AES-256 encryption is optional and needs to be set up.
Crucial
The X9 Portable SSD CT2000X9SSD9 is the 2 TB USB-C drive we reviewed.
- Crucial states a maximum read speed of 1.050 MB/s under specified test conditions and says the drive is supplied in exFAT format.
- Speed and compatibility depend on the host device and formatting. Reformatting erases data on the drive, so check the exact model first and make a copy if needed.
Products at Joybuy
This selection includes portable SSDs for copying and transferring files, and portable HDDs for local storage and backups. Compare capacity, connection and any compatibility requirements with the archive's computers and working practices.
No image available
SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB
A portable SSD for keeping an external copy that you can take between locations.
1 TB storage; stated read speed of up to 800 MB/s; drop protection from heights of up to 2 metres.
View at Joybuy
No image available
SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB
A portable SSD for anyone who regularly transfers files and has a suitable USB connection.
1 TB storage; stated read speed of up to 2.000 MB/s when used with a compatible USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 host device. A USB-C cable and USB-A adapter are listed as included.
View at Joybuy
No image available
My Passport 6TB White
A portable HDD for a local copy of a collection for which 6 TB of storage is relevant.
6 TB; product information lists password protection, 256-bit AES hardware encryption, backup software, USB power and an included USB cable.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Western Digital My Passport 2TB Black
A portable HDD for local storage and copies of teaching files.
2 TB; USB 3.2 Gen 1; product information lists 256-bit AES hardware encryption and automatic backup software. According to the product description, an additional driver is required to read and write on macOS.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Toshiba Canvas Basics 1TB Black 2.5" USB 3.2
A portable HDD for a local copy or transferring files from a Windows computer.
1 TB; USB 3.2 Gen 1 with backwards compatibility for USB 2.0. According to the product description, the drive is pre-formatted for Windows; it needs to be reformatted for macOS, which may erase existing data.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is one external drive enough to back up the teaching archive?
No, not if you also want to guard against losing the drive or an incident at one location. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping multiple versions on different media and storing a copy at another location. You should also test that important files can be restored and opened.
Do I need to format a new drive to use it with Windows and Mac computers?
It depends on the exact drive and the computers you use. Toshiba says the Canvio Basics model we reviewed uses NTFS and needs to be reformatted for macOS; Crucial supplies the X9 model we reviewed in exFAT. Reformatting may erase data on the drive, so check its format and make a copy of any existing files first.
How can we keep teaching resources readable in the long term?
Don't just store files; make sure they remain easy to find and can be opened with available software. The National Archives notes that file formats and software support can change, so include a representative selection of documents and media in your recovery tests.
Which Dutch privacy rules apply to backups containing personal data?
If your organisation processes personal data, the GDPR requires appropriate security measures tailored to the risks involved; the Dutch Data Protection Authority does not prescribe one specific type of external drive. Whether a data breach needs to be reported depends on the risk assessment. The applicable requirements depend on the content and how the organisation processes it.