Joybuy Insights

Choosing the Right Colored Pencils: A No-Nonsense Buyer's Guide

Whether you're filling in an adult coloring book, keeping your kids creatively occupied, or creating serious art, the right colored pencils make all the difference. However, the market is flooded with sets that over-promise and under-deliver. Many people buy a large, impressive-looking colored pencil set only to find that the leads constantly break or the colors are dull. Let's look at the most common pitfalls and what you should really pay attention to.

Pitfall 1: The "professional" deception. Many sets are labeled "professional," but the quality of the pigments and core is often subpar. This leads to frustration when colors don't blend well or the artwork fades after a few months due to a lack of lightfastness.

Pitfall 2: The "more is better" trap. A set with 120 colors for a low price seems like a great deal. However, this often means the quality per pencil is low. The colors are weak, the core is brittle, and you end up using only a fraction of the pencils. A smaller set with high-quality pigments is usually far more versatile.

Pitfall 3: The wrong match for your paper. Not every pencil works well on every type of paper. For example, standard pencils can be disappointing on dark or colored paper. Without knowing this, you might think the pencils are poor quality when they're simply not suited for your specific project.

What to Look for When Buying

To avoid wasting your money, here are a few objective specifications you can check before purchasing a set of colored pencils for adults or children.

1. Core Quality and Bonding

The core of the pencil determines the color laydown and break-resistance. Pay attention to the following:

  • Composition: Pencils are typically either wax-based or oil-based. Oil-based pencils, often found in professional colored pencil sets, are harder, hold a sharper point, and are great for detailed work. Wax-based pencils are softer and blend more easily, but can leave a waxy buildup.
  • Bonding: A weak core breaks easily, which is a major source of frustration, especially with colored pencils for kids. Brands like Faber-Castell use a special bonding process (often referred to as SV bonding) where the lead is glued to the wood along its entire length. This makes the pencils significantly more break-resistant.

2. Pencil Type for Your Purpose

Not all colored pencils are the same. The three main types are:

  • Standard colored pencils: These are the classic wax- or oil-based pencils, suitable for drawing and coloring.
  • Watercolor pencils: These pencils contain a water-soluble binder. You can draw with them dry like a normal pencil, or use water and a brush to blend the colors and create a watercolor effect.
  • Pastel pencils: These are essentially pastel sticks in pencil form. They are ideal for detailed pastel work without getting messy fingers and provide a soft, powdery finish.

3. Pigmentation and Lightfastness

Good pigmentation means the pencil delivers a rich, vibrant color without you having to press hard. Lightfastness indicates how well the colors resist fading when exposed to light. For artwork you want to preserve or display, high lightfastness is crucial. Some manufacturers, like Faber-Castell, indicate this with a star rating system on the pencil itself.

Recommended Options for Different Users

Below are some popular choices matched with specific user profiles, based on their product features.

MATCH FOR: The Young Creative
Faber-Castell Grip 2001 Colored Pencils Set - 24pcs, Assorted Colors

Faber-Castell Grip 2001 Colored Pencils Set - 24pcs

Why it's a great match: This set is designed with children in mind. The ergonomic triangular shape and patented Soft-Grip zone ensure the pencils fit comfortably in small hands and don't slip.

How it avoids the pitfall

The special SV bonding prevents the pencil lead from constantly breaking, a common frustration with cheaper kids' sets.

Key benefit & advantages

The pigments are water-soluble, allowing kids to create fun watercolor effects. Plus, they are washable from most fabrics.

MATCH FOR: The Detail-Oriented Hobbyist
Faber-Castell Black Edition Colored Pencils Set - 36pcs, Assorted in Metal Tin

Faber-Castell Black Edition Colored Pencils Set - 36pcs in Tin

Why it's a great match: The Faber-Castell Black Edition is popular among hobbyists. The super-soft lead provides an incredibly smooth and gentle color laydown with bright colors, which is ideal for filling in coloring books or creating original drawings.

How it avoids the pitfall

These pencils are specially designed to perform exceptionally well on dark and colored paper, avoiding the pitfall of dull colors on non-white surfaces.

Key benefit & advantages

The pencils are made from black wood and come in a stylish tin, giving them a premium feel. The triangular shape ensures comfort during long drawing sessions.

MATCH FOR: The Ambitious Artist
Faber-Castell Albrecht Dürer Watercolour Pencils Set - 36 pcs, Assorted Colors

Faber-Castell Albrecht Dürer Watercolour Pencils Set - 36pcs

Why it's a great match: These are true artist-grade watercolor pencils. They offer high pigmentation, are fully water-soluble for professional watercolor effects, and have excellent lightfastness.

How it avoids the pitfall

This set delivers on its "professional" promise with verifiable features, such as the lightfastness rating (star system) indicated on each pencil, unlike sets with vague marketing claims.

Key benefit & advantages

The 3.8 mm thick, break-resistant core and high-quality pigments allow for limitless blending possibilities, both wet and dry.

Looking for more options?

We've compiled a complete, up-to-date list of products that fully meet these strict selection criteria and UK regulations.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between wax-based and oil-based pencils?

Wax-based pencils are generally softer, which makes them great for blending colors. They are also often more affordable. Oil-based pencils have a harder core, so they wear down more slowly and maintain a sharper point. This makes them ideal for detailed work. They are typically more durable and less prone to waxy buildup on the paper.

How do I prevent my colored pencil lead from breaking all the time?

This is a common problem with lower-quality pencils. Opt for pencils with strong core bonding, like the SV bonding found in Faber-Castell colored pencils. Also, use a sharp, good-quality sharpener. A dull sharpener puts too much pressure on the wood and the core, leading to breakage. Sharpen with a gentle, rotating motion rather than with force.

Can I also use watercolor pencils 'dry'?

Absolutely. Watercolor pencils function as normal, high-quality colored pencils when used dry. The ability to add water is an extra feature. You can create a drawing, leave some parts dry, and work on other areas with a wet brush to create watercolor effects. This makes them a very versatile choice for both beginners and advanced artists.