Who is this buying guide for?

Club backup administrator

You want to be able to restore minutes, financial documents and other club files after an error or outage. Set up a separate copy and test recovery, as recommended by the Digital Trust Center.

Committee with shared files

Several authorised volunteers need access, but not everyone needs to see every folder. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says that security measures should be appropriate to the risks involved in processing the data.

Volunteer with limited desk space

You’re looking for central storage, but need to check whether the enclosure will fit with its cables and room for ventilation. Dimensions vary by model; QNAP and ASUSTOR, for example, publish different measurements for the two-bay models mentioned here.

What should you look for when buying?

First decide how you want to recover files, then consider access management and available space, and finally compare the complete storage setup.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this most relevant to?
Recoverable backups Check scheduled backups, a destination outside the NAS and whether you can restore files. If I need to recover minutes or financial files after an outage, I want to be able to test a separate copy. Around 31% of consumers would make recoverability their top priority.
Volunteer access Check user accounts, folder permissions and the settings for administration and access. If volunteers have different responsibilities, I don’t want everyone to see the same folders. Around 25% of consumers would make restricted access their top priority.
Placement on a small desk Measure the space for the enclosure, connections and ventilation; compare the dimensions of the exact model. If my workspace is limited, I want to know whether the NAS will fit with its cables and enough room for airflow. Around 25% of consumers would make available desk space their top priority.
Complete storage setup Compare the enclosure, compatible drives, usable capacity and a separate destination for the recovery copy. If I want to avoid leaving out essential components when comparing options, I’ll include the drives and an extra copy too. Around 19% of consumers would make the overall setup their top priority.

Things to watch out for when buying

  • Mistaking two mirrored drives for two independent backups

    RAID can help if a drive fails, but it is not a separate copy stored outside the NAS.

    Decide where the extra copy will be stored and test that you can restore a club file.

    Allow for a separate storage destination and time to test recovery.

  • Comparing the enclosure alone

    A NAS supplied without drives is not necessarily a complete storage setup. Also check whether your chosen drives are compatible with the exact model.

    Check what the offer includes and confirm drive compatibility before comparing the complete setup.

    Your setup may also need internal drives and a separate backup destination.

  • Looking only at the width when space is limited

    Enclosure depths vary, and you’ll also need space for cables and ventilation.

    Measure the available space and compare it with the dimensions of the exact enclosure, allowing for connections and ventilation.

  • Giving everyone the same access to shared club folders

    If files contain personal data, security measures should be appropriate to the risks involved in processing it. A NAS also requires you to manage users and folder permissions.

    Set up accounts and folder permissions according to each person’s role, and check who can access sensitive folders.

Brands to compare

Synology

The DS223j is a two-bay model worth considering if shared files and scheduled backups of PC folders are important.

  • Synology lists backups of PC folders and backups from the NAS to another destination for the DS223j.
  • For the DS225+, check drive compatibility and the applicable DSM version. A 2.5GbE port alone does not prove that the entire network connection will be faster.

QNAP

The TS-233 is a two-bay model to compare if a shallow enclosure and network folders are important.

  • QNAP lists a depth of 157,6 mm and one gigabit network port for the TS-233.
  • The stated height excludes the feet. Also measure the space needed for cables and ventilation; according to QNAP, the 2 GB of memory cannot be expanded.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL is a two-bay alternative for sharing files with 3.5-inch SATA HDDs.

  • ASUSTOR lists Btrfs, folder sharing and dimensions of 165 × 102 × 218 mm for this model.
  • The listed compatible internal drives are 3.5-inch SATA HDDs. Snapshots on a single device are not a substitute for a separate copy.

UGREEN

The NASync DXP2800 and DH2300 are two-bay models to compare if you’re also assessing the software and the drives you’ll need.

  • UGREEN lists a 2.5GbE port and diskless supply for the DXP2800, and a 1GbE port for the DH2300.
  • This information comes from international product pages and does not confirm which version is included in a Dutch offer. Check the version and what the offer includes.

Joybuy product picks

This selection includes Synology models for central storage and portable external drives as an alternative when network sharing isn’t needed. An external drive does not offer the same central network access as a NAS; check that the space and setup required for each model suit your club.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

A model to consider if several volunteers need to share files centrally; check that the enclosure and ventilation space will fit where you plan to put it.

The stated dimensions are 29 × 26 × 24 cm. A NAS is not a separate backup: set up an extra copy too and test recovery.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

A model to consider for central file sharing if you want to choose the drives yourself; this version is offered without hard drives.

Check which drives are compatible, and include both the storage you need and a separate recovery copy in your setup.

View at Joybuy
SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

A portable SSD to consider if one administrator mainly needs to copy files from a single computer and shared network storage isn’t required.

The product name lists 1 TB. This is not central network storage; don’t keep all your copies in the same place.

View at Joybuy
Toshiba Canvio Ready external hard drive 4TB

Toshiba Canvio Ready external hard drive 4TB

An external drive to consider if an administrator wants to store files from a computer and central network access isn’t needed.

The product name lists 4 TB and a 2.5-inch drive with a Micro-USB B connection. This model does not provide central network storage; make sure you also have a separate recovery copy.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

A larger central storage setup to consider if you need to support multiple users and devices; measure in advance to make sure it will fit where you plan to put it.

The stated dimensions are 45 × 36 × 30 cm. Also allow for ventilation space and set up a separate backup that you can test.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID 1 enough to back up membership records?

No, RAID 1 does not replace a separate backup. Keep recovery copies elsewhere and test that you can restore the files you need; the National Cyber Security Centre warns that a NAS is not a substitute for a backup.

How can you check that the backup works after installation?

Check that the backup software reports a task as successful, carry out a restore and open the restored files. Include this check in the club’s management plan, as recommended by the Digital Trust Center and the National Cyber Security Centre.

Do you need to buy drives separately for the NAS?

It depends on the version and what the offer includes. Check the type and compatibility of the drives, and include a separate backup destination when comparing the complete storage setup.

Can a Dutch club store members’ data on a NAS?

A NAS is not in itself prohibited for storing personal data. If club files contain information about identifiable people, the GDPR applies, and the club must choose appropriate security measures based on the risks. The Dutch Data Protection Authority does not specify a single NAS model or a standard retention period.

Do you need a data processing agreement for an external cloud backup?

If a cloud provider processes personal data on behalf of the club as a processor, the Dutch Data Protection Authority says a written data processing agreement is required. First establish which services are being used and what role the provider has; this is not a requirement for every NAS setup that is entirely local.