A NAS makes most sense when several administrators need regular network access to presentation files. For a one-off copy by a single administrator, an external drive may be simpler. If you choose a NAS, prioritise access permissions, a separate backup that you can restore from, and a manageable copying routine. The National Cyber Security Centre stresses that central storage alone is not a backup.
Who is this choice relevant to?
Volunteer archive administrator
You want to be able to find presentation files and restore them if something goes wrong. A second drive in the same NAS is not automatically a complete backup. The National Cyber Security Centre and Synology Knowledge Center explain the importance of keeping a separate recovery copy.
Shared-file coordinator
You want to give several volunteers access while deciding who can read or edit files. The Dutch Data Protection Authority stresses that organisations must decide for themselves which appropriate security measures to take when processing personal data.
Administrator who copies files regularly
You regularly take in new presentations and want to check in advance that the connections and copying steps suit the volunteers’ devices and way of working.
What should you look for?
External drive for a one-off copy
A good fit when: you’re transferring the presentations once and don’t need shared network access.
Trade-off: managing an external drive is simpler than managing a NAS, but you’ll still need a separate backup.
NAS with two drive bays
A good fit when: several administrators need regular access and the files you’ve listed will fit the chosen configuration, with room to grow.
Trade-off: central access and mirroring are possible, but mirroring is no substitute for a backup stored elsewhere.
NAS with more drive bays or a faster network port
A good fit when: your file inventory requires more space, or you regularly transfer large files over a network that supports the higher speed.
Trade-off: a faster port won’t automatically make copying faster; the other network connections and the types of files matter too.
The National Cyber Security Centre points out that central storage is not a backup. So, alongside deciding how you’ll copy files, work out how you’ll restore them, manage access permissions and handle new files as they come in.
| Consideration |
What to look for when buying |
Who is this most relevant to? |
| Restoring files |
Check whether there’s a backup destination outside the NAS, how the backup routine works and whether a test restore is practical. |
If I need to recover a presentation after something goes wrong, I want to know that a separate copy exists. Around 31% of consumers in this situation prioritise the ability to restore files. |
| Volunteer access |
Check whether you can set up accounts and folder permissions, and decide who is allowed to read or edit files. |
I want to give volunteers access without automatically giving everyone permission to edit files. Around 25% of consumers in this situation prioritise access management. |
| Copying presentations |
Decide whether files will come in via a computer, network or USB; check the copying steps for the exact model. |
If new presentations arrive regularly, I want to be able to transfer and check them without unnecessary steps. Around 19% of consumers in this situation prioritise the copying routine. |
| Complete setup |
Check what’s included and which drives or separate backup destination you’ll still need. |
I want to know in advance what I’ll need in addition to the NAS to set up the archive and backup. Around 13% of consumers in this situation focus mainly on the complete setup. |
| Usable capacity |
List your current files and expected additions, then compare the usable capacity of the drive configuration you’ve chosen. |
If the archive grows, I want to avoid looking only at the drives’ raw capacity. Around 12% of consumers in this situation prioritise having enough usable space. |
Common pitfalls
-
Assuming mirroring is a complete backup
Central storage or mirroring won’t protect you against every kind of data loss.
Set up a backup on a separate destination and try restoring a presentation.
-
Comparing NAS enclosures alone
The number of drive bays doesn’t, by itself, tell you how much usable space your configuration will provide.
Start by listing your files, then compare complete drive configurations, including a separate backup destination.
-
Assuming a faster network port means faster copying
Any potential speed benefit also depends on your other network connections and the types of files you’re transferring.
Check your computers’ and network equipment’s connections before using a higher network speed as a selection criterion.
-
Opening a shared archive folder without an access or publishing policy
Volunteers may then be able to view or edit more files than intended. Personal data and protected material may also come with additional obligations.
Separate read, edit and any publishing permissions, and check the contents before sharing files more widely.
Brands to compare when choosing a NAS
Synology
The DiskStation DS223j is a two-bay option for shared documents, access from different devices and backups to other destinations.
- Synology lists Synology Drive and Hyper Backup for this model.
- Check that the drives are compatible and that your chosen backup route is actually set up; the feature specifications don’t tell you how easy it will be to use in your situation.
QNAP
The TS-233 is a two-bay option for central storage of a small archive.
- QNAP lists a USB copy button for the TS-233.
- A copy button doesn’t guarantee that every supplied drive will copy files in the way you want without further setup.
ASUSTOR
The Drivestor 2 AS1102T is a two-bay option to consider if a 2.5-gigabit network port would be useful.
- ASUSTOR lists a 2.5-gigabit port and backup options for this model.
- The port alone doesn’t show that standard presentations will copy faster over your network.
TerraMaster
TerraMaster describes the F2-212 as a two-bay option for central storage, sharing and backup settings.
- TerraMaster describes drive trays and backup and synchronisation software for this model.
- Assess the specific management and recovery steps for the way you run your archive.
Joybuy products
These Synology models are options for central storage and shared archive files. Check which drives are included with each version, and whether your chosen network and backup setup will work for you.
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS
An option to consider if shared storage and room to expand are important; check that the specific configuration suits your archive.
According to the product description, hard drives are not included.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q
An option to consider for shared archive files in a two-bay configuration.
This version is supplied without drives, which you’ll need to buy separately.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1825+
An option to consider if your archive inventory calls for more storage options; check that the specific configuration and connection suit your network.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives
An option to consider if shared storage and extra archive space are important; check that your chosen configuration matches your inventory.
Hard drives are not included.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is a NAS with two mirrored drives enough as a backup?
No. Mirroring is no substitute for a backup stored elsewhere. The National Cyber Security Centre says mirroring can help you keep working if one drive fails, but RAID doesn’t protect against every kind of data loss. Set up a separate copy and check that you can restore it.
How do you manage access for volunteers who change over time?
Decide who can read, add and edit files, then set the relevant permissions. The National Cyber Security Centre also recommends reviewing default settings and passwords during installation, and limiting access over the internet.
Can a community archive copy or publicly share other people’s presentations without permission?
Not necessarily: using or publishing other people’s copyright-protected material may require permission. The Government of the Netherlands describes the private-copying exception as copying for personal use. So check the rights for each presentation, and don’t make files stored on a NAS public by default. If files contain personal data, the organisation must assess the applicable GDPR obligations, including appropriate security and retention periods.
What should you check about components and warranty rights in addition to the NAS enclosure?
Check which drives are included, which drives are compatible with the version you’re buying, and what you’ll need for a separate backup. According to ACM ConsuWijzer, purchases made as a consumer are covered by statutory guarantees under the applicable conditions; don’t assume there’s a standard two-year period. If you’re buying on behalf of an organisation, first establish which contractual and legal rules apply to that purchaser.
Is putting files on a NAS the same as managing a sustainable digital archive?
No. Storing files is not the same as managing them for the long term. The National Archives describes preservation as recording, keeping, managing and making information available in a way that ensures it remains consultable, accessible and authentic in the future. So agree on file names, versions, responsibilities and regular checks too.