Who is this choice relevant to?

Choir administrator with a growing archive

You store finished takes, original files and project folders, and want to be able to restore them later.

Volunteer audio editor

You regularly open and edit recordings, sometimes directly from external storage.

Choir member who transfers files

You move project files between computers and want to check in advance that the connection, reading and writing work properly, and who will have access.

What should you look for when choosing?

External HDD for archiving

Best for: mainly storing finished recordings and project files, when capacity matters more than working directly from the drive.

Trade-off: an HDD is less suitable if you often work from external storage or regularly carry the drive around.

External SSD for editing and transferring

Best for: regularly editing active projects directly from the drive or taking files between locations.

Trade-off: the stated speed and portability benefits do not automatically make an SSD the obvious choice for an archive you rarely access. Actual transfer speeds also depend on your computer, port and cable.

Consideration What to look for Who this matters to
Space for original files Check the size of complete project folders and allow for future recording sessions; compare the space you need with the stated capacity. I want to keep complete takes and project folders without running out of space too soon. Around 36% of consumers give having enough archive space their top priority.
Recoverability Keep an independent copy in another location and test that you can open files from the backup. If the archive drive fails, I still want to be able to recover my recordings. Around 29% of consumers prioritise recoverable backups.
Working from the drive Check that your computer, port and cable are compatible with the drive you choose; treat maximum speeds as product specifications, not as a guaranteed speed for your setup. I regularly open and edit active projects from external storage. Around 21% of consumers give working directly with projects their top priority.
Transferring files and access Check operating systems, file system and cable; make another copy before reformatting, and decide who will have access. When sharing files between computers, I want them to work properly and access to be carefully managed. Around 14% of consumers prioritise portability and controlled access.

Common buying pitfalls

  • Mistaking the archive drive for a complete backup

    A fault, loss or other incident could also affect your only external copy.

    Keep an independent copy in another location and test that you can open an original file from it. The Netherlands’ National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping multiple versions and testing recovery.

    A second storage device or another storage location means extra upkeep.

  • Expecting an HDD and an SSD to deliver the same speed

    Speed matters most when you work directly from external storage; the trade-off is different if you only occasionally save finished recordings.

    Choose according to the way you work, and check that your computer, port and cable are compatible with the drive. Stated maximum speeds are not guaranteed for your particular setup.

  • Checking the connector or format only after buying

    Different versions can come with different cables and file systems. A drive that works on one computer may need different settings on another.

    Check the full model code, cable, computer port, and read and write compatibility. Make another copy before reformatting.

    Finding a suitable cable or moving files can take extra time.

Brands to consider

Western Digital

The My Passport range may suit you if you want a portable HDD for an archive copy and value capacity and the option to restrict access.

  • For the black 4 TB My Passport, model WDBPKJ0040BBK-WESN, Western Digital lists password protection, hardware encryption and a USB-A cable.
  • Check the connection. For writing on macOS, Western Digital lists a downloadable NTFS driver or reformatting. Security features are no substitute for an independent backup.

Toshiba

Canvio Basics is worth considering if you want a straightforward, USB-powered HDD for a local archive copy.

  • For the 4TB version, HDTB540EK3CA, Toshiba lists USB 3.2 Gen 1, an included Type-A-to-Micro-B cable and NTFS formatting for Windows.
  • Toshiba says reformatting is required for macOS. Make another copy first if the drive already contains files.

Seagate

Expansion Portable includes HDD versions for storage and file transfers; check the full model number of the version you choose.

  • Seagate Netherlands lists a 4 TB Expansion Portable model with the model number STKM4000400.
  • The product family includes different generations and connections. Check the cable supplied with the version on offer. The standard limited warranty is not the same as compensation for lost data.

Samsung

The T7 Shield range is worth considering if you often take active audio projects with you or edit directly from external storage.

  • For the black 2 TB T7 Shield in the Netherlands, model MU-PE2T0S/EU, Samsung specifies USB 3.2 Gen 2, sequential read and write speeds of up to 1.050/1.000 MB/s, and IP65.
  • These are Samsung specifications under applicable conditions of use; they do not guarantee those speeds on every computer or protect against data loss.

Joybuy products for archiving and editing

These Joybuy products include portable HDDs for local archive copies and SSDs for editing or transferring recording files.

SanDisk Portable SSD 1 TB

SanDisk Portable SSD 1 TB

A portable SSD option for storing or transferring local recording files externally.

Storage capacity: 1 TB. The product description lists drop protection from heights of up to 2 metres and a rubber attachment loop.

View at Joybuy
My Passport SSD WDBAGF0010BGY 1 TB

My Passport SSD WDBAGF0010BGY 1 TB

An external SSD option for taking local recording files with you and storing them.

Storage capacity: 1 TB. The product description lists USB-C, support for Windows and macOS, and an included USB-C cable.

View at Joybuy
My Passport for Mac 2 TB Blue

My Passport for Mac 2 TB Blue

A portable HDD option for storing project files; the product title says it is for use with Mac.

Storage capacity: 2 TB. The product description lists USB 3.0, a USB-C adapter, password protection and Time Machine backups.

View at Joybuy
My Passport 6 TB White

My Passport 6 TB White

A portable HDD option for keeping a larger local archive copy.

Storage capacity: 6 TB. The product description lists USB 3.0, password protection and hardware encryption.

View at Joybuy
My Passport USB-C 5 TB Black

My Passport USB-C 5 TB Black

A portable HDD option for storing local original files externally.

Storage capacity: 5 TB. The product title lists USB-C; the product description mentions exFAT formatting, USB power and use with Windows and Mac.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is one external drive enough to store the original takes?

No, not if you want to be able to recover files after a failure or loss. The Netherlands’ National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping multiple versions on different media, with a copy in another location; you should also test that you can open files from the backup. This is security advice, not a legal standard for choir archives.

Can I use a Windows-formatted drive straight away on a Mac?

It depends on the model, the file system and whether you only want to read files or also write to the drive. Toshiba lists NTFS formatting for Canvio Basics and says reformatting is required for macOS; for My Passport, Western Digital describes a downloadable NTFS driver for reading and writing on compatible macOS versions, or reformatting. Make a separate copy before reformatting.

Does the warranty cover lost choir recordings?

Don’t assume it does. Seagate says its standard limited warranty does not cover data loss or recovery costs, unless an applicable Rescue plan has been purchased. For consumer purchases in the Netherlands, statutory rights also apply to products that meet the required standard; the Dutch government says there is no fixed statutory warranty period. This is no substitute for backups.

Does the choir need to consider the GDPR when storing recordings?

If someone can be recognised in a recording, it may contain personal data. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says that the organisation must then identify an appropriate legal basis, choose suitable security measures and not keep personal data for longer than necessary. The right legal basis and retention period depend on the recording and its purpose; consent is not automatically the only possible legal basis.