Who is this relevant to?

Choir archivist

You store the original recording, exports and successive project folders, and want to be able to retrieve an older version. Microsoft explains how File History can restore previous versions; the National Cyber Security Centre provides general backup guidance.

Choir producer working from home

You move recording sessions around and edit them regularly, so file transfers and connection to your work computer matter. The Dutch Consumers’ Association discusses the differences between HDDs and SSDs; Samsung publishes specifications for its Portable SSD T7 Shield.

Choir file administrator

You share storage with others or keep recordings of identifiable voices, so you need to consider access and security as well as recovery. The Dutch Data Protection Authority explains when identifiable audio recordings may count as personal data and what to consider when securing them.

What should you look for when choosing?

Choose an HDD if you mainly archive finished takes and project folders; consider an SSD if you regularly transfer files, work directly from the drive or take it with you. Treat recoverability separately from speed and capacity: you’ll need version control and a separate backup for that.

Priority What to look for when buying Who this matters most to
Restoring previous project versions Check which project folders your backup method includes, and try restoring an older version. If I need to retrieve an earlier mix or session, I want to know my project folders are included in the backup. Around 25% of consumers give restoring previous versions their highest priority.
Space for takes and project folders Take stock of your complete folders and decide how many versions you want to keep; arrange your backup separately. If I keep takes, exports and several complete project folders, I want enough space for my own versioning system. Around 25% of consumers give archive space their highest priority.
Working with the computers available Check your USB port, cable, operating system and the required file format before transferring files. If I want to use the drive with the choir’s computers and backup software, I want to know in advance whether the format is suitable. Around 19% of consumers give computer compatibility their highest priority.
Transferring and carrying files Check that your computer and cable support the connection, and consider whether you’ll work directly from the drive or simply store files on it. If I often carry the drive between rehearsal and editing locations or regularly transfer sessions to it, that will influence my choice. Around 12% of consumers give working speed and portability their highest priority.
Managing access to recordings Decide who needs access and check that the specific drive and your way of working support suitable security measures. If others will have access to recordings in which choir members are identifiable, I want to know how the files will be managed and protected. Around 19% of consumers give access and privacy their highest priority.

Pitfalls when buying and using

  • Treating one large external drive as a complete archive plan

    If the drive fails, gets lost or files are overwritten, a single copy gives you no independent way to recover them.

    Plan a separate second copy and test that you can restore it before deleting the original takes.

    Reformatting can erase files already stored on the drive.

Brands worth considering

Toshiba

The Canvio Ready and Canvio Basics ranges are portable HDDs for storage and USB connectivity.

  • For the Canvio Ready, Toshiba documents a USB-powered 2 TB model supplied with a Type-A-to-Micro-B cable.
  • The documented Canvio Ready and Canvio Basics models are pre-formatted as NTFS for Windows; reformatting is required for the macOS use described.

Seagate

The Expansion Portable range offers portable HDD storage in a choice of capacities.

  • Seagate lists a 5 TB capacity and a USB 3.0 connection for the Expansion Portable model shown.
  • Seagate says the drive needs to be reformatted for use with Time Machine. A stated interface speed doesn’t determine how quickly an audio project will copy.

Samsung

The Portable SSD T7 Shield is an SSD option if you regularly transfer projects or carry the drive around.

  • For the black 2 TB model, Samsung lists USB 3.2 Gen 2, sequential speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s read and 1.000 MB/s write, and IP65.
  • These are Samsung’s specifications, not a guarantee of the same speed with every choir project. An SSD is no substitute for a second copy either.

Joybuy products for storing choir recordings

These products are external HDDs and SSDs for storing and carrying choir recordings and project folders.

My Passport for Mac external hard drive, 2 TB, blue

WD My Passport for Mac 2 TB, blue

For anyone who wants to store project folders on a Mac and use the drive for Time Machine backups.

2 TB storage; described as suitable for Time Machine and pre-formatted for Mac. The product description mentions password protection, hardware encryption, a USB-A cable and a USB-C adapter.

View at Joybuy
My Passport portable hard drive, 6 TB, white

WD My Passport 6 TB, white

For anyone who wants to store lots of complete project folders and needs the security features described.

6 TB storage; USB 3.0 connection; the product description mentions 256-bit AES hardware encryption, password protection and software for scheduled backups. Don’t shake or knock the drive while it’s running and transferring data.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable external hard drive, 2 TB, USB-C, graphite

WD Elements Portable 2 TB USB-C, graphite

For anyone looking for a portable HDD to take project files with them.

2 TB storage; USB-C connection. The product description states that it’s ready to use straight away.

View at Joybuy
Portable external SSD, 1 TB, stated read speed of up to 1.000 MB/s

Portable SSD 1 TB, 1.000 MB/s

For anyone looking for a portable SSD to carry files and transfer them regularly.

1 TB storage; USB-C and USB 3.2 Gen 2. The product description states a read speed of up to 1.000 MB/s and drop protection from up to 2 m.

View at Joybuy
WD My Passport external hard drive, 2 TB, black

WD My Passport 2 TB, black

For anyone looking for a portable HDD for project files and scheduled backups.

2 TB storage; USB 3.2 Gen 1. The product description mentions 256-bit AES hardware encryption and software for automatic backups.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How can you restore an older project version that was accidentally overwritten?

On Windows, File History can restore previous versions of the folders it backs up. If a project folder isn’t in one of the standard libraries, add it to a library if necessary, and check that your audio software’s files are included. A separate copy on the same and only drive won’t help if that drive fails.

Can an external HDD set up for Windows be used straight away as a Time Machine drive?

Not while the drive is still using a Windows file format. Apple says that Time Machine may erase and reformat this type of drive, and recommends APFS or APFS Encrypted. Set up your backup before storing the only copy of your choir files on the drive.

Does a manufacturer’s warranty replace a backup of choir recordings?

No. According to ACM ConsuWijzer, statutory warranty may, under certain conditions, entitle you to a remedy from the seller if a product is faulty, but it won’t automatically recover lost audio files. So keep a separate copy that you can restore.

Which Dutch privacy rules may apply to a choir recording?

According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, an audio recording in which someone is identifiable may count as personal data. If the choir processes this data as an organisation, it needs a valid legal basis and appropriate security measures. Consent is one possible legal basis, but not automatically the only one; what’s appropriate depends on the specific use and risks.

Does archiving a recording also mean the choir can share it publicly?

No. Storing a recording on a drive doesn’t, in itself, give you the right to publish it. Before publishing, assess separately the personal data of identifiable people and the rights to any music used. The Dutch Government distinguishes between making a copy for personal use and distributing or making it available to the public.