Who is this relevant to?

Housemates with a Switch

First, check whether the Joy-Cons you already have provide enough individual controls. Whether a Joy-Con can be used as a standalone controller depends on the game and the play style it supports. Nintendo describes this option for supported software.

Housemates with a gaming PC

You play locally on one PC, so you can decide whether two players would like to share a keyboard or use a gamepad each. Team17 says that two players can share a keyboard when playing Overcooked! 2 locally.

Players around one screen

You already have a suitable platform and mainly need to choose between a cable that reaches your seat and a wireless controller. Check that the connection and exact model are compatible with your console or PC.

What should you consider when choosing?

First check your platform, then count the controls you already have. Finally, choose a controller that suits the game and the distance from your screen.

What to consider What to look for Who is this important for?
Platform compatibility Check the full model name, console model, connection mode and whether the game supports it. If you’re playing on an existing PC or console, you’ll want to avoid buying a controller that won’t connect or work with the game. Around 33% of consumers say platform compatibility is their top priority.
Controls for every player Count the controllers you already have and check whether the game supports a shared keyboard or individual Joy-Cons. If everyone in your household wants to play, you’ll want enough usable controls without immediately buying an extra gamepad for everyone. Around 27% of consumers say having enough controls for every player is their top priority.
Cables and seating distance Measure the distance to your PC or dock, and check the cable length and whether the controller can only be used with the console docked. If players are sitting in different places, you’ll want the cable to work with your setup, or you may prefer a wireless controller. Around 20% of consumers say having a practical connection from their seat is their top priority.
Grip and ease of use Compare a standalone Joy-Con with a full-size gamepad, and check how the model you choose is powered. If you want to play for a long time or avoid unnecessary usage and warranty costs, consider the grip and the terms for the exact model. Around 20% of consumers say comfort and avoiding unnecessary costs are their top priorities.

Pitfalls to avoid

  • Assuming Switch and Switch 2 controllers are interchangeable

    Compatibility varies by model. Nintendo says that Joy-Con 2 and the Switch 2 Pro Controller don’t work with the original Switch; the Switch 2 Pro Controller is only compatible with Switch 2.

    Before buying, compare the full controller name with your exact console model.

  • Buying a full-size gamepad for every housemate straight away

    In Overcooked! 2, two players can share a keyboard for local play on PC. On Switch, a Joy-Con can work as a standalone controller if the game supports that play style.

    Try the controls you already have first, then work out what else you need.

  • Choosing a wired Switch controller without checking the dock requirement

    PowerA says its Wired Controller can only be used when the Switch is docked, even though the model has a 3 m cable.

    Check whether you play with the Switch docked and whether the cable route works with your room layout.

Brands to compare

Nintendo

Nintendo offers Joy-Con controllers and Pro Controllers for a range of Switch setups.

  • Nintendo says that original Joy-Cons can be used wirelessly with Switch 2, but can’t be attached to it.
  • According to Nintendo, the Switch 2 Pro Controller only works with Switch 2. So check the exact model and console.

Microsoft Xbox

The Xbox Wireless Controller is an option for housemates playing on a compatible Xbox or Windows PC.

  • Microsoft lists Xbox Wireless and Bluetooth for compatible devices.
  • Those connections don’t automatically mean the controller will work with Switch or PlayStation games. Check that your device and game support it.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C Wired and Ultimate 2 Bluetooth are different versions, with different platform support.

  • 8BitDo lists Windows and Android support for the Ultimate 2C Wired, and Switch and Windows support for the Ultimate 2 Bluetooth.
  • The manufacturer says that the Ultimate 2 Bluetooth needs a firmware update before it can be used with Switch 2. Don’t assume every version has the same support.

PowerA

PowerA offers wired controllers, including options for playing near a dock.

  • For the Wired Controller mentioned here, PowerA lists a 3 m cable and use with a docked Switch.
  • According to PowerA, this model doesn’t have HD Rumble, motion controls, IR or amiibo NFC. These features relate to the controller mentioned here and don’t necessarily apply to every model from the brand.

Sony PlayStation

The DualSense is designed for a PS5 setup and can also be used with supported games and devices.

  • Sony describes use with compatible games on supported PCs and other devices via USB or Bluetooth.
  • A connection alone doesn’t guarantee that every game or DualSense feature will work on another device. Check the game and device separately.

Joybuy products

This selection includes Joy-Con for Switch, wireless controllers for PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series/PC, and wired HORI controllers for Switch models. Check that each exact controller model suits your platform and preferred setup.

Nintendo Switch Joy-Con pair, Neon Blue/Neon Yellow

Nintendo Switch Joy-Con pair - Neon Blue/Neon Yellow

Suitable for Switch players who want two separate controls from one set, provided the game supports playing with individual Joy-Cons.

View at Joybuy
PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller - Marvel’s Wolverine Battle Yellow Limited Edition

PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller - Marvel's Wolverine Battle Yellow Limited Edition

An option for a player who needs their own DualSense controller for a PS5 setup. Check game support if you want to use it with another device.

View at Joybuy
Xbox Wireless Controller - Ice Breaker Special Edition, Xbox Series/PC

Xbox Wireless Controller - Ice Breaker Special Edition, Xbox Series/PC

Suitable for a player who needs their own Xbox controller for Xbox Series or PC. Before using it with a PC, check that the connection and game are supported.

View at Joybuy
HORI Wired Controller Horipad Turbo for Switch and Switch 2 - Pokémon Eevee Cottage Core Edition

HORI Wired Controller Horipad Turbo for Switch and Switch 2 - Pokémon Eevee Cottage Core Edition

A wired option for a player who needs their own controller for Switch or Switch 2 and is happy to use a cable connection.

The product information says the USB cable isn’t included, so bear that in mind when planning your setup.

View at Joybuy
HORI Wired Controller Horipad Turbo for Switch 2 - Black

HORI Wired Controller Horipad Turbo for Switch 2 - Black

Suitable for a Switch 2 player who needs their own wired controller and can use a cable connection from their seat.

According to the product information, this model has a built-in USB cable.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does everyone need to buy a new controller for Overcooked! 2?

No, not always. Team17 says that two players can share a keyboard for local play on PC, Mac and Linux. First count the controls you can already use, then check what the game supports on your platform.

Can you use a Joy-Con as a standalone controller?

Yes, if the game supports that play style. Nintendo says you can hold a Joy-Con horizontally to use it as a standalone controller. Check which play styles the game supports, then sync the controller through the system menu.

Does a Switch 2 Pro Controller work with the original Switch?

No. Nintendo says that the Switch 2 Pro Controller only works with Switch 2. According to Nintendo, the original Switch Pro Controller can be synced wirelessly with Switch 2.

Can I use a wired PowerA controller when the Switch isn’t docked?

Not with the PowerA Wired Controller mentioned here: PowerA says this model can only be used when the Switch is docked. Before buying, also check that the 3 m cable will work with your seating arrangement.

Does a DualSense controller work with every PC game?

Not necessarily. Sony describes using it with compatible games on supported PCs and other devices, so check separately whether your device and game support the controller.