Who is this buying guide for?

Club move coordinator

Wants to arrange a recoverable copy before packing and make sure the original and backup aren’t lost together. The NCSC recommends keeping multiple versions of important files.

Membership records administrator

If the records contain personal data, they need to ensure that access and security measures are appropriate to the risks. The Dutch Data Protection Authority stresses that organisations must protect personal data properly.

Volunteer responsible for the NAS

Wants a practical way to set up and check backups, and restore files after the move. The NCSC also recommends carrying out a recovery test.

What should you look for when buying?

NAS with a separate copy

Best suited to: clubs that want central network access after the move and will also keep a copy separate from the equipment being moved.

Trade-off: you’ll manage two backup destinations and need to check that files can be restored from the additional copy.

External drive as an additional copy

Best suited to: clubs where an administrator wants to keep a copy separately without managing a second NAS.

Trade-off: manual copying can fall behind. Keep the drive separate from the equipment and check that the files open.

Cloud as an additional destination

Best suited to: clubs that want to keep a copy away from both moving locations and can manage a cloud service.

Trade-off: check recovery options and ongoing costs. If a service provider processes personal data, you may need a data processing agreement.

Consideration What should you check? Who is this most relevant to?
Loss during the move Can the NAS back up to an external drive, a second location or the cloud? Where will the additional copy be kept while the equipment is being moved? If you want to avoid losing the original and backup together in a single incident, look for a copy stored separately. Around 36% of consumers make preventing loss during a move their top priority.
Access to personal data Do the records contain personal data, who needs access, and what access settings does the chosen model offer? If you manage membership records, you’ll want to limit access to people who need the files for their role. Around 29% of consumers put protecting personal data first.
Recovery and checks Can a volunteer check that a backup has completed and restore a test file? If you’re preparing to hand things over to another volunteer, you’ll want to know that they can restore and open files. Around 21% of consumers make practical recovery their top priority.
Overall set-up and management Are compatible drives included, and what additional destination or service is needed for a separate copy? If you want to understand the full backup set-up, consider the enclosure, drives and additional destination together. Around 14% of consumers put total storage and management costs first.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming two mirrored drives count as two separate backups

    If both drives stay in the same NAS, they could be lost along with the device during the move.

    Keep a recoverable copy elsewhere, separate from the equipment being moved, and test it before you leave.

    A separate destination requires additional storage and management.

  • Comparing only the price of the NAS enclosure

    An enclosure may be sold without storage drives. Check whether drives are included and whether they’re compatible with the model.

    Compare the complete set-up, including your chosen additional backup destination. For example, UGREEN states that the NASync DXP2800 is supplied without storage drives.

    Compatible drives and a separate backup destination may require additional equipment or management.

  • Assuming a successful backup notification means you can restore your files

    A notification that a backup task has completed doesn’t, by itself, show whether the right files can be restored and used.

    Run a recovery test before the move and open a few important test files. The NCSC recommends testing your recovery process.

Brands to compare

Synology

The DS223j is an option for a small group that wants to store files centrally and back up PC folders. According to Synology, the DS225+ also has a built-in 2.5GbE port.

  • Synology lists PC folder backups and Btrfs features from DSM 7.2 onwards for the DS223j.
  • The published throughput figures for the DS225+ are based on Synology’s internal tests and aren’t a guarantee of performance for a club. Check drive compatibility for your chosen model.

QNAP

The TS-233 is a two-bay NAS for central storage. QNAP’s documentation for HBS covers backups to destinations including external devices and cloud storage.

  • According to QNAP, HBS offers backup, recovery and synchronisation options for external destinations.
  • The TS-233 has one gigabit network port and 2 GB of non-expandable memory. Check that this model and the HBS set-up you need are right for your club.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 AS1102T has two drive bays and, according to ASUSTOR, supports backup options including USB and a second NAS.

  • ASUSTOR lists a 2.5GbE connection and backup options for this model.
  • The manufacturer lists 1 GB of memory. The published speed figures are based on its own laboratory tests and don’t guarantee the speed you’ll get during a move.

UGREEN

The NASync DXP2800 is a two-bay, 2.5GbE alternative for anyone considering other local applications too.

  • UGREEN lists two drive bays and a 2.5GbE connection for this model.
  • UGREEN states that drives are sold separately and refers customers to a compatibility list. Check which drives are suitable and review the complete set-up before buying.

Joybuy products

This selection includes NAS models for central storage and backups, as well as external drives that can be used to keep a separate copy.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

An option for managing central club files and backups using DSM features.

Hard drives aren’t included; check which compatible drives are suitable for your chosen set-up.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

An option for centrally storing club files and backups using DSM features.

Compatible hard drives must be installed and DSM and the storage pool configured before use.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ NAS without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+ NAS, without hard drives

An option for sharing files centrally and managing backups using DSM features.

Hard drives aren’t included; install compatible drives and configure the storage.

Joybuy
Toshiba Canvio Ready external hard drive, 1 TB

Toshiba Canvio Ready 1 TB

An external drive for an additional copy that can be stored separately from the NAS; it isn’t a NAS for central network storage.

1 TB, 2.5-inch, Micro-USB B, 3.2 Gen 1 (3.1 Gen 1).

Joybuy
Toshiba Canvio Ready external hard drive, 4 TB

Toshiba Canvio Ready 4 TB

An external drive for an additional copy that can be stored separately from the NAS; it isn’t a NAS for central network storage.

4 TB, 2.5-inch, Micro-USB B, 2.0/3.2 Gen 1 (3.1 Gen 1).

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is a NAS with two mirrored drives enough for a move?

No, not if both drives stay in the same NAS. Mirroring can help if one drive fails, but you’ll need a copy stored separately to protect against losing the entire NAS too. Before you leave, test that you can open files from that copy.

How can you check that a backup works before packing?

Check that the backup task has completed successfully, then carry out a recovery test too. Open a few important restored files afterwards; the NCSC recommends testing that you can recover your data.

Do you need to arrange drives and cloud storage separately?

That depends on the model and backup destination you choose. Some NAS enclosures are supplied without storage drives; UGREEN, for example, states this for the NASync DXP2800. Also check whether a cloud service requires a subscription and that you can recover files from it.

What should a club consider when backing up membership records to the cloud?

If the records contain personal data, the club must choose appropriate security measures based on the risks. If it uses a processor to handle that data, the Dutch Data Protection Authority says a written data processing agreement is required. A NAS or backup service won’t arrange this automatically.

Does the loss of a storage device containing membership data always have to be reported?

Not without assessing the specific incident and the risks it may pose. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, whether the supervisory authority must be notified depends on the risk to the people affected. Whether those people must be informed also depends on the risks posed by the data breach.