Commuter looking to reduce train noise
If background noise drowns out quieter passages, compare the fit and isolation of closed-back models. ANC is another option to consider if passive isolation isn’t enough for your journey.
Start with a well-fitting closed-back studio model if you want to listen to a guitar solo repeatedly and limit sound leakage to fellow passengers. If train noise is your main concern, compare active noise cancellation (ANC) too. Also check the connection, cable length and comfort, and avoid trying to drown out noise by turning the volume up.
If background noise drowns out quieter passages, compare the fit and isolation of closed-back models. ANC is another option to consider if passive isolation isn’t enough for your journey.
If you replay short passages to distinguish the guitar from the backing, compare potential options using the same recording of your own. A stated frequency range alone won’t tell you how accurately a pair of headphones reproduces that recording.
Check the plug, your device’s output, cable length and how the headphones can be stored. Beyerdynamic says the 32-ohm version of the DT 770 PRO is suitable for portable sources; also check that it works with your own device.
| What to consider | What should you check? | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Reducing train noise | Fit and passive isolation; if you like, compare ANC using the same recording at a moderate volume. | If you want to hear quieter guitar passages without constantly turning up the volume, reducing train noise is likely your first priority. Around 36% of consumers rank this as their main concern. |
| Assessing guitar parts | Listen to the same short clip and focus on the guitar, backing and listening comfort when replaying it. | If you want to pick out notes or short riffs, you’ll want to follow the guitar part clearly without relying on specifications alone. Around 29% of consumers prioritise assessing guitar passages. |
| Connecting to your device | Check the plug, your player’s output and the cable supplied; for the DT 770 PRO, check the impedance of the exact version. | If you want to listen directly from your phone or player while travelling, the connection needs to suit your device. Around 21% of consumers make source compatibility their main consideration. |
| Comfort and maintenance | Compare the fit and check whether the exact version is foldable and has replaceable cables or ear pads. | If you often take your headphones with you or wear them for long periods, you’ll want to know how they fit and which parts can be replaced. Around 14% of consumers prioritise portability and maintenance. |
An open-back design is less obvious a choice if you want to keep train noise out and stop others from hearing your music. NS asks passengers in the quiet zone to keep the peace and not disturb others with music.
For train journeys, start by comparing closed-back models and check for any sound leakage at your usual listening volume.
The DT 770 PRO is available in versions with different impedances. Beyerdynamic distinguishes between them by source and use, and specifically recommends the 32-ohm version for portable sources.
Check the full model name and impedance, then compare them with the output of your own audio device.
Cable lengths and types vary by model. Sony lists a 3 m cable for the MDR-7506; according to Audio-Technica, the ATH-M50x comes with a 1.2 m straight cable and longer cables.
Before buying, check that the cable will work at your seat and that the plug is suitable for your audio source.
The World Health Organization points out that both sound level and listening time matter for your hearing.
First, try getting a good fit or, if it suits your needs, using noise cancellation. Keep an eye on both the volume and how long you listen for.
The closed-back ATH-M50x is worth considering if you’re looking for foldable studio headphones with detachable cables.
The closed-back DT 770 PRO and the separate DT 770 PRO X are models to compare if cable type and connectivity matter to you.
The wired MDR-7506 and the separate WH-1000XM6 offer two different options: studio monitoring and ANC for travel.
The closed-back HD 280 PRO is worth considering if foldability and replaceable ear pads are important to you.
The products below are selected for train travel and feature active noise cancellation. They haven’t been tested against each other for their suitability as a studio reference for guitar transcription.
No image available
Suited to anyone looking to reduce train noise who also wants the option of listening with a cable.
Active noise cancellation; closed-back design; 3.5 mm connection; 120 cm cable.
No image available
An option if you want to use ANC on the go and be able to fold your headphones away.
Wireless; active noise cancellation; foldable design.
Closed-back headphones are a sensible first choice if you want to reduce train noise and avoid disturbing fellow passengers. Check the model at your usual volume to see whether sound leaks out; NS’s house rules ask passengers in the quiet zone to keep the peace and not to disturb others with music anywhere on the train.
Yes, if the plug fits your phone’s output or you use a suitable adapter. According to Beyerdynamic, the 32-ohm version of the DT 770 PRO has a 3.5 mm mini-jack and is intended for portable sources; check the connection on your own device.
Don’t keep turning up the volume to drown out the train. The World Health Organization recommends well-fitting headphones and, where needed, noise cancellation. Also pay attention to both the volume and how long you listen for.
It depends on the model. Audio-Technica lists detachable cables for the ATH-M50x, while Sennheiser lists replaceable ear pads for the HD 280 PRO. Check the exact model version when buying replacement parts.
For online consumer purchases in the Netherlands, ACM ConsuWijzer says you usually have up to 14 days after delivery to change your mind, subject to exceptions. If a product is faulty, the seller is responsible for the statutory guarantee; the cooling-off period and your statutory rights if something is faulty are separate matters.