Who is this guide for?

People looking after irreplaceable photos

You want to know whether archive photos can be restored if an original is lost. Plan separate copies and check that recovery works by opening files, as the National Cyber Security Centre advises.

Collectors with a growing archive

You’re adding photos from several families and want to consider the archive’s current size and expected growth before choosing a capacity. Toshiba lists Canvio Basics models with capacities of up to 4 TB.

Volunteers who share photos

You move files between workstations or manage photos in which people are recognisable. Check that the connections and file system work with the computers you use, and assess access security separately. The Dutch Data Protection Authority stresses that organisations must determine appropriate security measures.

What should you consider when choosing?

First decide how you’ll keep and restore copies. Then measure your collection and compare connections, file systems and any security features.

What to consider What should you look for? Who should pay extra attention?
Restorable backup Record where your other copies are kept and regularly test whether you can restore and open a few photos. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends restoration tests. I want to be able to restore and open files if an original is lost; around 36% of consumers prioritise recoverability.
Capacity for growth Measure your current collection and estimate how much you’ll add. Compare its size with the capacity of the exact model; Toshiba lists Canvio Basics models with capacities including 4 TB. If the collection keeps growing, I want to avoid finding that planned copies won’t fit; around 29% of consumers prioritise capacity.
Access and protection Decide who can open files and what security measures are appropriate for your archive procedures. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says organisations should tailor security measures to the specific risks. When photos show recognisable people, I want to manage access carefully; around 21% of consumers prioritise protecting people.
Connection and file system Check the USB port, included cable and file system. Toshiba lists NTFS for the Canvio Basics series reviewed and says it must be reformatted for the macOS versions specified. Make a safe copy elsewhere before reformatting. When I share files between workstations, the connection and file system need to work with them; around 14% of consumers prioritise transferring files between devices.

Common mistakes

  • Assuming one external copy is a complete backup plan

    A backup only helps if a usable copy remains and you can restore your files. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping multiple versions of important files and testing that you can restore them.

    Record where separate copies are kept and periodically try restoring and opening a few photos.

    Keeping separate copies and testing them takes extra storage space and time to manage.

  • Assuming a Windows file system will work straight away with every Mac set-up

    Toshiba lists the Canvio Basics model reviewed as formatted in NTFS and says it must be reformatted for the macOS versions specified. If you don’t prepare it correctly, using it across different workstations can be more difficult.

    Check in advance which computers need to be able to write to the drive, and keep existing files somewhere else before formatting it.

    Choosing a suitable file system and, if needed, reformatting the drive safely takes time to prepare.

  • Assuming a password feature means you have permission to publish photos

    Access security and the legal basis for processing or publishing photos are separate matters. The Dutch Data Protection Authority treats photos of recognisable people as personal data.

    Assess appropriate security and the processing or publication of photos separately from your choice of drive.

Brands to consider

Toshiba

Canvio Basics is a portable HDD range for anyone who wants to compare capacity and connections first.

  • Toshiba lists USB 3.2 Gen 1, USB-powered operation and models with capacities of up to 4 TB.
  • The series reviewed is formatted as NTFS for Windows by default; it needs reformatting for the macOS versions specified. Check the exact model and make another copy before formatting.

Samsung

The 2 TB Portable SSD T7 model reviewed is worth comparing if you regularly transfer files and want a password feature you can set up.

  • For this T7, Samsung lists sequential read and write speeds of up to 1.050/1.000 MB/s, two included types of USB cable and password protection with AES 256-bit encryption.
  • These are manufacturer specifications for the T7 model mentioned, not results measured on the archive’s computers. Check the exact model and how its password is managed.

Seagate

Expansion Portable offers a portable HDD option for anyone looking for storage space.

  • The current Dutch product information lists USB-C and 2 and 4 TB models.
  • Seagate also lists older model numbers. Features shown on a current product page won’t necessarily apply to an older model, so check the model number.

Kingston

The XS1000 is a compact external SSD worth comparing if volunteers regularly take files with them.

  • Kingston lists 1 and 2 TB models, an included cable and adapter, and read speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s.
  • The stated speed is a manufacturer specification. Check separately whether the security set-up you need is available; don’t assume the drive is encrypted based on its model name.

Joybuy products

These portable external HDDs and SSDs are options to compare for storing and transferring copies of photo archives.

My Passport 4 TB portable hard drive

My Passport 4 TB, black

A portable 4 TB HDD worth comparing for a growing photo collection.

The product name mentions password protection and automatic backup software. Software is no substitute for separate backups that you test.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 2 TB USB-C in graphite black

WD Elements Portable 2 TB, USB-C, graphite black

A portable HDD worth comparing if you want to take a copy of your photos between workstations.

The product name lists 2 TB and USB-C; check that the connection is compatible with the computers in your archive.

View at Joybuy
Samsung Portable SSD T7 2 TB USB-C 3.2 Gen 2 in blue

Samsung Portable SSD T7 2 TB, blue

A portable SSD worth comparing if you regularly transfer photos between workstations.

The product name lists 2 TB and USB-C 3.2 Gen 2. Check the port and the capacity you need for the exact model.

View at Joybuy
Samsung MU-PE2T0R 2 TB external SSD, blue

Samsung MU-PE2T0R 2 TB, blue

A portable SSD worth comparing for an archive copy you might take with you.

The product name lists 2 TB and USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2; check that this connection works with the devices you use.

View at Joybuy
Toshiba Canvio Basics 4 TB external hard drive

Toshiba Canvio Basics 4 TB, black

A portable 4 TB HDD worth comparing for a growing photo collection.

The product information lists 2.5-inch, USB Type-A and Micro-USB B, and USB 2.0/3.2 Gen 1. Toshiba lists NTFS formatting for Windows and says the drive needs reformatting for the macOS versions specified. Make another copy before reformatting.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is one external drive enough to back up a community archive?

No. Don’t treat one external drive as your entire backup plan. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping at least three versions of important files: the original and two backups. You should also test that you can restore and open files. This is security advice, not a general legal requirement for every buyer.

What should you check if the archive uses both Windows and Mac computers?

Check the ports, included cable and file system for the exact drive. Toshiba says the Canvio Basics model reviewed uses NTFS for Windows by default and needs to be reformatted for the macOS versions specified. Keep existing files somewhere else before formatting the drive.

Can a community archive keep or publish recognisable family photos?

Buying a drive doesn’t give you permission to keep or publish photos. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, photos showing recognisable people are personal data. An organisation must assess an appropriate legal basis under the GDPR and put suitable security measures in place. The applicable legal basis and whether publication is permitted depend on how the archive operates in practice.

How do warranty and service affect your choice?

Check the terms for the exact model and seller before buying. Manufacturer support or data recovery is no substitute for your own backups, which you should test regularly. The National Cyber Security Centre specifically recommends checking that you can restore your files.