Joybuy Insights

Buying shoes without making the wrong choice: how to choose the right shoes for every activity

Buying shoes online seems simple, until you have to choose between football boots, walking shoes, trail running shoes, men’s shoes or women’s shoes. Looks alone tell you little about grip, fit or suitability. So the right choice starts not with the colour, but with the terrain, materials and size.

Three common pitfalls when buying shoes

1. Choosing a sole without considering the terrain

Football boots are not automatically suitable for every pitch. AG football boots are designed for artificial grass, with studs positioned for synthetic surfaces. According to the product description, FG football boots are intended for firm, natural grass pitches. Choose the wrong sole type and you may find the grip disappointing, while the sole could wear out more quickly.

The same applies to outdoor shoes: a deep tread isn’t necessary for every route. A sturdy hiking boot can feel heavy on the street, while a lightweight walking shoe may offer less protection on rocky trails.

2. Assuming “waterproof” means suitable for all weather

A membrane such as GORE-TEX can help keep water out and wick away moisture, according to the product information. That doesn’t mean every shoe will keep your feet completely dry in all conditions. Water could get in through the tongue, seams or top of the shoe, for example.

So always check the type of membrane, the height of the shoe and the care instructions. Waterproof walking shoes need to be dried properly. Don’t put shoes with a membrane on a radiator, as direct heat could damage the material.

3. Relying on the EU size alone

A size 43 won’t have exactly the same internal length or fit in every brand. Measure both feet at the end of the day, wearing the socks you’ll use with the shoes. Then compare your measurements with the product’s size chart.

For size 43 shoes, the stated foot length may be more important than the number itself. For the PELLIOT Hiking Boots, EU 43 corresponds to a foot length of 265 mm according to the supplied size chart. A little room around the toes is usually helpful in walking shoes, especially on longer descents.

The key specifications to check

Terrain and sole tread

Look at the combination of sole type and intended use:

  • AG studs: for artificial grass pitches; check that the manufacturer explicitly recommends them for this use.
  • FG studs: for firm natural grass, according to the product description for the Joma Propulsion Cup 2402 FG.
  • Trail tread: deep lugs are particularly useful on muddy or loose ground and mixed trails.
  • Rubber outsole: can help with grip and durability, but the tread determines how the shoe performs on a particular surface.

Don’t routinely wear football boots with plastic studs on tarmac. This can make them less comfortable to walk in and put unnecessary strain on the sole.

Fit, fastening and toe room

A well-fitting shoe holds your heel in place without pinching. With laces, you can adjust the tension for each foot. A quick-lace system can be useful for trail running or walking, but check that it stays secure while you’re moving.

Also consider the width. The Salomon Quest Tracker GTX is described in the product information as having a wide fit. That may appeal to you on long walks, but a wide shoe won’t feel equally stable on every foot.

Materials and care

Synthetic leather is often easy to wipe clean and is used in various football boots. Textile linings can affect how a shoe feels to wear. Leather men’s shoes generally need different care from lightweight outdoor shoes.

Always follow the manufacturer’s care advice:

  • remove mud with a soft brush;
  • leave shoes to dry at room temperature;
  • don’t put them in the washing machine unless this is explicitly allowed;
  • only treat a GORE-TEX model with a suitable care product;
  • store shoes somewhere dry and air them after use.

Our recommendations for different types of user

Suitable for: Budget-conscious beginners
Joma Super Copa 2402 AG SUPW2402AG 41

Joma Super Copa 2402 AG SUPW2402AG 41

Why it suits this profile: According to the product description, this model is designed for women’s football on artificial grass. The synthetic upper, lace-up fastening and regular fit make it a straightforward choice if you’re looking for your first pair of AG football boots.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The AG sole makes it clear which surface the boots are designed for, so you don’t have to choose based on colour or appearance alone.

Key benefit & features

AG sole, synthetic leather, rubber sole and a low-cut design with lace-up fastening.

Suitable for: Buyers looking for premium quality
Salomon Quest Tracker GTX L47605500 42 2/3

Salomon Quest Tracker GTX L47605500 42 2/3

Why it suits this profile: According to the product information, this taller outdoor boot is designed for multi-day routes and backpacking. Its stated GORE-TEX membrane, stable construction and wide fit make it a good match for walkers who value protection and support.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The product information identifies the membrane and its care requirements. This helps you avoid treating water resistance as unlimited protection.

Key benefit & features

High-cut design, GORE-TEX membrane, rubber sole and stable chassis construction, according to the product description.

Suitable for: Specific needs & intensive use
PELLIOT Hiking Boots for Men EU 43

PELLIOT Hiking Boots for Men Camping Travel Waterproof Durable – EU 43

Why it suits this profile: The product description focuses on trekking, camping and rougher terrain. The model has a protective toe cap, a durable synthetic upper, a treaded sole and a quick-lace system.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The size chart matches EU 43 to a foot length of 265 mm. This gives you a specific measurement to check, rather than relying on the size number alone.

Key benefit & features

Durable synthetic material, protective toe cap, treaded rubber sole and a stated water-repellent membrane.

Suitable for: Everyday wear and the office
GANT Men Footwear Boots GANT 45

GANT Men Footwear BOOTS GANT 45

Why it suits this profile: According to the product information, these men’s shoes are intended for the office, everyday wear and casual outfits. The leather outer and textile lining make them a good choice if you’re looking for a smart boot rather than a technical walking shoe.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The shoe isn’t presented as an outdoor model, making it clearer that you’ll need to weigh grip and protection against a smarter look.

Key benefit & features

Leather upper, soft textile lining and sturdy rubber sole, according to the product description.

Looking for more options?

We’ve put together a full, up-to-date list of products that meet these strict selection criteria and the current European safety regulations.

Frequently asked questions about buying shoes

How do I know what shoe size I need?

Measure both feet in millimetres while standing, then compare the longer measurement with the size chart for the specific model. Allow for sock thickness and intended use. Extra room around the toes can be comfortable in walking shoes; football boots are usually more practical with a close fit that doesn’t pinch.

Are waterproof walking shoes suitable for everyday wear?

They can be, but they’re not always necessary. A membrane can offer protection in the rain and on wet trails, while a lighter shoe is often more flexible for everyday walking. Check the ventilation, weight and height of the boot before you choose.

How long do comfortable shoes last?

Their lifespan depends on use, terrain, body weight, care and materials. Look out for worn tread, seams coming loose, a misshapen heel counter or a sole that no longer provides even support. Replace shoes based on these visible signs of wear, not just after a set period.