Who is this buying guide for?

Maker of sturdy card inserts

You want to print individual inserts on a specific sheet, which may be heavier than standard paper. Check the paper sizes and weights supported by the exact model, as well as the approved feed path.

Home worker with regular print runs

You print card inserts as well as everyday documents, and want to weigh toner use and any separate consumables against your own print volume. Consumentenbond includes cartridge costs and print yield when comparing laser printers.

Maker of image-heavy inserts

You use large areas of colour or photo-style images. Consumentenbond recommends assessing photo prints separately; if necessary, compare an inkjet printer too, using the paper you intend to print on.

What should you look for when printing card inserts?

Colour laser or colour LED printer without a scanner

Choose this if: you mainly print text and colour accents, and don't need scanning or copying.

Consider: check the paper feed and the cost of toner and any separate consumables. The printer technology alone doesn't prove that your card paper is suitable.

Multifunction colour laser printer

Choose this if: you regularly scan or copy documents as well as printing card inserts.

Consider: extra features tell you nothing about paper suitability; check the exact model and feed path.

Inkjet printer as an alternative

Choose this if: large images or a specific paper finish are important to you, and you want to compare this printing technology too.

Consider: assess the print result on your intended paper; a test print can help you check the margins and image.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who should consider this?
Paper suitability Check the size, weight, paper type and feed path supported by the exact model. Also check whether automatic double-sided printing is permitted for that paper. If you want to print individual inserts on a specific sheet that may be heavier than standard paper, paper suitability comes first. Around 36% of consumers rank it as their top buying priority.
Toner and maintenance costs Compare the correct black and colour toners, any starter cartridges and separate consumables based on your expected use. If you regularly print card inserts as well as everyday documents, you'll want to factor in ongoing running costs. Around 29% of consumers put these costs at the top of their list.
Colour on your inserts Decide whether you'll mainly print text and simple illustrations or large areas of imagery. If possible, assess a test print on your chosen paper; if you're printing photos, compare inkjet printers too. If you use image-heavy designs, you'll want to assess the result on your intended paper before choosing a printer type. Around 21% of consumers give colour the highest priority.
Extra office features Check whether you need a scanner, copying function, Wi-Fi or a network connection. If you want to scan or copy documents as well as print card inserts, these features may influence your choice. Around 14% of consumers put extra office features first.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming ‘double-sided’ means the printer is suitable for sturdy card

    A duplex function doesn't tell you which paper types are supported on that feed path. Paper that isn't supported by the approved feed may be unusable or require extra manual work.

    Check the manual for the exact model to see which paper sizes, weights and types are allowed for each feed path, as well as any separate conditions for automatic double-sided printing.

  • Comparing only the purchase price

    The printer price doesn't tell you how much regular colour printing will cost. Consumentenbond includes cartridge costs and print yield in its comparisons.

    Compare toner yields and costs based on the number and type of prints you expect to make. Brother also lists separate drum and belt products for the HL-L3240CDW.

    Depending on the model, replacement toner and separate consumables may be part of ongoing maintenance.

  • Choosing an image-heavy card insert based only on speed or resolution

    Print quality can vary between colour laser printers, and photo prints need to be assessed separately. Speed or a single specification won't tell you how your design will look on your chosen paper.

    Assess the type of image you actually use on your intended paper, and compare an inkjet printer if necessary.

    Test prints may require extra paper and time.

  • Assuming every cheaper toner will work in the HP 3202dw

    HP states that dynamic security may prevent cartridges without an HP chip or circuitry from working, either now or in the future.

    Bear this HP restriction in mind when comparing your options and the cost of replacement cartridges.

    This restriction may limit your choice of replacement cartridges.

Brands to compare

Brother

The HL-L3240CDW is a colour LED printer without a built-in scanner.

  • Brother lists automatic double-sided printing, Wi-Fi, Ethernet and included toner.
  • Brother lists separate drum and belt products. Check separately whether your card paper is suitable for the feed path you choose.

HP

The Color LaserJet Pro 3202dw is a colour printer with wireless and double-sided printing.

  • The product information describes wireless and double-sided printing.
  • HP states that dynamic security may prevent cartridges without an HP chip or circuitry from working, either now or in the future. Check this if you're considering alternative toner; the printer listing doesn't confirm that your card paper is suitable.

Canon

The i-SENSYS MF750 II series consists of multifunction colour printers for those who want to scan or copy as well as print.

  • Canon lists scanning functions across the series.
  • Canon says the MF752Cdw II and MF754Cdw II differ in their fax function. Check the full model name and the paper specifications for the version you're considering.

Lexmark

Lexmark describes the CS431dw as a colour laser printer for small workgroups.

  • Lexmark lists Wi-Fi, Ethernet and built-in double-sided printing.
  • Lexmark gives a recommended monthly volume of 750–5000 pages. This stated range doesn't automatically make the model suitable for occasional card inserts; check the paper specifications too.

Printer options at Joybuy

These models are inkjet alternatives to compare if you want scanning and copying functions as well as card inserts; check the paper sizes and weights supported by your printer, and the approved feed path.

HP Smart Tank 7305 Wireless All-in-One colour printer

HP Smart Tank 7305 Wireless All-in-One colour printer

An inkjet alternative to compare if you want to print card inserts as well as scan and copy; check that your paper is suitable for the exact model.

The product name lists colour printing, automatic double-sided printing, a copier and a scanner.

View at Joybuy
HP Smart Tank 7005 Wireless All-in-One colour printer

HP Smart Tank 7005 Wireless All-in-One colour printer

An inkjet alternative to compare if you want to print card inserts as well as scan and copy; check that your paper is suitable for the exact model.

The product name lists colour printing, automatic double-sided printing, a copier and a scanner.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I print double-sided on any sturdy sheet of card?

No. Don't assume you can just because the printer has a duplex function. For the exact model, check the permitted paper weight, size and type for each feed path, along with any separate restrictions on automatic double-sided printing.

How do I prepare for my first print on a card insert?

Set the actual paper size and type in the printer software, use the feed path specified for that paper in the manual, and print a test copy first to check the positioning and margins.

What costs should I consider besides the printer price?

Compare the correct replacement black and colour toners, any included starter cartridges and separate maintenance parts. A stated toner yield isn't a guaranteed yield for image-heavy card inserts, as your own designs may produce different results.

What guarantee do I have when buying as a consumer in the Netherlands?

According to the Dutch government, you're entitled to a product that works as it should, and the seller must provide a solution if there's a fault. The Netherlands doesn't have a fixed statutory two-year guarantee period; what you can expect depends, among other things, on the product, its price and the information provided at the time of sale. This applies to consumer purchases and not necessarily to business orders.

Can I return a printer bought online and hand in my old printer?

For a qualifying distance purchase, the Dutch government generally states a 14-day cooling-off period; check the terms and exceptions that apply to your purchase. As a private individual, when buying a similar new appliance, you can hand in your old appliance free of charge under the old-for-new scheme, including when buying online. According to the Dutch government, this scheme doesn't apply to equipment owned by businesses.