Joybuy Insights

Choosing coloured pencils: how to find the right set without wasting money

Coloured pencils may seem straightforward, but the differences between sets often lie in details you only notice once you start drawing. A cheap set may contain lots of colours, yet still be difficult to blend. A metal tin may look practical, but it says nothing about the quality of the core. And a product described as “ergonomic” is not automatically suitable for every hand.

With this buying guide, you can compare coloured pencils based on measurable features, such as the number of colours, core thickness, pencil shape and how you plan to use the set.

Common pitfalls when choosing coloured pencils

1. Looking only at the number of colours

A 48-colour pencil set may seem appealing, but more colours do not automatically mean a better drawing experience. For children or beginners, 12 to 24 colours are often easier to manage. If you create lots of shadows, skin tones or landscapes, you may benefit from 36 or 48 individual shades.

Don’t just consider the number of pencils. Also look at:

  • The balance of light, dark and mid-tone colours
  • The hardness of the core
  • Whether colours can be layered
  • Whether a sharpener, eraser or waterbrush is included

2. Confusing a “soft core” with durability

Coloured pencils with a soft core generally release colour easily and are useful for smooth areas of colour. However, a soft point wears down more quickly and may break under heavy pressure. Check whether the product description provides information about core thickness and core bonding.

For some products, the manufacturer may mention special SV bonding or a break-resistant core. This is a product specification from the brand, not a guarantee that the point will never break under any circumstances. Store pencils in a dry place and avoid dropping them or pressing too hard.

3. Ignoring the shape and packaging

A round wooden barrel can roll away while you are drawing. A hexagonal shape is usually more stable on a desk. A triangular shape can make the pencil easier to hold, particularly for young children or during longer drawing sessions. The choice is personal, so focus on whether the dimensions suit the user.

A set of coloured pencils in a metal tin protects the pencils during transport and makes storage simple. Cardboard packaging is often lighter and may be perfectly adequate for use at a dedicated drawing desk.

Important features to compare

Core hardness and core thickness

Hardness determines how the pencil responds to paper. A softer core releases colour more quickly and is suitable for colouring, layering and soft transitions. A harder core is useful for fine lines and details. Coloured pencils may use designations such as B, HB or a brand-specific classification. Only compare these designations within the context of the product, as the scale may feel different from one brand to another.

Core thickness is also relevant:

  • 2.5 to 3 mm: suitable for fine lines and detailed work
  • 3.8 to 4.2 mm: more colour laydown and suitable for larger areas
  • 5 mm: often designed to provide a soft, striking layer of colour

Watercolour pencils or ordinary coloured pencils?

You can use watercolour pencils dry, just like ordinary coloured pencils. With a wet brush or waterbrush, you can blend and spread the applied colour. Check that the product description explicitly states that the core is water-soluble. An ordinary coloured pencil core does not automatically become a watercolour pencil simply because the pencil has been coated with water-based lacquer.

For illustrations with visible lines, ordinary coloured pencils are often easier to use. For backgrounds, colour gradients and painterly effects, watercolour pencils are more versatile. Bear in mind that you will need suitable paper and a brush.

Ergonomics and use by children

For young users, thicker, triangular pencils may be more comfortable to hold. According to the product description, the STABILO Trio thick has a 4.2 mm core and a triangular shape. The Faber-Castell Jumbo Grip range also uses a thicker triangular shape and a Soft-Grip zone. Children above the stated minimum age should still be supervised because of the sharp point and small parts.

Recommended coloured pencils by user profile

Suitable for: Budget-conscious beginners
M&G Coloured Pencils, 48 Pack, Soft Core

M&G Coloured Pencils, 48 Pack, Soft Core

Why it suits this profile: The set offers 48 colours for schoolwork, simple illustrations and first drawing projects. The hexagonal wooden barrel is practical for use at a desk.

How this product avoids the pitfall

You are not limited to working with just a small selection of basic colours. The product description also mentions pre-sharpened, break-resistant cores; use normal pressure to help prevent the points from breaking.

Key benefit & highlights

48 individual colours, a hexagonal shape and a wooden barrel. According to the product information, the set is suitable for colouring, sketching and school use.

Suitable for: Buyers looking for premium quality
Faber-Castell Albrecht Dürer Watercolour Pencils Set, 36 pcs

Faber-Castell Albrecht Dürer Watercolour Pencils Set – 36 pcs

Why it suits this profile: This set combines dry drawing with water-soluble colour. That makes it suitable for adults, students and illustrators who want to explore different techniques.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The product description clearly states that the core is fully water-soluble, has a diameter of 3.8 mm and comes in a metal tin. This makes the features more specific than a general claim of quality.

Key benefit & highlights

36 watercolour pencils, a hexagonal shape, certified cedar wood according to the product information, and a metal tin. A waterbrush is not listed for this variant.

Suitable for: Specific uses & intensive users
Faber-Castell Black Edition Coloured Pencils Set, 36 pcs, in Metal Tin

Faber-Castell Black Edition Coloured Pencils Set – 36 pcs, Assorted in Metal Tin

Why it suits this profile: This set is aimed at people who colour regularly and use different types of paper. According to the product description, the pencils are suitable for light, coloured and black paper.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The triangular shape provides a secure grip, while the metal tin prevents loose pencils from rolling around in a bag. The stated SV bonding is designed to help limit core breakage.

Key benefit & highlights

36 colours, a 5 mm core, soft colour laydown according to the product description, and a metal tin. No eraser is included.

Looking for more options?

We have put together a complete, up-to-date list of products that fully meet these strict selection criteria and the applicable European safety regulations.

Care for a longer service life

The lifespan of coloured pencils depends greatly on how they are used. These habits can help prevent unnecessary wear:

  • Use a sharpener that matches the diameter of the pencil core.
  • Turn the pencil gently instead of pressing down hard.
  • Store coloured pencils in a dry place away from direct sunlight.
  • For watercolour pencils, use paper suitable for wet media.
  • Put pencils back in a box or case after use to prevent them from being dropped.

Frequently asked questions about coloured pencils

Which coloured pencils are suitable for children?

For children, it is generally best to choose a thicker, triangular shape with a sturdy core. Also check the recommended minimum age and use a suitable sharpener. The STABILO Trio thick and Faber-Castell Jumbo Grip are examples of models aimed at children’s hands according to their product descriptions.

What is the difference between coloured pencils and watercolour pencils?

Ordinary coloured pencils are designed for dry use. Watercolour pencils contain a water-soluble core, allowing you to blend the colours with a wet brush. Always check the product specifications; not every pencil that creates soft lines is water-soluble.

How many coloured pencils do you need to get started?

For simple drawings, 12 to 24 colours are enough. A set of 36 or 48 colours offers more possibilities for mixing, shading and creating gradual transitions. Start with a smaller set if you are not yet sure which drawing technique you use most.