For periodic backups of club files, a portable HDD may be a good fit if capacity matters more than fast transfers. An SSD is a more practical choice if you often take the drive with you or copy large files. First, measure the size of your current archive and decide how many previous versions you want to keep. Then check your computer’s connection and backup method. Don’t keep your only backup on a single drive, and regularly test that you can restore files, as advised by the Digital Trust Centre.
Who is this guide for?
Membership records administrator
Needs a backup that can be restored, with appropriate access controls for files containing personal data. The Digital Trust Centre advises regularly testing that backups work; the Dutch Data Protection Authority stresses that organisations must determine appropriate security measures.
Volunteer with a small desk
Looking for a drive and cable that take up little space and are easy to put away after a backup.
Administrator of a growing archive
Needs enough space for current files and backups of previous versions, without relying on speed figures alone.
What should you consider when choosing?
Portable HDD
A good fit if: you periodically copy a growing archive and put the drive away afterwards.
Bear in mind: check the cable, port and file system; it’s best not to move an HDD while it’s in use.
Portable SSD
A good fit if: you regularly take the drive with you or often transfer large files.
Bear in mind: manufacturers’ maximum figures don’t represent measured speeds on your computer. Speed may matter less when you’re making small, periodic copies of documents.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this most relevant to? |
| Recovery and security |
Check how copies are made, where a second copy is kept and whether files can be restored. If you’re handling personal data, decide who should have access. |
If I need to restore the administration files after a loss and control access to personal data, this is my top priority. Around 33% of consumers put recovery and security first. |
| Desk space |
Compare the drive’s dimensions and cable with your workspace, and check that you can safely disconnect and put the drive away after use. |
With limited desk space, I want a set-up that’s easy to put away after a backup. Around 25% of consumers prefer a compact, manageable set-up. |
| Archive capacity |
Measure your current files and decide how many previous versions you want to keep. Then choose a suitable capacity option. |
If the archive is growing, I want space for both current files and future copies. Around 25% of consumers put capacity first. |
| Connection and software |
Check your operating system, available USB port and cable, and whether you’ll need to format the drive for your backup method. |
To avoid connection or formatting issues disrupting my backup, I check that the drive and computer are compatible in advance. Around 17% of consumers put compatibility first. |
Buying and usage pitfalls
-
Keeping your only backup on a single external drive
An external drive won’t protect you from every incident at the same location. If the drive or the location fails, your backup could be lost too.
Keep a second copy somewhere else or in a different storage format, and practise restoring files.
-
Assuming a speed figure equals the speed of your backup
The maximum sequential speeds Samsung quotes for the T7 Shield are manufacturer figures. File size and your computer’s set-up also affect performance.
First, work out how much data you copy and how often. Then compare the capacity and connections that are relevant to your computer and how you’ll use the drive.
-
Formatting a drive without checking its existing contents
Apple warns that reformatting a drive with a Windows file system can permanently erase existing data.
Check the file system before setting up the drive, and save elsewhere any files you want to keep.
Brands to consider for this backup choice
Toshiba
Canvio Basics is a portable HDD range for anyone looking for storage that fits on a small desk.
- For the 2 TB version, Toshiba lists dimensions of 78 × 109 × 14 mm and power via a single USB cable.
- Toshiba says the drive is formatted as NTFS for Windows; you’ll need to reformat it to use it with macOS. First check whether it contains any files you want to keep.
Western Digital
My Passport is a portable HDD range for local backups where access protection may be useful.
- Western Digital lists password protection and hardware encryption for the range reviewed. The 2 TB version measures 107,2 × 75,0 × 13,5 mm.
- Check the full specification of the version you’re considering and how its security features are set up. A single drive is still only one backup.
Samsung
The T7 Shield is a portable SSD range for anyone who regularly moves their drive or transfers larger files.
- For the 1 TB version, Samsung quotes maximum sequential read and write speeds of 1.050 and 1.000 MB/s respectively.
- These are manufacturer figures, not measured speeds for your computer or files. Also check that the capacity suits your archive.
Seagate
Seagate Portable is a portable HDD range for copying files and making local backups.
- For the 1 TB version reviewed, Seagate lists a USB-A cable and dimensions of 117 × 80 × 14,8 mm.
- If your computer has a USB-C port, check that the connection is compatible, and review the specifications for the capacity option you choose.
Products for local backups
This selection includes portable HDDs and SSDs for local backups of club files. Before choosing a version, compare its capacity and connection with your computer and your backup needs.
Image unavailable
SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB
A portable SSD for storing files locally and taking the drive with you.
The product description lists read speeds of up to 800 MB/s, drop protection from heights of up to 2 metres and a carabiner loop.
Joybuy
Image unavailable
WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C Graphite Black
A portable HDD for keeping an archive locally. Check whether 5 TB is suitable for your files and previous versions.
The product description lists USB-C, USB 3.2 Gen 1, a 2.5-inch design and a weight of 240 g.
Joybuy
Image unavailable
WD My Passport for Mac 2TB Blue
A portable HDD for Mac backups. Check that the included connection is compatible with your computer.
The product description lists a USB-C adapter, Time Machine support, password protection with hardware encryption and pre-formatting for Mac. According to the description, the design weighs 120 g.
Joybuy
Image unavailable
WD My Passport 6TB White
A portable HDD for a larger local archive. First, work out how much space you need for your files and previous versions.
The product description lists scheduled automatic backups, password protection and 256-bit AES hardware encryption. According to the description, the 2.5-inch model weighs 210 g.
Joybuy
Image unavailable
WD Elements Portable 2TB USB-C Graphite Black
A portable HDD for local copies of documents and other files. Check whether 2 TB is enough for your archive.
The title lists USB-C and 2 TB; the product description lists USB 3.2 Gen 1.
Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
How do you work out the capacity you need for club files?
First, measure the size of the files you want to protect and decide how many previous versions you want to keep. Then choose a capacity that suits your needs.
Can a drive formatted for Windows be used straight away as a Time Machine drive?
Not necessarily. Apple says a drive with a Windows file system may need to be reformatted for Time Machine, which permanently deletes existing data. Check this before putting files on the drive.
How can you tell whether a backup is usable?
Test it regularly by restoring files. The Digital Trust Centre advises checking periodically that a backup really works; also avoid keeping all your backups in one location.
What security do you need if club files contain personal data?
The club should determine appropriate security measures based on the risks. The Dutch Data Protection Authority does not prescribe a specific brand, type of drive or standard encryption specification, so also consider who has access and how that access is managed.
What should you check about the warranty and service?
Check the terms for the specific version and whether the club is buying as a consumer or a business. The Dutch government describes the legal guarantee as a consumer right in addition to any manufacturer’s or retailer’s guarantee. Don’t assume that consumer guidance automatically applies to a business purchase.