Who is this choice relevant to?

Club with a cable route to the basement

For a club that needs reliable access for archive work and can run a network cable to a Wi-Fi point downstairs. TP-Link describes Ethernet backhaul as a connection between Deco units via Ethernet.

Club without a cable route

For a club weighing up whether a wireless midway point can still receive a usable signal, or whether a powerline kit using the club's own sockets could be an alternative. The Consumers' Association recommends placing Wi-Fi points with as few obstacles between them as possible.

Archive access manager

For anyone who needs to manage not only Wi-Fi coverage, but also which members or guests can access any personal data in the archive. The Dutch Data Protection Authority stresses that organisations must prevent unauthorised access to the personal data they process.

What should you consider when choosing?

First, work out whether the problem is with the Wi-Fi connection, the archive server or access permissions. Then choose how to connect and check that your preferred setup can accommodate the existing router and archive devices.

Concern What to check before buying Who is this important to?
Reliable connection to the basement Check whether the system supports Ethernet backhaul, how it connects in router or access point mode, and how many ports will remain free. If I can run a cable downstairs, I don't want to rely on the wireless connection between the points. Around 31% of consumers put reliable wired connections first.
Placement without a cable Test whether a potential midway location can still receive a usable connection; the Consumers' Association recommends keeping obstacles between Wi-Fi points to a minimum. If running a cable isn't possible, I need to find a spot where the wireless point itself still gets a good connection. Around 25% of consumers give wireless coverage the highest priority.
Connection over the power lines Check whether the models support powerline backhaul and test the connection using the sockets the club intends to use. If I can't run a cable, I want to know whether powerline will work with the club's sockets. Around 19% of consumers look into this as their first alternative.
Access to the archive Decide where the archive is stored, which devices need to access it, and how network and file permissions will be managed. If I want authorised members to be able to access the archive, I also need to prevent unauthorised access. Around 13% of consumers prioritise restricted archive access.
Existing router and connections Check the network mode you need, how many Ethernet ports are free, and how many points the setup requires. If I want to keep using the club router, I need to know in advance how the mesh system will work with it and which connections will remain available. Around 12% of consumers prioritise keeping their existing equipment and managing the associated running costs.

Common pitfalls

  • Putting an extra wireless point in the spot with the poorest coverage

    A mesh point needs to receive a usable connection itself. Placing one where the signal is weakest won't automatically fix a poor connection to the router.

    First, try a midway location where the signal is still usable, or compare that option with running a network cable.

    If the extra point can't get a usable connection, you may still need to run a cable or find another location.

  • Assuming all Deco models provide the same powerline backhaul

    According to TP-Link, the Deco PX50 does not provide powerline backhaul with the Deco PX10, P7 or P9. So sharing a brand name doesn't mean these models are interchangeable for this purpose.

    Before buying, check the full model names of all the points you want to use together.

  • Confusing a guest network with access permissions for the archive

    A Wi-Fi network doesn't automatically control who can open files. The Dutch Data Protection Authority reminds organisations that they must prevent unauthorised access to personal data.

    Decide separately who needs access to the network and to the archive files, then set up permissions accordingly.

  • Counting every Ethernet port as a spare port

    A port used to connect to the router or for backhaul won't also be available for an archive computer.

    Map out the connections for each point, then count how many ports will be left for devices.

    If you then need to connect another wired device, you may need a switch.

Relevant brands to consider

TP-Link

The Deco X50 is an option for Ethernet backhaul; the Deco PX50 is a separate product line with G.hn powerline.

  • TP-Link documents Ethernet backhaul and an access point mode for Deco.
  • According to TP-Link, the PX50 does not provide powerline backhaul with the PX10, P7 or P9. Be sure to check the full model combination.

FRITZ!

According to FRITZ!, the FRITZ!Mesh Set 1700 can be set up behind a FRITZ!Box or a router from another brand.

  • FRITZ! describes connecting via Wi-Fi or LAN behind a FRITZ!Box.
  • When used behind a router from another brand, a repeater in the set takes on the role of Mesh Master. Check that this setup is right for the club network.

ASUS

According to ASUS, the ZenWiFi BD4 has an access point mode and AiMesh modes.

  • ASUS's Dutch specifications page lists two 2.5 Gbit/s WAN/LAN ports per point.
  • Ports and stated Wi-Fi specifications don't prove that the connection will work through a basement floor. Also check the exact version of the set.

NETGEAR

Orbi is an option to compare by exact router and satellite model for wired or wireless backhaul.

  • NETGEAR documents both connection methods for Orbi.
  • NETGEAR recommends updating the firmware before setting up Ethernet backhaul. Check the ports and compatibility for each model.

Mesh products at Joybuy

These products are mesh Wi-Fi systems designed for setups with multiple points, where wired connections, wireless links or a guest network may be relevant. Before buying, check for the CE marking on the radio equipment being offered and make sure the product version is suitable for your chosen setup.

TP-Link Deco BE68 2-pack

TP-Link Deco BE68 2-pack

Suitable for a mesh setup where both wired and wireless backhaul are being considered.

The product description lists tri-band Wi-Fi and three WAN/LAN ports per unit.

Joybuy
ASUS ZenWiFi BT8 2-pack

ASUS ZenWiFi BT8 2-pack

An option to compare if you're looking for a mesh setup with two points.

The product title lists tri-band and Wi-Fi 7.

Joybuy
ASUS ZenWiFi BD4 2-pack

ASUS ZenWiFi BD4 2-pack

Suitable for a mesh setup where wired backhaul and a guest network are being considered.

The product title lists dual-band and Wi-Fi 7; the product description mentions an option for wired backhaul and a guest network.

Joybuy
TP-Link Deco M4 3-pack

TP-Link Deco M4 3-pack

An option to compare if you want to place several mesh points.

The product title lists dual-band and Wi-Fi 5; the product description mentions three units working together and setup via the Deco app.

Joybuy
TP-Link Deco X50 3-pack

TP-Link Deco X50 3-pack

Suitable for a mesh setup with multiple points and wired devices.

The product title lists dual-band and Wi-Fi 6. The product description mentions three gigabit Ethernet ports per Deco unit.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do you always need a mesh point in the basement?

No, not always. If you only need Wi-Fi in the basement and there's a cable connection, you can compare a single wired access point with a complete mesh kit. With wireless mesh, a point in the chosen location still needs to receive a usable connection.

Can I keep the existing club router?

That depends on the system and the network setup you want. TP-Link documents an access point mode for Deco with Ethernet backhaul, in which the main router handles DHCP, among other things, and certain Deco features are unavailable. FRITZ! also describes a setup behind routers from other brands.

How can I check whether the Deco PX50 uses powerline?

According to TP-Link, you can select the satellite point in the Deco app's network map and check the type of backhaul. Also test the connection using the sockets the club actually intends to use.

Can visitors access the archive through a guest network?

Not automatically. ASUS describes a guest network for the ZenWiFi BD4 that restricts access to the local network. Separately, decide which authorised users can open the archive and check how this works with your chosen setup.

Which Dutch product requirement should I check before buying?

Radio equipment placed on the market in the EU must meet the applicable European requirements and carry the correct CE marking. The Dutch Authority for Digital Infrastructure states that the marking must be on the equipment. Check this on the specific product being offered and its corresponding version.