For short scrapbook captions, a single-function colour laser printer is often all you need. Before buying, check that the exact paper size, type and weight are suitable for your chosen model and feed path. Choose a multifunction printer only if you also want to scan or copy. The Dutch Consumers’ Association describes laser printers as suitable for sharp text, while inkjet printers are a separate consideration for photos on glossy paper.
Who is this choice relevant to?
Teachers who cut out and stick on captions
If you want to print short text with colour accents on scrapbook paper, compare the size, weight and feed method in advance. Canon Netherlands specifies these details for each paper type and feed path on the i-SENSYS LBP646Cdw.
Teachers with a shared classroom printer
Check that the printer connects to the school’s devices and find out how print jobs containing pupils’ data are protected. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says schools must be able to demonstrate that they have technical and organisational measures in place to protect pupils’ data.
Those managing the printing budget
Remember to factor in replacement colour toner and any other consumables, as well as the printer itself. The Dutch Consumers’ Association includes cost per print in its printer tests; Lexmark says actual toner yield depends on usage.
What should you look for when buying?
First, compare your scrapbook paper with the printer, then check connectivity and running costs. Next, decide whether you need scanning or copying as well as printing.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this more important for? |
| Legible text on scrapbook paper |
Compare the size, paper type and weight in g/m² with the model specifications and the chosen feed path. Canon Netherlands lists 60–163 g/m² in the cassette for the LBP646Cdw and a maximum of 200 g/m² for coated paper; the manual feed is for one sheet. |
I want short captions to be easy to read on the paper I’ll actually be using. Paper compatibility and legibility are a priority for around 28% of consumers in this context. |
| Cost of repeat printing |
Compare replacement cartridges, the supplied toner and any separate consumables based on your expected print volume. Lexmark warns that actual cartridge yield can vary; Brother lists a drum and belt unit as well as toner for the HL-L3240CDW. |
If I print colour accents regularly, I want to know in advance which parts will need replacing later. Running costs are the top priority for around 22% of consumers in this context. |
| Shared use and pupils’ data |
Check connections to classroom devices and, if personal data is involved, discuss the school’s arrangements for access to print jobs and printouts. Canon lists Secure Print for the LBP646Cdw; the Dutch Data Protection Authority outlines schools’ responsibility to take appropriate measures. |
I want to share the printer with colleagues without leaving personal captions accessible to others. Shared and secure printing is a priority for around 22% of consumers in this context. |
| Space in a small classroom |
Measure the space available and leave room to open trays and load paper. Lexmark gives the CS331dw’s dimensions as 243.7 × 411.2 × 394.1 mm, in height × width × depth order. |
I want to position the printer so it remains easy to use without blocking the workspace. Available space is the top priority for around 17% of consumers in this context. |
| Scanning and copying |
Decide whether you also want to digitise or copy physical teaching materials. Canon describes the MF664Cdw as a 3-in-1 colour laser printer and gives its dimensions as approximately 425 × 461 × 397 mm with the trays retracted. |
If I want to handle drawings or documents as well as captions, having one device for everything could be useful. Extra scanning and copying functions are the main priority for around 11% of consumers in this context. |
Things to watch out for when buying
-
Assuming every heavy scrapbook sheet is suitable
The permitted paper weight can depend on the paper type and feed path. A limit for coated paper does not automatically apply to every type of card.
Check the size, paper type and weight of the specific sheet against the specifications for the exact printer model.
If the paper won’t feed through the printer, the scrapbook sheets you’ve bought may not be usable for this purpose.
-
Comparing only the purchase price
For repeat printing, you’ll also need to factor in replacement toner and any other consumables. The stated page yield won’t tell you exactly how many captions you can print.
Compare cartridges and consumables for the model and variant you’re considering, and base your calculations on how much you expect to print.
-
Assuming a colour LED printer is a colour laser printer
Brother describes the HL-L3240CDW as a colour LED printer, while the Canon LBP646Cdw is described as a colour laser printer.
Check the stated print technology if laser is a firm requirement. Compare LED models only if you’re also open to that technology.
-
Assuming a shared printer is automatically suitable for personal captions
If captions contain pupils’ data, the school must take steps to protect it. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says schools must be able to demonstrate that they have appropriate technical and organisational measures in place.
Before using the printer, discuss how the school will manage access to print jobs and the collection of printouts.
Relevant brands to consider
HP
The Color LaserJet Pro 3202dw is a single-function colour laser printer for those who want to print wirelessly and from a mobile device.
- HP specifies a maximum speed of 25 pages per minute for both black and colour printing.
- HP says its dynamic security feature may block toner cartridges without an HP chip or circuitry, either now or after an update. Check this when choosing replacement toner.
Canon
The i-SENSYS LBP646Cdw is designed for printing only; the MF664Cdw also offers scanning and copying.
- Canon specifies paper sizes and weights, Secure Print and network connections for the LBP646Cdw.
- The multifunction MF664Cdw takes up more space. Compare its dimensions with the space available and decide whether you need the extra features.
Lexmark
The CS331dw is a colour laser printer without a scanning function, with Wi-Fi and Ethernet according to Lexmark Netherlands.
- Lexmark lists its dimensions and integrated double-sided printing.
- Lexmark’s recommended monthly volume of 600–2500 pages is manufacturer information, not a minimum requirement for every classroom.
Brother
The HL-L3240CDW is a colour LED printer and could be a useful comparison if you’re also considering LED technology.
- Brother lists double-sided printing, Wi-Fi and Ethernet.
- Brother lists separate toner, drum and belt components. This model uses LED technology, not colour laser printing.
Joybuy products
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Can I feed scrapbook card directly into the printer?
Not based on the word ‘card’ alone. Check the specific sheet against the paper sizes, types and weights supported by your chosen model, as well as the feed path. Canon Netherlands lists 60–163 g/m² in the cassette for the LBP646Cdw and a maximum of 200 g/m² for coated paper; that doesn’t mean every type of scrapbook card is suitable.
Do I need a scanner if I only want to print captions?
No. Scanning and copying are separate functions. A printer that only prints is suitable for captions supplied digitally; a multifunction model is worth considering if you also want to scan or copy physical materials.
How do I compare running costs?
Factor in replacement cartridges and any other consumables, as well as the number of prints you expect to make. A stated toner yield doesn’t guarantee how many captions you’ll actually be able to print; Lexmark says yield varies.
What should I consider if captions contain pupils’ data?
Make sure shared printing follows the school’s data protection measures. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says schools must be able to demonstrate that they have technical and organisational measures in place to protect pupils’ data; having a printer feature does not, in itself, prove that this responsibility has been met.