Which type of printer is right for you?

Club with regular colour print runs

If you regularly print multiple copies in colour, compare the purchase price, refill ink and expected usage for your own print run. The Consumers’ Association advises factoring running costs into your choice too.

Editor producing double-sided issues

If you want to print on both sides of the paper, compare the stated duplex speed and paper tray. Automatic double-sided printing and double-sided scanning are different features.

Club with occasional text-only issues

If your newsletter is mostly text and you can do without colour, a black-and-white laser printer is one option to compare. Factor in the toner and, where applicable, a separate drum when calculating running costs.

What should you look for?

Colour ink-tank printer

When: if your club regularly prints colour images or accents, compare the cost of refill ink and the purchase price based on your own print run. Epson, Canon and HP offer various A4 colour ink-tank models.

Consider: the purchase price and ink usage need to suit how often and how much you print. Running and maintenance costs vary by model.

Colour LED printer

When: if you need coloured text or illustrations, you could compare a colour LED printer such as the Brother HL-L3240CDW with an ink-tank printer.

Consider: allow for colour toner and compare the stated duplex print speed separately from the single-sided speed, as Brother specifies for this model.

Black-and-white laser printer

When: if your newsletter can be printed without colour and consists mainly of text, a monochrome laser printer such as the Brother HL-L2445DW is worth considering.

Consider: you won’t be able to print colour images. For this Brother model, include both the toner and the separate drum in your cost comparison.

The Consumers’ Association advises that the purchase price shouldn’t be your only deciding factor. Compare costs and features over the same expected period of use and print volume.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Ongoing colour costs Compare the purchase price, suitable refill ink and maintenance for the same expected print volume and period of use. Treat stated ink yields as model figures based on the conditions given. For regular colour issues, I want to know how the purchase price and refill ink work out for our print run. Around 36% of consumers say ongoing colour costs are their main concern.
Double-sided print runs Check for automatic double-sided printing, the paper tray and the stated duplex speed. A single-sided speed doesn’t tell you how quickly a double-sided issue will print. If we print multiple copies on both sides, I don’t want to keep refilling the paper tray, and I need to estimate production time accurately. Around 29% of consumers prioritise a fast double-sided print run.
Occasional black-and-white printing Decide whether you need colour and, for a black-and-white laser printer, compare the toner and any separate drum. For a club that occasionally prints mostly text and can do without colour, choosing a printer and consumables suited to its needs is a key consideration. Around 21% of consumers say occasional black-and-white printing is their main priority.
Scanning paper contributions Check whether the model has a scanner and whether its document feeder handles single-sided or double-sided originals. An ADF is not a duplex printing feature. When members send in paper contributions, I want to be able to digitise them without treating each sheet as a print job. This is the main priority for around 14% of consumers.

Common pitfalls

  • Comparing only the purchase price

    The Consumers’ Association points out that printing costs depend on how you use your printer. Comparing purchase prices alone leaves ink, toner and model-specific replacement parts out of the picture.

    Estimate your print volume over a set period and compare the relevant consumables for the models you’re considering.

  • Using single-sided speed to estimate production time

    A double-sided issue may print more slowly than the single-sided speed suggests. Brother lists separate speeds for single-sided and double-sided printing on the HL-L3240CDW.

    Compare the stated duplex speed and paper tray capacity with the number of copies you want to produce.

    Allow extra time for a print run if double-sided printing is slower than single-sided printing.

  • Assuming automatic duplex works with every type of paper

    Canon limits the stated automatic duplex function on the MAXIFY GX4050 to A4 or Letter-sized plain paper, using specific feeders. This doesn’t automatically mean the same feature works with other paper types or feeder combinations.

    Check the combination of paper size, paper type and feeder for the newsletter you want to print.

Brands as a guide

These examples relate to specific product lines. They aren’t an assessment of a brand as a whole or an indication that individual models are available.

Epson

The EcoTank ET-3950 is an A4 colour ink-tank printer with print, copy and scan functions, designed for regular colour printing.

  • Epson lists a duplex document feeder and refillable ink bottles for this model.
  • Stated yields and savings are Epson claims based on its own conditions; they won’t necessarily reflect costs for your club.

Canon

The MAXIFY GX4050 combines an A4 colour ink tank with scanning and document-feeding functions.

  • Canon specifies a cassette that holds up to 250 sheets of plain paper.
  • The stated automatic duplex function applies to A4 or Letter-sized plain paper using the specified feeders. Check the combination if you’re using other paper.

Brother

The HL-L3240CDW is a colour LED printer, while the HL-L2445DW is a black-and-white laser printer. Both are printer-only models.

  • Brother specifies automatic double-sided printing and a 250-sheet paper tray for both models.
  • The HL-L2445DW prints in black and white only; toner and drum are separate consumables for this model. For the HL-L3240CDW, factor in multiple colour toners when comparing costs.

HP

The Smart Tank 7305 is an A4 colour ink-tank printer with scanning and document-feeding functions.

  • HP lists automatic double-sided printing and a document feeder for this model.
  • The stated print speeds are HP’s specifications for this model. Compare them with your double-sided workflow and print volume.

Joybuy printers for club newsletters

This Joybuy selection includes colour printers for colour issues and a black-and-white laser printer for newsletters that don’t need colour. Check that each model’s features suit your paper, print volume and scanning needs.

Brother MFC-J6760DW A3 all-in-one inkjet printer

Brother MFC-J6760DW A3 all-in-one inkjet printer

Suited to a colour issue that needs double-sided printing and scanning.

A3 printing; automatic duplex; 50-sheet ADF; 250-sheet paper tray.

Joybuy
Epson WorkForce Pro WF-C5390DW A4 colour printer

Epson WorkForce Pro WF-C5390DW A4 colour printer

Suited to a colour issue printed over a network that needs automatic double-sided printing.

A4 colour inkjet; automatic duplex; Wi-Fi, Ethernet and Apple AirPrint.

The product information advises lifting with two people; the stated weight is over 15 kg.

Joybuy
Brother HL-L5210DW black-and-white laser printer

Brother HL-L5210DW black-and-white laser printer

Suited to a newsletter that can be printed without colour and shared over a network.

A4 monochrome laser; automatic double-sided printing; Wi-Fi and Ethernet.

This is a printer-only model with no scanner, and it prints in black and white only.

Joybuy
HP Smart Tank 7005 wireless colour printer with scanning

HP Smart Tank 7005 Wireless All-in-One Color Printer

Suited to a colour issue that needs automatic double-sided printing and scanning.

Colour ink tank; automatic double-sided printing; flatbed scanner.

The scanner is a flatbed model; there’s no automatic document feeder.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Should I count copies or printed sides?

Work out the number of copies per issue and the number of printed sides per copy, then add up the issues over the same period. Also note which pages are in colour, so you can compare paper and consumables on a like-for-like basis.

Is automatic double-sided printing the same as double-sided scanning?

No. Duplex printing prints on both sides of the paper; double-sided scanning scans originals on both sides. Check for both features separately if your club receives paper contributions.

What should I look for when it comes to installation and maintenance?

Check that the connections will work with the computer or network in your club room. Also compare the compatible ink or toner and any separate replacement parts. If the scanner has a document feeder, check whether it handles single-sided or double-sided originals.

Can we hand in our old printer when the club buys a new one?

The Dutch Government describes a take-back scheme for individuals buying a new, similar appliance; according to its information, the scheme doesn’t apply to business equipment. Check whether a purchase made on behalf of your club falls within the situation described.

What costs should I include besides the purchase price?

Compare the printer, expected paper use, compatible ink or toner and any separate parts, such as a drum, over the same period of use. Keep the proportion of colour printing and the number of double-sided prints consistent across the models you compare.