First, choose a controller that works with your console or PC and with the co-op controls in the specific puzzle game. In compatible Switch games, a pair of Joy-Con controllers can serve two players, but Nintendo stresses that this varies from game to game. Playing during the day does not, in itself, call for a special type of controller.
Who is this choice relevant to?
Switch players sharing one screen
If you want to play with two players on one screen, you may be able to share an existing Joy-Con. Whether this works depends on the game and Switch model; Nintendo outlines different controller layouts for different games.
PC or console players with a second player
An extra controller needs to be supported by both the system and the game's co-op mode. Xbox and PlayStation outline connection options for different devices, but feature support can vary by game and connection type.
Occasional players
If you only play now and then, you may want a controller that connects quickly and doesn't come with unexpected power requirements. So check how it connects and what is included with the version you're considering.
What should you look for when buying?
Start with the system and the game's controller layout, then check whether your existing controllers will do the job. Only then choose between wired and wireless, and check what power supply or accessories you'll need.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| System and game compatibility |
Check the exact device, the game's support and the intended USB or wireless connection. |
If I want to check first that the controller works with both my system and my puzzle game, compatibility comes first. Around 34% of consumers give this check top priority. |
| Controls for two players |
Check whether local co-op supports two separate controllers and which layout the game requires. |
I want both players to have separate controls, not just two controllers connected. Around 33% of consumers prioritise controls for two players. |
| Convenience for occasional play |
Decide whether a cable will be practical and whether you'll need to pair the controller with a different device each time. |
If I only play now and then, I want to get started without unnecessary steps and use the controller comfortably near the screen. Around 13% of consumers prioritise this convenience. |
| Power and extra essentials |
Check whether the controller needs batteries, a compatible rechargeable battery or a cable, and what is included. |
I want to know in advance whether I'll need batteries or a charging solution. Around 20% of consumers put power and additional essentials at the top of their list. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Assuming Joy-Con 2 work with the original Switch
Nintendo says that Joy-Con 2 cannot be used with the original Switch. Original Joy-Con can be used wirelessly with Switch 2, but cannot be attached to the system.
Before buying, check which generation of Switch you have and how you charge your existing controllers.
-
Assuming every puzzle game supports a shared pair of Joy-Con
The game determines whether Joy-Con can be used separately and which play style or buttons are needed. So a pair won't automatically work with every local co-op mode.
Check the player and controller requirements for the specific game before buying an extra set.
-
Choosing a wired Switch controller without checking your set-up
The PowerA Enhanced Wired version described is designed for use with the Switch in its dock. According to PowerA, this version does not have HD rumble, motion controls, IR or NFC, and is not intended for games that only support Joy-Con.
Compare the game's control requirements with the exact controller version, and consider whether playing with a cable suits your set-up.
-
Assuming a wireless Xbox controller always includes batteries or a rechargeable battery
Microsoft lists AA batteries and a compatible separate rechargeable solution as power options. What comes in the box can vary by version.
Check what's included with the product you're considering and decide in advance how you'll power the controller.
Brands to consider
Nintendo
Joy-Con and Joy-Con 2 are worth considering for Switch games that support separate controller use.
- Nintendo says that a Joy-Con can be used as a separate controller in compatible games.
- Joy-Con 2 do not work with the original Switch. Original Joy-Con work with Switch 2 wirelessly only and cannot be attached to it.
Xbox
The wireless Xbox controller is an option for supported Xbox systems, Windows PCs and the mobile systems listed by Xbox.
- Microsoft lists Bluetooth and a hybrid D-pad.
- Check whether your version uses AA batteries or a compatible separate rechargeable solution, and what comes in the box.
PlayStation
DualSense is designed for PS5 and can also be used with supported PC, Mac and mobile applications.
- PlayStation lists USB and Bluetooth connections.
- On PC, PlayStation says haptic feedback requires support from the game and a USB connection; don't expect the same features on every platform.
8BitDo
The Ultimate 2C Wireless and Ultimate 2C Bluetooth are different versions, designed for different platforms.
- According to 8BitDo, the Wireless version supports 2.4 GHz or USB for Windows, and Bluetooth for Android.
- The Bluetooth version is designed for Switch; check the stated system and firmware version for Switch 2.
PowerA
The Enhanced Wired Controller described is a wired option for using the Switch in its dock.
- PowerA says this version includes a cable and does not require batteries.
- This version does not have HD rumble, motion controls, IR or NFC, and is not suitable for games that only support Joy-Con.
Controllers at Joybuy
This selection includes controllers for different Switch models, PS4 and PC, and PS5. For each controller and game, check that the stated connection and controls suit your set-up.
No image available
Turtle Beach Afterglow Wave Wireless Controller (Bluetooth) RGB
A good fit if you're looking for a wireless controller for one of the Switch models listed; also check that the game supports the controls you need.
The product information lists Bluetooth, two programmable buttons and up to 40 hours of battery life.
The title lists Switch 2, Switch, Switch Lite and Switch OLED.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Hori Wired Controller Horipad Turbo, Pokémon Eevee Cottage Core Edition
A wired option if you're looking for a controller for Switch or Switch 2 and are happy to play with a cable.
The product information lists a USB connection, programmable rear buttons and a turbo function.
The cable is not included, according to the product information. The description does not mention HD Rumble, NFC or motion controls; check whether your game needs these features.
View at Joybuy
No image available
KONIX JoyPad Controller Pair, blue and red
A set for anyone looking for two controllers for a supported Switch game; check that the local co-op controls you want work with each title.
The product information lists Bluetooth, USB charging and up to 8 hours of battery life.
The product title lists Switch and Switch OLED, and compatibility with Switch 2.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Black wireless Dualshock game controller for PS4 and PC
A wireless controller if you're looking for a version that, according to the product information, works with PS4 and PC; check that your chosen game supports it.
The description lists a touchpad, a 6-axis gyroscope, dual vibration and a USB cable for initial pairing.
View at Joybuy
No image available
PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller, Grand Theft Auto VI White Limited Edition
A good fit if you're looking for a DualSense for PS5 or a supported PC game; for PC, also check the connection and features required by the title.
The product information lists USB-C and Bluetooth, a built-in rechargeable battery, and use with PS5, PC, Mac and mobile devices.
On PC, haptic feedback and adaptive triggers may require a USB connection and support from the game.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Do two players always need two extra controllers?
No, not in every Switch game. In games that support it, each Joy-Con or Joy-Con 2 held horizontally can be used as a separate controller. Check the game mode and what came with your console before buying anything else.
How do you set up two original Joy-Con for a compatible Switch game?
Nintendo describes the option Controllers > Change Grip/Order; hold each Joy-Con horizontally and press SL and SR. The available layout depends on the game.
Can you use original Joy-Con with Switch 2 and charge them there?
Yes. Nintendo says original Joy-Con can be used wirelessly with Switch 2, but cannot be attached to the system. To charge them, you'll need an original Switch or a compatible charging accessory.
Do all DualSense features work wirelessly in a PC game?
No. A Bluetooth connection doesn't mean every feature will be available. According to PlayStation, haptic feedback on PC requires both support from the game and a USB connection. Also check the connection and controller requirements for the specific title.
What should you look for in a wireless controller sold in the Netherlands?
The Dutch Authority for Digital Infrastructure outlines the European requirements for radio equipment and the associated CE marking. Check the controller's marking and product information; a product listing alone does not prove that an individual item meets every requirement.